Cordell Steakhouse Menu – Salem, OH

Type : Restaurant

Location : Salem, OH

Based on 40 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price

Cordell Steakhouse 44460

Address:
333 W 4th St, Salem, OH 44460

Phone: (234) 575-0226

Website:

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Ron C
We weren’t sure what to expect, but were hoping for a better experience than what we had. The dining experience gave us the feeling that we were in a banquet hall, not the “classic steakhouse” experience we read about online. The menu was easy and simple to follow, but the pricing was something you see in downtown Pittsburgh, not Salem. $26 for a regular cut of Prime Rib and $50 for a “king cut” seems a bit pricey for this area. We ordered the Prime Rib medium-rare and it came out well done and tasted like roast beef. The other steak we ordered was a NY Strip. It wasn’t bad, but not worth $17. The salads weren’t anything special and the ranch dressing wasn’t good. The sides of rice pilaf we ordered were bland. We have been to A LOT of different steakhouses over the years and this by far was not worth the $47 price tag for 2. For the benefit of Salem we hope it gets better, but unfortunately we won’t be back to try it.

… more

Joseph Caporale
Wednesday $5 Burgers and fresh cut fries was well worth the drive

… more

Rick Kamperman
Appetizers were ok (fried mushrooms bland, calamari good, cheese sticks good) service is slow but very nice. Steak was thin and bland. Kids loved the cheeseburgers. Salad was…sad.

… more

Anna Vietmeier
Worst meal ever. When we walked in the girl pointed us to a booth and didn’t seat us. The waitress was rude and condescending. The menu was overpriced. The alcoholic drinks were not made well. They were out of burger and out of thousand island dressing. The restaurant was not welcoming to sit in. Wires were hanging from ceiling fans and out the wall. There was 3 of us in our party and they gave us only 2 menus and 2 sets of silverware to start. My 24 dollar 8 Oz Filet Migon did not look like an 8 oz. It was suppose to be medium rare and instead was still raw in the center. I returned it back to the kitchen. They cut my filet Migon in half in the kitchen to finish cooking it!! It was still overly rareally by the way. The steak was not seasoned. The gravy on the potatoes was salty. I will NEVER go back to that restaurant.

… more

Dominic McGhee
Service was sooooo slow, we were there for an hour and 45 minutes but only really wanted to be there around an hour. Everything took forever! I ordered prime rib and it was cooked as I asked but had no flavor, very bland. No draft beer, only bottles. I hope it survives but I wouldn’t get money on it

… more

Linda Wiland
The pork chops were very good as was the steak salad. The service was prompt and friendly. There are booths and tables. It would be easy to accommodate large parties. Nice bar.

… more

Brook Scott
Well if anyone thinks 3 small strips of onion on a burger is worth the trip,I’m glad I drove less than a mile.$5 is less than McDonald’s and BKing is better.

… more

Vernon Isaacs
I had a very good meal. My steak was big. And done the way I wanted it. Nice sized baked potato. A very good dinner

… more

Russell Pugh
It is pretty good, they have the coldest, crispiest salad ever. The food was reasonabley priced, but the spaghetti sauce was chunky and it was very runny.

… more

J hark
Food was pretty good. The decor could use some work. If it was busy it would get very loud.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions