Carmine's Menu - New York, NY

Low-key eatery offering a big menu of pizza & Italian classics, plus a full bar. Based on 15 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Carmine's 10036

Address:
200 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036

Phone: (212) 221-3800

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday	11:30 AM–11 PM
Wednesday	11:30 AM–11 PM
Thursday	11:30 AM–11 PM
Friday	11:30 AM–12 AM
Saturday	11:30 AM–12 AM
Sunday	11:30 AM–11 PM
Monday	11:30 AM–11 PM

BEST SELLERS
Penne Alla Vodka Chopped Plum Tomatoes Combined with Cream, Romano Cheese, Sautéed Onions, Garlic & Crushed Red Pepper Flakes – Feeds 2-4	$36.95
Eggplant Parmigiana Lightly Battered & Fried Eggplant Thinly Sliced – Layered with Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella & Romano Cheeses Piled High Then Baked – Feeds 2-4	$36.95
Caesar Salad Romaine Lettuce, Parmesan Romano Cheese, Homemade Garlic Croutons- Served with House Made Caesar Dressing on the Side – Feeds 2-4	$29.95
Bread Pudding Toasted Italian Bread with Golden Raisins, Chocolate Chips, Soaked in a Custard Consisting of Cinnamon, Eggs, Vanilla, & Heavy Cream – Baked Until Crispy Brown, Served Warm with Whipped Cream on The Side – Feeds 2-4	$25.95
Chicken Parmigiana Breaded Chicken – Pan-Fried to a Crispy Golden Brown Topped with Melted Mozzarella & Romano Cheese & Served Over Marinara Sauce – Feeds 2-4	$37.95
Meatballs Six Over-Sized Meatballs Made with Beef & Veal Served in Our Signature Marinara Sauce – Feeds 2-4	$27.95
APPETIZERS
Spicy Scarpariello Wings Marinated w/ Garlic & Rosemary, Pan-Fried & Tossed in a Spicy Lemon & Butter Herb Sauce Served w/ Gorgonzola Dipping Sauce – Approximately 20-24pcs	$39.95
Garlic Bread Thick Sliced Bread Topped w/ Garlic & Herb Butter – Approximately 8-9pcs	$17.95
Zuppa Di Clams Fresh Little Neck Clams Cooked in a Red or White Broth w/ Garlic, White Wine & Herbs – Approximately 16-18pcs	$26.95
Zuppa Di Mussels Fresh Mussels Cooked in a Red or White Broth w/ Garlic, White Wine & Herbs – Approximately 18-20pcs	$26.95
Stuffed Artichoke Stuffed & Baked w/ Our Seasoned Breadcrumbs in Chicken Stock – 2 Per Order	$24.95
Stuffed Mushrooms Stuffed Mushroom Caps with Sweet Italian Sausage, Sweet Pepper & Hot Pepper Filling – Approximately 6-8pcs	$19.95
Spiedini Alla Romana Thick Sliced Bread Rubbed w/ Garlic, Layered w/ Fresh Mozzarella Cheese & Stacked – Toasted & Melted Topped w/ Lemon, Butter, White Wine, Capers & Anchovies Sauce – Feeds 2-4	$25.95
Fried Calamari Fresh Calamari Lightly Dusted in Our Seasoned Flour – Served w/ Spicy Marinara Sauce – Feeds 2-4	$42.95
Fried Zucchini Shoestring Strands of Zucchini Dredged in Milk & Lightly Breaded in Seasoned Flour – Fried Golden Brown & Topped w/ Grated Romano Cheese – Feeds 2-4	$25.95
Cold Antipasto An Assortment of Seasonally Chef Selected Cold Appetizers – Feeds 2-4	$49.95
Hot Antipasto An Assortment of Seasonally Chef Selected Cold Appetizers – Feeds 2-4	$49.95
Carmine’s Salad Mixed Greens, Tomato, Onions, Pepperoncini, Celery, Radish, Olives Topped w/ Diced Meats & Cheeses – Served with House Vinaigrette Dressing on the Side – Feeds 2-4	$33.95
Mixed Green Salad Mixed Greens, Tomato, Onions, Pepperoncini, Celery, Radish, Olives – Served with House Vinaigrette Dressing on the Side – Feeds 2-4	$29.95
Caesar Salad Romaine Lettuce, Parmesan Romano Cheese, Homemade Garlic Croutons- Served with House Made Caesar Dressing on the Side. (Dressing will always contain Anchovy Paste) – Feeds 2-4	$29.95
Caprese Salad Tomato, Mozzarella, Black & Green Olives, Onions & Roasted Red Peppers Dressed w/ Oil & Vinegar	$33.95
