Looking for the best pizza in Hilliard? Rejoice, you aficionados of all things pizza pie – the seemingly endless search is finally over. From thin crust to deep dish to gluten-free options and beyond, we’ve got you covered. We at Cottage Inn Pizza pride ourselves on serving the Hilliard community with superior products using only the finest ingredients available. Not to mention, we’re always listening to our customers to provide the best possible service around. The result? Decadent, delicious, delivery-ready gourmet pizza. Located in the Hillard Square Shopping Center on Cemetery Road makes it easy to enjoy fast and fresh any time. Have a family to take care of? Grab dinner on the way home for something the entire crew will enjoy!
Long-running Midwestern chain serving deep-dish & thin-crust pizzas, plus subs, salads & more. Based on 115 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery ✔️ No dine-in
Address:
4674 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026
Phone: (614) 777-5450
Website:
Hours
| Wednesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday |
12–9 PM |
| Monday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lance Weber
Amazing pizza. Crust under the pizza is soft and pillowy, just crunchy enough on the edges. Breadsticks were, literally, the perfect blend between soft and hard. The garlic/ Parmesan crust topper is amazing, I asked for a little extra sauce/ Parmesan on the breadsticks b/c so many places give them to you dry, I like them to actually have flavor. It was all perfect! Great service, great tasting pizza. I will certainly order again! Thanks guys!
… more
Derek Torrence
Stopped in randomly last night and I’m glad we did! The staff was really nice, the pizza was top-notch and the sub was out of this world. I’ll definitely be back!
… more
Scott Jason
Honestly…hard to believe we haven’t had the pizza in the 4 1/2 years we’ve lived here. Very tasty and friendly employee I spoke to on the phone. Pizza was as advertised and with my wife being a tough critic even she was super happy.
… more
Kimberly Adams
Really nice guy at the from counter but while taking my order, I saw one of the pizza makers eat toppings out of one of the containers. That should have clued me in for bad things to come.
… more
Michael Ritchie
Ordered for the first time tonight. Awesome pizza. The sauce on the Pizza is fantastic. Great taste. We’ve lived in the area now for over a year and have tried almost every pizza shop. This is definitely a must order pizza. Hand tossed Ordered again the next night because it was so good. Got the wings along with the Pizza..Fantastic wings.
… more
Patrick Mayer
Great pizza place in Hilliard. A little pricier than your other major chains but the quality has always been great. We have some gluten free family members and they also love the GF options as well.
… more
Kyriya
Had a wonderful experience this evening dining in. Everyone greeted us as we walked in. We got two pizzas and the Innsticks. Everything was hot, fresh, and delicious. Always great food when we come here!
… more
Lance Brown
Was staying in a hotel for work. Ate their pizza twice. I spent 26 years in the pizza industry. Both pizza’s were excellent! Fast and friendly delivery! Will definitely be ordering again next time I’m there. Keep up the great work! Lots of terrible pizza out there and you guys are making it right.
… more
Julie S
I ordered a large 14×1 pizza. Received a small ? Medium? The box is 12inches. Argued with the “owners son” Joe. He absolutely refused to make this right. I will not be back. I hate being mansplained to. “Mam that’s a large” please.
… more
Ahmet Karaagac
My first order from Hilliard was because i eat downtown location alot i give it try and it was great. On monday around 4pm. Second time today on Thursday at 5 which I took picture was the worst pizza ever. i had to eat because didnt have time to reorder. Burned, no parmesan butter on the crust. Just plain terrible. I cant believe i paid $31 for this sh..
… more
… View more
