Takeout ONLY– NO DELIVERY: Cosentino Pizzeria, located in the heart of Rootstown Ohio, offers stone oven baked pizzas, subs, fresh salads and other authentic Italian cuisine which is made fresh from scratch daily. Our famous family Italian sauce recipe delivers a unique and extraordinary flavor sure to please. Also serving the areas best premium soft serve ice cream. Check out our popular catering menu for your next event. Takeout ONLY– NO DELIVERY
Based on 78 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No dine-in ✔️ No delivery
Address:
4139 Tallmadge Rd, Rootstown, OH 44272
Phone: (330) 850-5055
Website: https://www.cosentinorestaurants.com/
Hours
| Wednesday |
4–9 PM |
| Thursday |
4–9 PM |
| Friday |
4–9 PM |
| Saturday |
4–9 PM |
| Sunday |
4–8 PM |
| Monday |
Closed |
| Tuesday |
4–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Taylor Woodall
We absolutely love Consentinos! We used to rotate through a couple different pizza places before finding this place. Not anymore, it’s the gold standard! I won’t eat pizza from anywhere else. We have tried many of the specialty pizzas and all are delicious but we always get the classic CAPRESE – it’s perfect every time! We love their spaghetti too, the sauce is to die for!!
… more
Kara R
Ordered a medium eggplant/fresh mozzarella with white sauce, Italian wings & cannoli…some of the best cannoli I have ever had, just the right amount of sweetness! The wings were amazing and pizza as well with the perfect crispy crust, even my picky eater devoured it!! Staff was super friendly and an all around good atmosphere. Definitely a new favorite spot!
… more
Mic-Nog
Great Real Italian foods!! Even Italian desserts!! Oh my very authentic Italian restaurants !! A must !!
… more
Todd Kortright eXp Realty Guy
I love Cosentino’s! Stromboli is on point. Italian Wings YUM! Subs amazing. The one that keeps me up at night thinking about though is the Bolognese pizza!! Pepperoni and Meatballs!!! OMG. Homemade goodness you can taste it. Thank you Cosentiono’s.
… more
Steve S.
Very good thin crust pizza at very reasonable prices. So far we’ve only had pizza and salad and both have been great. One caveat, the website says dine-in but there is not.
… more
Gio
We took a little road trip from North Canton for dinner because the food looked so appealing online and we were really happy that we did! The food was fantastic! The pasta was delicious! The cheese pizza was scrumptious! And the caprese pizza was just top notch!! The lady who I believe to be the owner was just so nice and sweet and had her hands full with business but worked to fit in our order. Definitely check this place out! I know we will be back in the near future.
… more
Joseph Engelhart
Wanted to give them a try but nobody was answering the phone. I called a couple more times and even HEARD the employee pick the phone up and set it down then walk away. I am so beyond appalled by the service I experienced AND I DIDN’T EVEN GET TO EAT ANYTHING! I would leave a zero star review if I could.
… more
Felicia Reed
Pizza was hot, wings were perfect. 10/10, will order again. Got a deluxe, I don’t usually like sausage but it was so good I didn’t even bother picking it off. The peppers were amazing, mushrooms were huge. Definitely recommend this place.
… more
Don Kurkey
Excellent pizza not made on a conveyer belt like most other places
… more
Lisa Smith
BEST PIZZA N SPAGHETTI IVE HAD IN LONG TIME
… more
… View more
