Your New Glarus, WI Casey’s at 1019 State Hwy 69 has the best pizza featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and only the freshest pizza toppings. We’ve also got appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and a variety of household essentials and groceries. When you’re stopping by, you can even fill up your gas tank with quality fuels – Whatever you need, Casey’s is here to help.
Convenience-store chain offering fuel, drinks & food, including pizza, sandwiches & baked goods. Based on 62 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No dine-in ✔️ No delivery
Address:
1019 WI-69, New Glarus, WI 53574
Phone: (608) 453-4834
Website:
Hours
Thursday |
5 AM–10 PM |
Friday |
5 AM–10 PM |
Saturday |
5 AM–10 PM |
Sunday |
5 AM–10 PM |
Monday |
5 AM–10 PM |
Tuesday |
5 AM–10 PM |
Wednesday |
5 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Leslie Stockton
Great in and out really enjoyed not going somewhere that was a Kwik trip. Nice change of pace. Very friendly. Great ice.
… more
Brandon Maury
Great to have ethanol free premium. Good fuel and pretty good food. Always a large selection of breakfast pastries etc. Not a KT but still the better option in this burg.
… more
Sara Silgado
This Casey’s is so nice, friendly and knowledgeable staff. I drive the extra time to come here instead of Monticello. You can tell the staff has been trained and has good customer service. Whoever’s running Monticello store is unprofessional and careless
… more
Paul Burk
Everytime we order a pizza, they screw up. Ordered extra pepperoni, didn’t get it. They can give us bread sticks inserted off the right order. I guess maybe we’ll try again in 3 months. Sugar River is not much more fire better quality.
… more
Richard “Betta7776” Bergemann
Amazing service, Amazing pizza, Amazing chicken tenders
… more
Eric Spanton
Need new food service people. Hardly have anything out most of time. Went there today for a chicken sandwich that they are advertising and they didn’t have any. They didn’t have any burgers either and it was 12:50. They had a girl there I had seen at other stores and she did great. Lots of options and very helpful. Went to the Co-op to get lunch.
… more
Guy Fieri
Very slow customer service. Always have to wait in line when there is staff to have 2 checkouts open. Seems like cigarette inventory is higher priority then serving people.
… more
Troy G
Wanted a sub just before 8pm, employee seemed less than enthused to do his job. This was confirmed when he asked, “Is subway closed?” Like I should have went there instead. Now Living in New Glarus I have been here 50+ times and have more than once stood at cash register while employees straighten shelves…. sorry this is a convenevce store which should be quick, don’t waste my time and nobody cares that much about product placement. Needed a google play card an none of the employees knew how to ring it up.
… more
Indy 5110
They need to improve on the ingredients that are on the pizza…sauce has no flavor is …way too salty..and I just got a plain cheese slices…so pretty much I paid for a slice of bread with salt..
… more
Kaytee Lemke
Quick in and out….love the chocolate chip muffins…you need to bring back the double chocolate chip muffins….i have been having to get them from Kwik Trip which I dont mind..but you are like 3 mins from my house… Their coolers need to be stocked more and often…when i go in at night there is literally nothing to choose from for drinks…
… more
… View more