Based on 610 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
121 Hawkins Dr, Montgomery, NY 12549
Phone: (845) 457-1014
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Allie Peifer
UPDATE: The owner Anthony us an extremely nice guy and business owner. He invited my fiance and I back for pizza. He definitly made it right. The pizza was delicious and filling. Much happier than we were on Valentine’s Day. Anthiny definitely left us with a better taste in our mouth about his restaurant.
… more
jar DuHill
Easy parking, clean place, clean bathrooms, polite people, good food, good price
… more
S2 xo
Just got the best slice I’ve had in a long time !
… more
Aimee Hebert
Ordered a supreme pizza…walked to the place which is 5 minutes away and got back to the hotel. Somehow it is a cheese. Paid for supreme. Place was closing so by the time we got to look then it was too late. My fault for not checking in house but they didn’t open it for us either like they do back home to check. Sucks to get screwed after a long a long teip
… more
Christy Stamoulis
Husband and I were passing thru last Sunday from PA to NH and decided to stop here for a few slices. So glad we did! We decided to get 4 slices to split (pepperoni/sausage, pepperoni, white and eggplant parm.) The EXTREMELY friendly girl behind the counter was the best.. when she brought us the slices she offered to cut all 4 in half, since we were splitting them all, which was awesome and much appreciated! Now for the pizza.. we are both pizza snobs and this pizza was a winner! NY style, sauce was so good and every slice we tried was excellent! My personal fav was the eggplant parm pizza, so good, I would go there just to get that! So if you are ever in the area or passing through, I highly recommend stopping here, you won’t be disappointed. Thanks everyone at Cascarino’s for your friendly service and fantastic pizza!
… more
Lorraine Rivera
My husband works for Medline
… more
Miranda Romleski
We LOVE Cascarino’s! We have used them for years for parties, personal dinners, and catered business events! They are the most personable bunch and the “family owned” is evident. Feels like home! For pizza, CBR is phenomenal! The buffalo chicken or original Stromboli are great! The CBR hero, and chicken Caesar heroes are phenomenal. The chicken Caesar wrap is also amazing. Chefs salad is the bomb too. Rice balls with vodka sauce! The make your own pizza kits are adorable and perfect for toddlers/little guys! I can’t pick favorites but there’s nothing on this well rounded menu you could possibly dislike.
… more
Amanda Calabro
I got the penne alla vodka pasta lunch special and it was very good! Came with a small salad and roll. $10. Staff was super friendly too. Great place for a quick lunch.
… more
Robert Gailie
I just had lunch here and have to say the food and experience was excellent. I love trying different and unique foods and when I walked in they had a chicken and waffle pizza. I had to give it a try and it was delicious. The owner came over and gave me extra sauce if I wanted it for the slice. The owner Anthony Casacrino was very friendly and gave genuine customer service and took the time to care about his customers. His staff was very friendly and welcoming. I also had a slice of the bruschetta pizza that was delicious. If you are a person who likes shopping local I would definitely recommend coming here for not only delicious people but friendly and genuine customer service. We will certainly be back. Five stars.
… more
Karen Harding
We stayed at the Holiday inn express and they had a menu and I looked on the hotel website for places to eat and a lady said they had good pizza so we ordered they delivered good pizza, good food and fast service we decided to eat at the restaurant Wednesday night before we headed home the food was good and service was nice and good prices if you are in the area eat here . The Harding Family
… more
… View more