Based on 250 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
213 NJ-37 Suite 3, Toms River, NJ 08753
Phone: (732) 281-8259
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Samantha DeRose
The food here is REALLY good. This is the second time I’ve ordered the Lamb Chops from Cathy’s and they are easily the best Lamb Chops around! The meat is always cooked perfectly & the broccoli rabe has so much flavor. Much better than we even expected. Make sure you add Cathy’s on your regular rotation when you are in the mood for authentic Italian food.
Brandon Chiappetta
The food was pretty good. But the server was horrible. “Laren” we seen her one time. I was I could of just tip the guys with the long hair. Everything was good but the mussels. The clams and beans needs more spicy.
Frank Vulpis
What great food and service for the entire family. BYOB and large great tasting portions. We’ll be heading back!
PJ Pops
I’m from out of state. Get the chicken Parmesan, you won’t regret it. The biggest piece of chicken I have ever seen, super juicy and plump. The chicken alone filled the plate. I recommend
Lorie Susan
Always a delicious meal and Joe Leo on Friday nights makes a great night! Eduardo is usually our waiter and always does an amazing job!
CaptainMark RedAngel
My family has been there many times and each time we had consistently great dishes. Both the specials and regular menu offerings keep us coming back for more. Highly recommended by my whole family!
Maria A
So incredibly delicious!!! From start to finish we couldn’t stop talking about how much we enjoyed everything. A few stand out favorites were the shrimp and calamari, mussels, rack of lamb, chicken savoy.. YUMMMM. Prices were cheap and the portions are huge. They even brought us free dessert to end the night (which convinced us to take pastries home with us ) A great and much needed addition to TR- we’re already looking forward to our next visit!
Coconuts Tropics
Hidden away in an ugly strip center. Big restaurant but garishly decorated and with way too loud music playing constantly. Unfortunately one of those restaurants that charges 3% to use a credit card. Food was pretty good though. Huge portions served hot. Excellent bread. House salad included with most entrees. Reasonable prices. Very good service. Nightly specials. BYOB
Doreen alexander
Wonderful sorta hidden spot. The staff were the friendliest and most helpful we have ever encountered. Large portions of delicious food. The rack of lamb is a must! Great cappuccino though a bit strong for me; I asked for some milk to make it less strong. They brought me heated milk. WOW! We wanted a little something sweet after dinner so ordered half a pound of cookies. Great choice and we had the rest to take home.
Denise Rutilio
Tried this Restaurant on the recommendation of our friend. Byob food was great big portions. Staff was very attentive and friendly! They do take reservations. They also have an attached bakery with lots of choices made on the premises! They told us they have a Pastry Chef! If you want dessert after your meal you walk over to the bakery side ( it’s attached no need to go outside) tell them what you would like you go back to your table and they bring it to you. The bakery is also open if you just want to go in and by desserts or breads to go! Will definately be going back!
… View more