Portobello Parmigiana Large Portobello Mushrooms Breaded & Fried – Served Parmigiana Style with Marinara Sauce & Melted Cheese – Feeds 2-3	$20.95
Roasted Peppers W/ Anchovy Freshly Roasted Red Peppers Topped w/ Anchovies & Basil Herb Oil – Feeds 2-4	$16.95
Roasted Peppers, Mozzarella W/ Anchovy Freshly Roasted Red Peppers Topped, Mozzarella w/ Anchovies & Basil Herb Oil – Feeds 2-4	$21.95
Baked Clams Fresh Little Neck Clams Baked w/ Our Seasoned Breadcrumbs & Clam Broth – Approximately 10-12pcs	$26.95
PASTAS
Penne Alla Vodka Chopped Plum Tomatoes Combined with Cream, Romano Cheese, Sautéed Onions, Garlic & Crushed Red Pepper Flakes – Feeds 2-4	$36.95
Meatballs Our Homemade Meatballs Consisting of Beef & Veal Served in a Combination of Marinara & Ragu Sauces – Feeds 2-4	$36.95
Marinara Our Signature Sauce of Plum Tomatoes, Olive Oil, Garlic, Fresh Herbs & Romano Cheese – Feeds 2-4	$29.95
Garlic & Oil Olive Oil, Fresh Herbs, Garlic & Chicken Stock.. Topped with Season Breadcrumbs & Romano – Feeds 2-4	$27.95
Sausage Sweet Italian Pork Sausage Links with Choice of Sauce – Our Slow-Cooked Ragu Sauce or Marinara Sauce – Feeds 2-4	$33.95
Pomodoro Plum Tomatoes Sautéed in White Wine, Garlic, Oil & Prosciutto – Feeds 2-4	$29.95
Lasagna Layers of Ground Beef & Veal Layered with Three Cheeses – Baked & Topped with Our Marinara Sauce – Feeds 2-4	$36.95
Shrimp Shrimp Sautéed with Fresh Garlic & Herbs Cooked with Choice of White (garlic, Olive Oil, Fresh Herbs & Clam Juice) or Red (adds Tomato) Sauce – Feeds 2-4	$40.95
Clam Sliced Cherry Stone Clams Cooked with Choice of White (garlic, Olive Oil, Fresh Herbs & Clam Juice) or Red (adds Tomato) Sauce – Feeds 2-4	$36.95
Calamari Calamari Served with Either Red Sauce (garlic, Fresh Herbs, a touch of Crushed Red Pepper, White Wine & Italian Plum Tomatoes) or White Sauce (garlic, Olive Oil, Fresh Herbs & Clam Juice) – Feeds 2-4	$38.95
Mixed Seafood a Variety of Seafood including Lobster, Shrimp, Clams, Mussels & Calamari & Served with Either White (garlic & Oil with Garlic & Herbs) or Red (adds Plum Tomato & Marinara) Sauce – Feeds 3-5	$95.95
Ragu (Assorted Meats) Meatballs, Italian Sausage Slow-Cooked in a Rich Shredded Meat Tomato Sauce – Feeds 3-5	$37.95
Rigatoni Broccoli Sautéed Broccoli with Choice of Sauce – Signature Marinara or White Sauce (Garlic, Oil with Chicken Stock & Fresh Herbs) – Feeds 2-4	$30.95
Rigatoni Broccoli Sausage Sautéed Broccoli, Crumbled Italian Sausage with Choice of Sauce – Signature Marinara or White Sauce (Garlic, Oil with Chicken Stock & Fresh Herbs) – Feeds 2-4	$31.95
Giardiniera Fresh Medley of Broccoli, Spinach, Italian Plum Tomatoes, Garlic, Onions, Mushrooms, Basil, Parsley, Vegetable Stock & Grated Romano Cheese – Feeds 2-4 Vegan Ordered Without Cheese	$31.95
Ravioli W/ Cheese Three Cheese Ravioli with Choice of Sauce – Our Slow-cooked Ragu Sauce or Marinara Sauce – Feeds 2-4	$32.95
Rigatoni Country Style Rich & Buttery Sauce Consisting of Pork Sausage, Prosciutto, Chicken Stock, Cannellini Beans, Broccoli, Onions & Romano Cheese – Feeds 3-5	$33.95
Manicotti Thin Italian Egg Crepes Stuffed with a Mixture of Four Cheeses – Baked Over a Layer of Our Signature Marinara Sauce – Approximately 5-6pcs	$32.95
Bolognese Meat Sauce Slowly Simmered Tomato Sauce with Ground Beef & Sweet Italian Sausage – Feeds 2-4	$35.95
ENTREES
Chicken Scarpariello Whole Chicken Cut on The Bone Marinated in Lemon, Garlic, Rosemary – Pan Fried & Finished with a Lemon Butter Sauce – Feeds 2-4	$38.95
Chicken Contadina Whole Chicken Cut on The Bone Pan-Fried & Served with Roasted Peppers, Potatoes & Sweet Italian Sausage – Topped with Sweet Pepper Vinegar – Feeds 3-5	$49.95
