Cinco de Mayo Menu – New York, NY

Type : Mexican restaurant

Location : New York, NY

Based on 44 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Cinco de Mayo 10017

Address:
153 E 43rd St, New York, NY 10017

Phone: (212) 682-2197

Website:

Hours

Tuesday 10 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 10 AM–9 PM
Thursday 10 AM–10 PM
Friday 10 AM–10 PM
Saturday 12–10 PM
Sunday 12–9 PM
Monday 10 AM–9 PM

Menu

ALL NEW: Tacos
3 Tacos: (Choose Your Protein)
Tortilla choice:
1. Soft Corn
2. Soft Flour
3. Hard Corn

Protein choice

Topping choice:
1. Cilantro & onions
2. Lettuce, tomato & cheese

$14.00
Single Taco (1)
Tortilla choice:
1. Soft Corn
2. Soft Flour
3. Hard Corn

Protein choice

Topping choice:
1. Cilantro & onions
2. Lettuce, tomato & cheese

$4.45
Birria Tacos (3)
6″ INCHES CORN TORTILLA CHOPPED BIRRIA, MUENSTER CHEESE, ONION, CILANTRO AND BIRRIA SAUCE ON SIDE.
$17.10
*ALL NEW: Mexican Style Burritos
Mexican Style Burrito: (Choose Your Protein)
Mexican rice, lettuce, beans, cheese, sour cream & pico de gallo
(Birria burrito tortillas are dipped in birria sauce)
$12.85
ALL NEW: Quesadillas
Quesadillas (Choose Your Protein)
Melted cheese, Pico de Gallo, sour cream with a side of tomatillo avocado salsa

Tortilla choice:
1. Flour
2. Whole wheat

$14.00
Quesabirria
Birria Quesadilla, Flour tortilla, served with pico de gallo, corn, sour cream & salsa verde
$17.45
Cheese Quesadilla
Melted cheese, Pico de Gallo, sour cream with a side of tomatillo avocado salsa

Tortilla choice:
1. Flour
2. Whole wheat

$9.35
Piñata Quesadilla
Melted cheese with cucumbers, pickled jalapeños, black beans, onions & cilantro *inside*. Served with pico de gallo, sour cream and lettuce.
$12.95
ALL NEW: Nachos
Nachos: (Choose Your Protein)
Corn tortilla chips, beans, melted cheese, sour cream, jalapenos & tomato
$10.75
Mixed Nachos
Corn tortilla chips, beans, melted cheese, sour cream, jalapenos & tomato
$18.35
*ALL NEW: Mexican Salad Bowl
Soft Or Hard Taco Salad: (Choose Your Protein)
Soft shell taco, lettuce, tomato, beans, guacamole, cotija cheese & sour cream
$15.65
*ALL NEW: All Types of Mexican Bowls
Veggie Mix Bowl (Vegetarian)
Beans over brown rice topped with guacamole & pico de gallo
$12.40
Finest Bowl (Triple Protein)
Mexican rice, beans, with chicken, steak & carnitas sautéed with Pico de gallo
$16.00
Gym Bowl
Made with; Brown rice, beans, Pico de Gallo & grilled chicken breast topped with guacamole
$15.85
Burrito Bowls (Choose Your Protein)
Made with; Mexican rice, pinto beans, cheese, sour cream, pico de gallo & lettuce.
$12.85
Chicken Enchiladas Suizas
3 rolled up tortillas with tomatillo sauce, lettuce, sour cream, tomato, onions & melted cheese on top served with rice & beans
$16.35
PD Finest Bowl
Mexican rice, beans with chicken, steak, carnitas, sautéed with pico de gallo.
$15.65
Cinco De Mayo Plate
Grilled chicken, pinto beans, pico de gallo, salsa verde, muenster cheese, yellow rice & guacamole.
$18.55
Beverages
Bottled Water $2.30
Jarritos (Mexican Soda) $3.45
Soda Can $2.30
Mexican Coke $4.45
Power Plates
Gym Bowl
Brown rice, beans, pico de gallo & grilled chicken breast topped with guacamole
$15.85
*ALL NEW: Catering Mexican Side Orders
Guacamole & Chips (Catering)
Per 10 People
$42.15
Salsa & Chips (Catering)
Per 10 People
$31.90
Tray Of Beans (Catering)
Per 10 People
$22.75
Tray Of Chips (Catering)
Per 10 People
$17.05
Tray Of Rice (Catering)
Per 10 People
$28.45
*ALL NEW: Mexican Side Orders
Side Of Beans $4.60
Side Of Chips $2.30
Side Of Chips & Guacamole SM (4oz) $6.10
Side Of Chips & Pico SM (4oz) $4.85
Side Of Guacamole SM (4oz) $4.60
Side Of Rice $4.60
Side Of Rice & Beans $6.35
Side Of Salsa & Chips $4.75
Side Of Sour Cream $1.40

