Storied, family-run, dockside eatery with area-sourced seafood dishes, a sushi bar & a rooftop deck. Based on 342 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ No takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
470 W Lake Dr, Montauk, NY 11954
Phone: (631) 668-6252
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 5–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 5–10 PM |
| Thursday | 5–10 PM |
| Friday | 5–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday | 5–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Anthony Falsetta
What an excellent place to dine before a day of fishing off Montauk Point! Oyster’s & Clams couln’t be any fresher! And whatever the seared scallop dish was, off the charts! Been coming here for 30+ years.
… more
Seagull Shore
the first time we went to salivars we had a great experience- amazing service, atmosphere, and lobsters! We made sure to come back this summer- except after this time we left with no intentions of coming back. Very disappointed with the pina colada i had been dreaming about!! It came tasting like ice. I had my bf try it and he confirmed yes, it was terrible. We asked the server if she could have the bartender add more colada mix (didn’t even want more alcohol!) into it to make it taste like an actually pina colada to which she returned and said “yea she said that’s our recipe for it” and left the drink on the table. As a server and bartender ourselves, we were not impressed that was the “solution” when it was easily fixable. The pictures are from the pina colada I got last summer compared to the one i’m talking about this summer… i think it speaks for itself. There was also a lack of knowledge about the menu when we asked if the brownie dessert was still gf our server said “oh i don’t know” to which we had to push for her to find out. We had another server come and ask how everything was about two inches from my boyfriends face, i thought he was tryna steal a kiss. Strange experience this time around.
… more
manuel verzosa
Amazing seafood restaurant located in Montauk. Sarah was our server. Very friendly and personable. She answered all our questions and was very patient with us. My wife had the frogmore stew. I had the tilefish. We also had oysters and clams. If you like seafood this is one if not the best. I met Phil. He is one of the owners. . Also very nice.. another person we met was Tanner. He had a fresh catch of lobsters in a basket and let us hold a lobster. You need to go here. Highly recommend.
… more
edward c
The clam chowder was good the wings were good too,but the beet salad didn’t have any beets , we were so hungry by the time the food came that we had it without the beets. We complained to the waitress about but nothing was done about it and they still charged us full price for it and no one came over to apologize or make amends.
… more
Thomas Cheung
As a lover of good food and a seeker of dining experiences, I’ve journeyed far and wide, from the bright lights of the city to the tranquil coastline, in pursuit of culinary delights. Last night, that quest led us to a restaurant in Montauk that turned out to be such a treat.
… more
Brandon Lopez
Do yourself a favor and skip this joint. Go to the others around it. Rudest host in the world. We got a table and then had three more join. They said they “could not accommodate us” for another table. They have three tables open around us. Check my photos. I had remind the waiter that he was our waiter. I miss the old owners. Everyone surrounding me is mad and not having a good time.
… more
Sal Verdi
Stopped by this gem of dinner . Just Wow amazing.. everything was so fresh . Live music and fresh seafood is exactly the vibe you are goin for in Montauk .. highly recommended
… more
Paul P
Had the top deck to ourselves. Great music, great servers. We came for the delicious Fish Parmigiana and it did not disappointa. Had a few planes take off from the nearby airport and they went right over us which was pretty cool.
… more
Nancy Zhang
Excellent fresh fish and casual seaside atmosphere. If you’ve got a group, I recommend calling ahead for a reservation. It would save you a long wait time.
… more
Julie Bienvenue
Perfect stop on holiday lunch in Montauk
… more
… View more