Based on 189 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1226 Harrisburg Pike, Lancaster, PA 17603
Phone: (717) 393-5577
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Stephen Young
We love this place very much. It did have a change of owners and employees, but they are still great and kept things how they were for the most part and added a lot more to the menu. They did make some small changes to make things even better. We do miss the old staff but the new owner and staff are very nice and hardworking and we like them a lot. This place makes the best pizza in Lancaster County, strombolis are pretty good, and so are the subs. Just wish they would drop the Pepsi products for Coke products. The prices are reasonable and usually better than anywhere else. My entire family has been coming here for years. We are never disappointed. The only negative thing I could say is that their dining room could use a remodel. But we usually get takeout/delivery. We go out to many different pizza places almost every Friday night, but most of the time, we end up just getting Columbos if we can’t all agree on a new place. We also love Rosa Rosa and Two Cousins on Columbia Ave near Tobias Frog. Thanks for the years of great food and service, and I will probably keep coming till I’m 6 ft under.
… more
Mincciblurr Koala
unlike most pizza places the ingredients here are high quality, and taste fresh! great experience
… more
Carmen Amaro
Columboli’s have been to Utah, New York, Philadelphia, Puerto Rico… where ever my son has been stationed there they have been. Never a bad experience and the staff if beyond awesome. Now I’m on a cheesesteak kick and OMG they are the best!!!
… more
Kyle Conaty
I can honestly say, I’ve never been disappointed! We order all the time from pizza shops in Lancaster and Columbos is one we always end up going back to. Prices are great, delivery time estimates are almost always dead on and the food is great! What more could you ask for?
… more
Sandra Mays
Just had my first Columbo’s Pizza but it won’t be my last! That was delicious! Thanks for showing up on DoorDash!
… more
Amanda Sperduto
Ordered a $16 small veggie pizza and the crust is still raw! It’s stuck to the box.I added a photo in the pictures part.
… more
Sandra Kurtz
Quality is declining fast, Last Columboli was very disappointing. Very little meat in it, not much mustard…they didn’t put in extra side of sauce, which I probably paid for. Very sad after 20+ years of Great food and service, to see this happening to what was my favorite place
… more
Tmart Pc
Great food! Pizza is always my go to. But the small Stromboli is perfect size and so delicious. Can’t beat the price!
… more
James Renz
DO NOT EAT HERE!! I ordered a meat Stromboli and it had plastic inside of the boli, which ended breaking a tooth. I talked to whoever was in charge and they refused to accept responsibility for it. Worst dining experience I’ve ever had. Never using them again. Tell your friends.
… more
Garrett Alder
The worst pizza place ever they tried to not deliver my pizzas after I paid with credit card! I argued for 3 hours then got it delivered cold and burnt. It reminded me of a frozen pizza from Walmart just bland and plain. You can’t make this stuff up! I have tried almost every pizza place in Lancaster and this is the worse by far. I found out they have had 3 write ups for cleanliness in the last few yrs. nightmare of a place!
… more
… View more