Castaways has been serving incredible food to the fine people of Lancaster, Ohio for over 70 years. We cook up all of your favorite meals: from pizza and hamburgers to steak and fresh oysters, we have something for every taste. Enjoy our cozy little space with patio seating that looks out to our forest surroundings for a casual evening of good food, good friends, and a beautiful view. We also have space for parties and corporate lunches, so feel free to bring a crowd. We can’t wait to see you here!
Based on 331 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
1500 N High St, Lancaster, OH 43130
Phone: (740) 654-9197
Website: https://www.castawayslancaster.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday |
4–8:30 PM |
| Thursday |
4–8:30 PM |
| Friday |
4–9:30 PM |
| Saturday |
4–9:30 PM |
| Sunday |
Closed |
| Monday |
Closed |
| Tuesday |
4–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kevin Montgomery
My wife and I stumbled upon this place as we were driving through the area. Now I’ll warn you, it is off the beaten path and just when you’re about to give up and turn around, just keep going haha!
… more
PS V
First time I’ve ever been. Best steaks I’ve ever had. Whenever I’m hungry for a steak that’s where I’ll be going.
… more
Cindy Wolfinger
I hadn’t been here for quite some time. I was disappointed with the food before and found it wasn’t any better than the last time. The salad was just a bed of greens that was old and wilted, no other veggies added at all. The fries were crinkle cut out of a bag and undercooked…and the fried jumbo shrimp was just mediocre. I don’t plan on going back again.
… more
Melissa Thompson
This was our first visit here. We ordered their potato skins for an appetizer I had their surf & turf (ribeye & lobster tail). My husband had their sirloin with mushrooms. Steaks were cooked perfectly, and the appetizer and sides were all delicious. Service was amazing! Highly recommend this place.
… more
Susan Dilimone
Not good at all. Went due to online reviews. Must have been family an friends. Service was subpar. Filet mignon was not even the correct cut of meat and my companion had another steak dish served with expired A1 sauce that tasted awful. We will not go back. The table nearest us was loud drunks that were clearly friends of the wait staff. Avoid if possible.
… more
Gary Wassmuth
We we’re recommend to come to the restaurant because we were in the area. I have to say we have never had a meal this bad anywhere. Maybe they had a bad night! The porterhouse steaks we got were below sub par. The place was busy so someone must see something in this restaurant. Sorry for the bad reviews.
… more
Tracy Colegrove
Perfect. I have never eaten here before, ordered and took home. Still great! Everything was fresh, and the salad dressing was amazing. Definitely will be returning
… more
Adam Hampson
Great family restaurant. Reminds me of when times were better. Steaks are really good and burgers. Comes straight from the butcher. Good food no matter what you order. Only wish they still delivered.
… more
Lexy Jane
Love this place! Came up with my boyfriend over the weekend and we more than impressed. It was just the two of us and everything was so nice and came out so fast. After reading a few of these reviews(only when looking up the address) I just don’t understand how they could not like it! This place was not outdated at all and they were very busy and we indeed did have to wait for them to clean up some tables but that’s to be expected if we didn’t want to sit at a dirty one. Everyone was pleasant and attentive even this they were super busy. We will definitely be back!
… more
chris swain
Amazing food, attentive staff!!! Very quick service!!!!! Will return every time in town!!!!
… more
… View more
