Your Evansville, WI Casey’s at 230 E Main St has the best pizza featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and only the freshest pizza toppings. We’ve also got appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and a variety of household essentials and groceries. When you’re stopping by, you can even fill up your gas tank with quality fuels – Whatever you need, Casey’s is here to help.
Convenience-store chain offering fuel, drinks & food, including pizza, sandwiches & baked goods. Based on 33 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No dine-in ✔️ No delivery
Address:
230 E Main St, Evansville, WI 53536
Phone: (608) 453-3914
Hours
| Thursday | 4 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 4 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 4 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 4 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sarah Ponicki
We have been ordering 4-8 pizzas a month from Casey’s every month for almost a year now. I just went in today to order and they don’t accept online coupons anymore and told me they never have. They have every other time I was there.
… more
Simeon Stala
5 dollar tiny square of pizza. No thanks, pizza is cheap and this is just price gouging.
… more
Nikki Frydenlund
It’s sad that they won’t accept the coupons/deals that are on the Casey’s app anymore.
… more
Natalia Lema
Used to be the only gas station that was open somewhat later than the others. Now it’s the only one that closes at 9? Bummer…
… more
Ariana Walker
I love how people can put on the review something bad about Casey’s because they didn’t get hired. then say someone is the best worker because your friends with them… isn’t right…. Hmmm. I think Casey’s is a great place to go to and the workers are all great especially the managers!
… more
D C (Hypocritical Dissimulator)
A couple of years ago it was exciting to know we were going to get a Casey’s here in Evansville so we can go have dons decent pizza.. nope. Flatbread only and it’s another Evansville pizza fail, back to Oregon and Stoughton for pizza.
… more
Erik Lenning
I’m only giving this Casey’s one star because I can’t give it any less. I grew up in Iowa with Casey’s all over and they have the best pizza! Unfortunately this Casey’s NEVER has any pizza when I stop by, even at noon! It’s never busy either, except for the attached Subway that always busy because people like to eat! I drive past here at least twice a week on the way to Janesville and never any pizza. It’s pretty sad. I’m done stopping.
… more
Ky
Only have flat breads available because their “kitchen is too small”… fine. But when I had to ask the cashier if she was open because she was on her phone behind the register watching a video I was not happy. Then I came back in for some water I was told the public sink was the only option to fill my water bottle up. Pathetic!!
… more
Thomas Kenney
I have grown up on these gas stations. Absolutely love them I’m only giving three stars because of this locations pizza. Sadly it’s not Casey’s pizza it’s completely different. Not sure why they are different but it’s just not the same. Otherwise love the location.
… more
Danielle Bremer
The manager is so unprofessional..walked in yesterday and she was behind the counter saying f this and thay very loudly, and she was wearing a spaghetti string tank top where u could see her under garments..as I walked around the store she seemed to be the only worker not working..the rest of the team were busy putting truck away..the food service manager was running back and forth bring out fresh food ect.i believe her name is Dorey..she has great customer skills and from what I’ve seen being a frequent customer is she’s a very hard work who goes above and beyond upper management really needs to fired Quinn the store manager she is horrible..and for anyone who doesn’t have a strong stomach don’t look when she bends over or croches down you will see a thongs unprofessional I only go in now if she’s not there
… more
… View more