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Cindy Chiu
Delicious, authentic tacos al pastor. Reasonably priced at 3 for $12. Takeout only but there are some chairs and tables across the street, so you can enjoy the made-to-order tacos while they’re fresh and hot.

… more

Rachel
If you are a Texan and are used to great Tex Mex or Mexican food, simply do not even think about ordering from here. The burritos are mostly rice (bland rice), the salsa has sugar in it…. It’s SWEET sweet. The meat has no spices on it whatsoever. This was legitimately the worst Mexican food I’ve had anywhere in three decades.

… more

Agostino Pini
This is a great place for some comfort food. A hidden gem where you can have a great meal without overpaying for it. I had the birria tacos and I loved them. If come here for the gram, maybe this is not your spot but if you are looking for something authentic, stop and try it. There is no place to sit so this is something you should keep in mind. However, two blocks away there is a beautiful park with tables and chair where you can enjoy your tacos.

… more

Greyson Bushman
I didn’t know the phrase “hole in the wall” could be a literal expression until I ate here. As we were in line, another patron (who had already ordered I might add) tried to warn us away. He was very disappointed when we did not take his recommendation and continued to order anyway, now with more worry in our hearts than ever before. Since there was no seating, we went back to our hotel to eat. The food was a surprisingly good size and they did not skimp. We dug in with conviction. To be 100% honest I was terrified this food would give us the shits—the kind that flows through you like lava. But it didn’t! Which was good because there were 6 of us sharing 1 tiny bathroom. The food itself was actually really good. I personally enjoyed the chicken burrito. Quite a scrumptious flavor. Overall a shockingly good experience with a tiny New York restaurant.

… more

vivian piccone jung
Super nice service. I got Three different tacos; chicken, pork, steak. I got all the toppings that were offered. And three different sauces. Everything was delicious. Price is good. And they were super courteous.

… more

Krishin Asnani
A hole in the wall that is a needle in the haystack ; it’s place where servings are generous, the service is warm; the husband wife team are from Ecuador and they are so easy to converse with ; they modify the order per your taste; their vegetarian burrito , vegetarian tacos and nacho bowl are fresh and flavorful and come with lemon wedges; Love the spicy red sauce and flavorful green sauce.

… more

Blake Kelton Prentiss
My order:

… more

Sara Ash
Our first night in NYC, my family and I found this place around the corner from our hotel room. I got the birria tacos and they were amazing! I haven’t been able to find anything that compares where I live. 10/10 definitely recommend the birria tacos!

… more

Kate Shepard
Steak was too salty, I’m a Los Taco (136th Church St. Or 214 W. 43rd) fan & this place can not compare to Los Taco…total waste of $15 for 3 tacos & they charge extra $2 for guacamole which is crazy b/c Los Taco gives free guacamole & unlimited toppings. Worst part is they cook the steak BUT Los Taco Grill the steak. This pace advertise street taco but it’s far from street taco. Lesson learned never cheat on Los Taco again!! Stomach hurts & im heading to the toilet to release this mess.

… more

Dhruv
The food was mid at best and tasted like every Mexican restaurant. Also the atmosphere was really dull but the service was nice and staff was kind.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions