Based on 23 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price
Address:
600 E 2nd St, Dayton, OH 45402
Phone: (336) 529-8418
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Joe Cararie
I got the Kiwi Classic and loved it. I’m confident you couldn’t go wrong with any menu selection here! Located within the charming 2nd Street Market, this was an amazing find while on vacation in Dayton!
… more
Keith Owen
Was passing through Dayton for bussiness. Stopped by the Farmers Market to kill some time. Passed by the Cheeky Meat Pies booth and Riley was putting some in the oven. I stopped back by a little later, just as they were coming out. AWESOME! If you looked up “comfort food” in an illustrated dictionary… there would be a picture of Riley’s meat pies. Just wish I could have figured out how to get some on the plane and back to Oklahoma.
… more
Josh Lang
This is really late from our visit, I think it was a year ago or so, but we thought about coming again today and I remembered how disappointed that visit compared to 5 or 6 years ago when we went fairly regularly.
… more
Andrew Via
I wish I had seen the review from Jeff below. I saw the Cheeky stand and thought I’d surprise the wife with some Tandoor Chook pies like she used to love years ago. They were not like years ago. It was hard to describe — just off. Spiced differently and not in a good way. If you’re going to buy the business, you’d think you’d get the recipes too. Just really strange and not what we were expecting. I still gave 2 stars because they are edible.
… more
Tanner Michels
I think these meat pies are delicious! I buy two almost every Saturday morning! The dough is made by scratch every day they’re open by the owner and all the filling is made from scratch. The owner has great customer service and is always polite. It’s my favorite part of 2nd Street Market!
… more
Levi For Waifu
Have not been open on June 4 and June 11, 2022. A shame since it’s why I come to 2nd street markets.
… more
Charlie Calhoun
During my bicycle tour in NZ I ate Georgie pies almost everyday. When I came back home I found myself missing the delicious meat pie almost as much as missed Skyline while abroad.
… more
Zach Hittle
I happened to stumble upon these guys here on Google and let me tell you, most definitely worth a visit to 2nd Street Market! Many flavor options and they are sooooooo good!!!! Great atmosphere and delicious food! Please sir, take all my money!
… more
Jeff Seedes
Under new ownership and they have changed the recipes. Fortunately I had the chance to enjoy the place before it changed. Dont waste your money at $6 each its not worth it at all. I can say that the Tandori Chicken Pie was tasteless and not the same as the original.
… more
Lindsey Davidson
Ordered some frozen pies but lost the heating instructions. They were quick to reply and the pies were just as good as I remembered from the market! Thanks for still being there for us during COVID!
… more
… View more