Carter’s Pigpen Bar-B-Que Menu – Mechanicsville, VA

Type : Barbecue restaurant

Location : Mechanicsville, VA

Carolina & Virginia-style pulled pork plus classic Southern sides offered in a down-home smokehouse. Based on 466 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout

Carter's Pigpen Bar-B-Que 23111

Address:
8011 Cold Harbor Rd, Mechanicsville, VA 23111

Phone: (804) 730-3616

Website:

Hours

Thursday 11 AM–8 PM
Friday 11 AM–8 PM
Saturday 11 AM–8 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday 11 AM–8 PM
Tuesday 11 AM–8 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–8 PM

Menu

Sandwiches
Carter’s Bar-B-Que
The perfect blend of vinegar and spices.
$9.40
Grandma’s Bar-B-Que
A tomato based sauce, sweet and rich with flavor.
$9.40
Mixed Company
An excellent spicy combo of Carter’s & Grandma’s.
$9.40
Pulled Chicken
A tangy tomato-based sauce, sweet and rich with flavor.
$9.40
Pulled Beef
In the mood for something different? Try our hand-pulled all beef sirloin.
$10.60
Brisket Melt
Crispy outside, smothered in Monterey jack cheese, and a kick of Grandma’s sauce.
$13.10
Sides
Baked Beans
Perfectly traditional.
$3.75
Potato Salad
Red roasted potatoes with cheese, onions, and celery.
$3.75
Cole Slaw
Delicious, creamy coleslaw.
$3.75
Green Beans
Country style.
$3.75
Mac & Cheese
Triple cheese with a golden crust.
$3.75
Cornbread Muffins
Two pieces. Sweet taste and baked daily.
$2.00
Combos
Carter’s Combo $16.90
Grandma’s Combo $16.90
Mixed Company Combo $16.90
Pulled Chicken Combo $16.90
Pulled Beef Combo $18.10
Brisket Melt Combo $20.60
Platters
Papa’s Platter
Choice of Carter’s, Grandma’s or mixed company.
$20.00
Pulled Chicken Platter $20.00
Pulled Beef Platter $21.25
Ultimate Platter
Just under a pound of your choice of three meats.
$23.75
Ribs
Half Rack
Rubbed in a special blend of spices and smoked to perfection.
$21.25
Full Rack
Rubbed with a special blend of spices and smoked to perfection.
$31.25
Kids’
PB&J $3.75
Grilled Cheese $3.75
By the Pint
Carter’s Bar-B-Que $10.00
Grandma’s Bar-B-Que $10.00
Mixed Company $10.00
Pulled Chicken $10.00
Pulled Beef $11.25
Family Packs
Carter’s Bar-B-Que $35.00
Grandma’s Bar-B-Que $35.00
Mixed Company $35.00
Pulled Chicken $35.00
Pulled Beef $37.50
Hotdogs
All American
Add mustard, ketchup, relish or onions.
$7.50
All American Combo
Add mustard, ketchup, relish or onions.
$11.90
Jumbo Joe
Topped with chili, cheese and coleslaw.
$8.75
Jumbo Joe Combo
Topped with chili, cheese and coleslaw.
$12.50
Desserts
Our Famous Banana Pudding $5.00
Favorite Cookies: Chocolate Chip & Oatmeal Raisin $0.95
Peach Cobbler Bread Pudding $6.25
Drinks
Bottle Water $2.50
Tea $2.50
Lemonade $2.50
Limeade
Fresh & carbonated.
$2.00
Canned Soda $2.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

T Williams
I’m giving them 3 stars because it’s my first visit. Although my order was ‘messed up’ the guy at the counter is willing to make up for it. I’ll give them a second chance.

… more

Jessica Ownby
The cutest little BBQ place!this has been one my favorite place to get great top quality BBQ. The staff is very friendly and you can dine in on the front on nice day they are quiet and so delicious you get craving for it you will be back

… more

Kim Grammer
I brought home the Grandma and Carter Platters. Each came with potato salad, baked beans, Cole slaw, and corn bread muffins. I would’ve liked to try the macaroni and cheese, but they were out.

… more

Preston Burns
This place was highly recommended by a local. I had to check it out. While there I got a text saying I needed to pick up dinner. Great timing. I got a pint of each type of pork BBQ, coleslaw, Mac and cheese, and corn bread muffins. I drove it back to Fredericksburg to rave reviews from the kids and our friends. They did not disappoint! I will add this to my favorite places list!

… more

Stephanie Terrell
Food was DELICIOUS! Love the mac & cheese and the banana pudding was the best I had in awhile! Service was awesome. Will definitely be back & recommend it to EVERYBODY! My husband says that the banana pudding was delicious and he recommends it!

… more

Deepak Jain
Great local BBQ spot with both Carolina vinegar (Carter’s) BBQ and a tomato based (Grandmas) BBQ. They have limeade too.

… more

Ben Ward
Ordered lunch and picked up father’s day family 4 pack 24 hrs in advance. Order 1 lb of chicken bbq. Found out the day of pickup they only had a 1/2 pound of chicken bbq. Was able to substitute the other 1/2 pound of beef. Was told when we ordered they had enough then they took some for catering. Lack of attention to detail. I was lucky that it worked out. I just don’t understand how people are not paying attention to what people order and pay for. Went to pay for my lunch and they tried to charge me again for the family 4 pack in addition to lunch when we already paid at time of order 24 hrs prior. They looked it up and found payment and took it off the bill and I only paid for lunch. Again lack of attention to detail. This is not hard folks.

… more

Logan Fields
This is an edit to an original review that was one star. I am always willing to offer another chance to an establishment just to see if it was an off day. The staff there today was solid and the food was d*mn good. Solid job this time folks

… more

Christian Vasquez
Awesome find great sandwiches and awesome pulled pork. The sauces are wonderful and both grandma’s and Carter style sandwiches are great! Definitely stop by.

… more

Susan Woody
Great food. Great, friendly people. Left my phone there, they not only held onto it but had me explain it to ensure it belonged to me.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions