Your Newton, IA Casey’s at 3104 1st Ave E has the best pizza delivery and pickup featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and only the freshest pizza toppings. We’ve also got appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and a variety of household essentials and groceries. When you’re stopping by, you can even fill up your gas tank with quality fuels – Whatever you need, Casey’s is here to help.
Convenience-store chain offering fuel, drinks & food, including pizza, sandwiches & baked goods. Based on 76 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery ✔️ No dine-in
Address:
3104 1st Ave E, Newton, IA 50208
Phone: (641) 792-2825
Website:
Hours
Sunday |
5 AM–10 PM |
Monday
(Labor Day)
|
5 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
Tuesday |
5 AM–10 PM |
Wednesday |
5 AM–10 PM |
Thursday |
5 AM–10 PM |
Friday |
5 AM–10 PM |
Saturday |
5 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Michael W.
Don’t bother getting the cheesy breadsticks they are advertising… I am very disappointed.
… more
Henry Dog
ask cashier not to scan my I’d so she did anyway i think there steeling id’s she scanned it and laughed and told me to leave sounds like a scam -*
… more
Anthony Jensen
I love Casey’s pizza. But compared to other staffs around the area, they are completely less friendly (especially the evening staff when managers are gone). It seems every time you order a sausage pizza it seems they run out of sausage. We ordered a large taco and a medium sausage pepperoni. It had like twelve crumbles of sausage. The pizza itself didn’t seem to have one full serving of toppings when we pay for the extra topping. That’s not the first time that has happened from this store. If Casey’s is going to scrimp that much when it comes to their pizzas, then I’ve lost the best reason to go there
… more
jasmine lee
Just pulling out of there now. Pulled in to fill up our RV and get some food. First there was 1 piece of pizza and nothing else prepared or ready. Now as I tell the rest of this story picture 1 employee shooting the breeze with someone while the other who is right next to her keeps staring at me and then looking at his phone. This goes on for several minutes. Mire people came in and were hungry…but again 1 piece of pizza which we gladly gave to a gentleman who came in after us since we needed more than one for our group anyway. Finally a 3rd employee walks up who isnalso on his phone but I am glad he is upright as he was laying down on the concrete behind the building when we pulled up. Finally I asked if anyone had anymore food going and he said no and proceeded to get back on his phone. By the time we got to the front door all 3 employees were on their phones. It is by far the laziest group of employees I have ever seen with no care for customer service at all. 6 people walked out of there hungry and ready to spend their money anywhere else. As a buisness owner myself I am not sure how your labor costs are even remotely close to reasonable. Good luck but don’t stop there if you are hungry or want a helpful face not in a phone.
… more
Tony Hamilton
Everything at first glance was normal, surprisingly i was greeted by the nicest gentleman making pizzas, asked if there was anything he could do? Pleasant staff, cup&lids were fully stocked, something i always notice, as i once managed a store. Went to a very freshly cleaned restroom, again nice to see. After chatting with the pizza boy im pretty sure hes on top of things, polite, friendly, and the pizza was perfect not dry or greasy like other caseys pizzas are and u can tell when someone cares about their work ! ! ! Thanks Newton for a great pizza and a hot pizza maker hubba hubba.. seemed like a ninja with his hair up.
… more
Zach
The coffee is horrible. Both the classic and hazelnut. BUT the attendant was very sweet. Thats why i won’t give one star.
… more
Lacey Mason
I love Casey’s there friendly people, there store’s r always clean & they make the best pizza
… more
Stephanie Goodman
Really! 2 pieces of what looks to be buddig bull ham and 1/2 of a piece of cheese on their breakfast sandwich!? Come on Casey’s make them worth the money!!
… more
Amanda Montoya
Best Casey’s in town. Other one has horrible deliverance and services. Great job everyone! Great Store. Love that .
… more
Mama G
Good big piece of pizza is always goid
… more
… View more