For 30 years, Caruso’s Pizza and Pasta Italian Eatery of Georgetown, DE, has offered the area’s finest and freshest Italian cuisine. We never try to compete with anyone. Our only concern is to satisfy each and every one of our customers.
• We use 100 percent Grande cheeses-no imitation cheeses-and all of our sauces are made in-house. Taste the difference!
• Our catering service will make your next party a memorable one. We offer a special catering menu with an outstanding selection of Italian foods made from scratch. Any item on our regular menu can be prepared for outgoing catering. We deliver within 5 miles of our location at in Selvybille.
Based on 14 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.5 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
37232 Lighthouse Rd, Selbyville, DE 19975
Phone: (302) 436-0213
Website:
Hours
| Saturday |
10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
10 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday |
10 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
10 AM–10 PM |
Reviews
Ashley Wilkinson
We got the Spicy Buffalo Chicken Wrap and the Cheesesteak- both were really good! The workers were friendly. They are pretty new and working out the kinks, but we had a pleasant experience and will definitely be back.
… more
Brian Johnson
I really enjoyed the cheesesteak. Way better bread than the previous shop. Haven’t tried the pizza but it looked classically NY coming out of the oven
… more
Scott Sahrhage
I ordered two pizzas and the Texas fries which is essentially loaded fries. The food was excellent. Typical NY style pizza was one of the better ones I’ve had down here. Possibly better than Ken’s when it was here.
… more
Alison Cuomo
We got carryout over the weekend and the food was great. I have to say the eggplant parm sub and cheesesteak stromboli were the best I’ve ever had! Can’t wait to try more of the menu when we’re back in the area!
… more
Jeff Langeheine
It’s great to have Carusos back on Rt 54. Really nice place with quality food. It’s a sub shop but it’s always good.
… more
Lindsey Kennedy
I placed a take out order. I went to pick it up and they seemed very disorganized. There was something that messed up on their computer when I tried to pay…which is fine things happen. My issue is that almost my entire order was wrong. I ordered 2 cheeseburgers, one plain and one with ketchup. They both had lettuce, tomato and pickles on them. I also ordered an Italian sub that should have had mayo, oil, vinegar, salt, pepper and oregano….no onions or tomato…well it had onions and tomato on it….no oil…no vinegar….no oregano…and barely and mayo. The cheesesteak I ordered was also wrong and the bottom of the roll was all soggy. When this place was Ken’s it was our favorite place to order…probably won’t be ordering again from here…it’s just not the same.
… more
Home Owner
Food was pretty good, but I would not recommend going to this restaurant due to poor customer service. We ordered multiple items from the menu. We order some pasta (was good, heavy on the sauce, but order got messed up), calamari (dry and they forgot to include the marinara), chicken parm (very good)
… more
P Hardy
I called in my order for a large pizza with toppings. I went to pick it up and it was $3.00 more than what was listed in the menu. I asked for a receipt and was not given an itemized receipt but one for the total. So I asked them why there was a difference and I was told it was due to me using a credit card. Ok – so I went home and calculated that I was charged 15% for using my credit card. That can’t be right. So I called and asked the manager. He said that the toppings are $3.00 on a large (not $1.50 as advertised). I told him that they should only charge what they advertise. I asked for the owner (not available) so I asked him to have him call me. It not necessarily the money as much as the principle of 1) overcharging and 2) telling a customer 2 different reasons. It’s probably a 15% tip (which I would not give them as I picked it up). Just saying – that’s bad business.
… more
Eric Mitchell
It’s hard to find a good cheesesteak down here, but Caruso’s is one of my go-to’s. Only wish they had proper ‘hots’ (hot cherry pepper spread) – they use banana peppers. Still would recommend their cheesesteak.
… more
Andy Tvardzik
Very poor service, made order completely wrong. I said I would wait for them to remake the order. They were rude and defunded the order. I will never come back this place!
… more
… View more
