Casual, pirate-themed seafood eatery open seasonally, & offering a full bar. Based on 122 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 2.7 stars. Price
Address:
399 Co Rd A, Wisconsin Dells, WI 53965
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Anais Kiczula
As soon as we checked into our hotel we high tailed it over to Crabby’s and it was a fantastic start to a beautiful honeymoon.
… more
Allison Haaning
Despite the bad reviews, my family went here because it was within walking distance from our hotel. We were pleasantly surprised. The menu doesn’t have a lot of options, but everything we ordered was really good. A few of us ordered steaks cooked on hot rocks. It was a fun, unique experience, although we were a little bit concerned about the kids accidentally touching the rocks – fortunately, all left unscathed. We were a pretty large group of seven adults and four kids. We tried a lot of stuff on the menu, and there were no complaints about the food. Our only complaint was that they sat us in a back room that was secluded from the main part of the restaurant. They sat another bigger party with kids back there too, so it may be that it’s difficult for them to accommodate large parties in the main dining room or they try to keep loud little kids away from other diners. Either way, we would have preferred to be in the main dining area, which, although a bit cheesy, has pirate-themed decor.
… more
Jen Thomas
My husband and I came here for our anniversary dinner. We’d been here a couple of years ago and it was a buffet then and was not great. We were surprised to see it had changed and the menu upgraded. We had a snow crab dinner and a Black Angus steak (cooked on a hot lava rock at our table, you cook yourself). Super happy with our experience. Server Philip was awesome and the food was great! I would recommend this to anyone looking for quality dining in the Dells. As with all seafood, its a little more expensive than a burger joint but well worth it for fine dining! Our new favorite!
… more
Heather Perez
My family had a GREAT experience here. Prices were not bad. We went for dinner on a Saturday 30 minutes before closing. Total was $37. My fiance ordered the salmon (after being told they were out of chicken). I ordered a ceasar salad and our children split the popcorn shrimp kids meal. The kids had leftovers after both getting full from one meal. My fiance and I shared ours (IE, I gave him half my salad and he gave me one of his salmons). We felt that we had good food and service for a decent price. Especially after earlier in the day we felt ripped off paying the same price for a mediocre at best pizza buffet down the street.
… more
Krystal Roberts
I was very “iffy” about this place after reading reviews. However, I was very surprised! The service was very quick! We sat on the patio and were served drinks right away. My husband ordered the surf and turf on the hot plate and the steak was AMAZING! I wish I would have ordered it! I had the coconut shrimp, they were all right. Kids had crab legs and they were also very delicious. Server Mihai was very kind and did a wonderful job also! Would definitely come here again, for anything on the hot plate!!!
… more
J
After reading reviews, I judged this place way more than I should’ve. The 1lb. Of crab legs for $19.99 was seasoned and hot. Good portion of crab legs too :). Also, not overcooked at all. Service was great and our food arrived in a decent amount of time for a family of five. Corn and fries tasted a bit soggy, but it was a side, so it didn’t really bother me at all. Thanks for the family time Crabby’s :)!
… more
Juke N. Bussin
I read the bad reviews but came anyway. The food was actually decent! The appetizers were delicious and the seafood( shrimp, crab legs, etc. ) was bangin’, I mean scrumptious. The drinks were made to perfection. The server had a nice personality. What else is there to say?
… more
Nick
I assume the bad reviews are mostly attributed to service or skimpy crab legs (yes a snarky person or two but most staff are from out of town and we had a great waitress when we went) but you won’t find another restaurant like this around with hot stones and you won’t get as good of food for the money in the area. $45 for a filet mignon and lobster tail come on that’s crazy cheap!! Atmosphere is more for family so don’t go expecting some romantic ambiance but you also don’t pay for it in the price either. My rating is relative to the price paid and 1 star docked due to us expecting bigger crab legs and ambiance. This place could be better with friendlier staff, better drink selections, and nicer ambiance, but we will definitely visit again knowing we can cook our food to our own liking and have a great meal for cheap.
… more
Jim V (Timbucktwo)
First off, I thought since it being 20 dollars per person they would have a great selection of food. WOW did I think wrong! for 20 dollars you get nothing but two islands of food, and the food wasn’t even good. I could of wasted 40 bucks on me and my girlfriend at red lobster and would of been completely satisfied. We wanted to try a new place in this location and saw that it was a buffet but just horrid with the kind of food that they had. Place is nice outside but for 20 bucks I could definitely spend it else where. We asked one of the local gas station around and they recommended the place, WOW I’m not sure if we were eating at the same place, food was dry, fish was mediocre, and 10 extra bucks for crab legs?? NO thanks! Hate to say it but the chinese buffet near me had a way better selection, would of saved 20 bucks easily. And I hate their buffet!
… more
Sam Adamson
If you are going to eat here ( who would ) but they have more food in the dumpster than in the the buffet. the crab legs cost 9.99 a pound. The outdoor seating was nice but the food was horrid. We had a big party and we were seated right away so that good. But be careful what you get because excessive amounts of food left on your plate costs an extra 3 dollars so eat small portions at a time.If there is no place left and you have to eat there at least there is soft serve for your kids. I hope this helped.
… more
… View more