Modest storefront featuring a wide variety of Italian dishes along with draft beers & cocktails. Based on 267 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
Address:
415 Spring St, Jeffersonville, IN 47130
Phone: (812) 285-1777
Website: https://www.facebook.com/Come-Back-Inn-116193961734397/
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lourdes Laysan
I ordered Chicken Parmigiana, got a wonderful plate of yum :). Breadsticks could use some work, but above average for all the competition.
… more
Alicia Mosley-Rives
So delicious! The pita chips and cheese appetizer was so awesome. We also had the best Spinach Ricotta Pizza ever! It was a perfect meal!!
… more
Andrew DeGruccio
Friendly dining. Good Italian fare. Price is right.
… more
Robert Polk
This is my wife and my go to place quite often. It’s always wonderful food and really good service. Two of our favorite dishes are specials one being the seafood lasagna that they had last night and the duck pasta. Only wish they had those two specials more often but everything is really good. Also love their crab cakes.
… more
Kendall Browning
Service was great. The waitress brought plenty of refills and was polite and fun. Could use a little more marinade with the breadsticks that aren’t free and the garlic sauce was a bit oily with the minced parts settled at the bottom that is hard to get to. Servings were large and had enough to eat again later when we got home. Food was great if you like Italian and prices were slightly high, but most of the places in that area price up for the atmosphere. Plus I would imagine they have to pay higher property taxes or leases.
… more
Jeff Jarecki
Love this place. Weird hours/days, but easily worth the wait! Get the Steak-Gorgonzola Salad, I order mine with chicken instead of steak and it’s fantastic! Service is great, prices are reasonable. The ambiance isn’t the best, but the food and service makes up for it.
… more
Dusty Firebird
Awesome experience. I’m not one to send food back but I misunderstood the menu and it was taken care of very quickly. Trisha was our server and made sure our meal was perfect. Our glasses remained filled and she was attentive to our needs. We had pasta (gongolla?) and it was delicious. Large enough portions for lunch tomorrow! Highly recommend and will be back.
… more
Suzanne Severs
food was good. service was good. wine was very good. But when I pay 30.00 for a bottle of wine and my bill comes to 62.60 I would like glass glasses for my water and a decent size napkin. They had very small paper napkins and a dispenser on the table. Also, the table rocked every time you leaned on it
… more
Ce Garrison
I’m going to be very honest. I heard wonderful things about this place. We came for our early Valentine’s Day dinner. I got the bolognese, and my partner got the ravioli. I haven’t been so disappointed in a meal in a long time. The building is quaint, the service was decent, but the food wasn’t palatable. My partner sent his food back, but I usually find it hard to send things back when I order them. I had high hopes based off personal recommendations and Google reviewers, but this will not be added to the list of restaurants that I come back to.
… more
Sydney Sleadd
Not even ashamed to say I come here on my lunch break once a week, every week. I’ve experimented with different items, but I usually get a cup of the chicken tortellini soup (sooo good) and the wild mushroom basil pesto pasta with chicken added. Service is always wonderful, food comes out quick, and the atmosphere is great. Love this place! Even on busy days I’m in and out in 30-40 minutes tops, which is great when you only have an hour for lunch! be prepared to get a to go box though….portions are huge and the prices are very low for what you get.
… more
… View more