Chicken Cutlet Breaded Thin Pounded Chicken – Pan-Fried to a Crispy Golden Brown – Feeds 2-4	$33.95
Chicken Parmigiana Breaded Chicken – Pan-Fried to a Crispy Golden Brown Topped with Melted Mozzarella & Romano Cheese & Served Over Marinara Sauce – Feeds 2-4	$37.95
Chicken Scaloppine Marsala Chicken Scaloppine Sautéed with Fresh Sliced Mushrooms Simmered in a Deep Rich Veal Stock & Marsala Wine Sauce – Feeds 2-3	$33.95
Chicken Scaloppine W/ Lemon & Butter Chicken Scaloppine Sautéed in a Lemon & Butter Sauce Served Over Sauteed Spinach – Feeds 2-3	$33.95
Chicken Saltimbocca Thin Sliced Chicken on a Bed of Sautéed Spinach Topped with Prosciutto & Melted Mozzarella in a Marsala Wine Sauce – Feeds 2-3	$35.95
Veal Cutlet Breaded Thin Pounded Veal – Pan-Fried to a Crispy Golden Brown – Feeds 2-4	$39.95
Veal Parmigiana Breaded Thin Pounded Veal – Pan-Fried to a Crispy Golden Brown Topped with Melted Mozzarella – Served Over Marinara Sauce – Feeds 2-4	$43.95
Veal Scaloppine Marsala Veal Scaloppine Sautéed with Fresh Sliced Mushrooms Simmered in a Deep Rich Veal Stock & Marsala Wine Sauce – Feeds 2-3	$42.95
Veal Scaloppine W/ Lemon & Butter Thin Sliced Veal Scaloppine Sautéed in a Lemon & Butter Sauce Over Sautéed Spinach – Feeds 2-3	$42.95
Veal Saltimbocca Thin Sliced Veal on a Bed of Sautéed Spinach Topped with Prosciutto & Melted Mozzarella in a Marsala Wine Sauce – Feeds 2-3	$43.95
Shrimp Marinara Shrimp Sautéed with Garlic & Fresh Herbs in a Marinara Sauce with White Wine – Feeds 2-3	$42.95
Shrimp Scampi Shrimp Broiled with Garlic Breadcrumbs Served in a Garlic, Clam Juice, Olive Oil & Butter Sauce – Feeds 2-3	$42.95
Shrimp Parmigiana Shrimp Breaded & Pan-Fried Topped with Melted Mozzarella & Marinara Sauce – Feeds 2-3	$44.95
Shrimp Fra Diavolo Shrimp Sautéed in a Spicy Marinara Sauce with White Wine & Fresh Herbs – Feeds 2-3	$42.95
Salmon Oreganata 22 Oz Salmon Fillet Topped with Garlic Butter & Seasoned Bread Crumbs, Broiled & Served with a Scampi Sauce, Clams & Mussels – Feeds 2-4	$72.00
Porterhouse Steak 45oz Porterhouse Seasoned & Cooked to Your Liking, Finished with Olive Oil, Fresh Herbs & Garlic – Feeds 2-4	$148.00
Porterhouse Contadina 45 Oz Porterhouse Cooked to Your Liking with Sautéed Peppers & Onions, Roasted Potatoes, & Sausage Links, & Finished with Sweet & Spicy Pepperoncini Juice- Feeds 3-5	$165.00
Porterhouse Pizzaiola 45 Oz Porterhouse Cooked to Your Liking, Sautéed Green & Red Bell Peppers & Onions, Fresh Pomodoro Sauce- Feeds 2-4	$155.00
Porterhouse W/ Peppers & Onions 45 Oz Porterhouse Cooked to Your Liking Served with Seasoned Sautéed Peppers & Onions- Feeds 2-4	$155.00
SIDES
Escarole Sautéed Escarole with Garlic, Olive Oil & Chicken Stock – Feeds 2-3	$20.95
Spinach Sautéed Spinach with Garlic & Olive Oil – Feeds 2-3	$20.95
Eggplant Parmigiana Lightly Battered & Fried Eggplant Thinly Sliced – Layered with Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella & Romano Cheeses Piled High Then Baked – Feeds 2-4	$36.95
Peppers & Onions Red & Green Peppers with Spanish Onions Sautéed with Garlic, Oil & Fresh Herbs – Feeds 2-3	$19.95
Sausage Four Sweet Italian Fennel Sausage Links – Pan-Fried Approximately 3-4pcs	$26.95
Meatballs Six Over-Sized Meatballs Made with Beef & Veal Served in Our Signature Marinara Sauce	$27.95
Broccoli Sautéed Broccoli Spears with Garlic, Olive Oil & Chicken Stock – Feeds 2-3	$22.95
Contadina Roasted Potatoes Sliced Roasted Potatoes	$15.95
Focaccia Bread A Portion of our Homemade Focaccia Bread	$8.95
Marinara Sauce Pint A Pint Of Our Homemade Marinara Sauce	$6.95
Grated Pecorino Romano Cheese A Pint OF Our Freshly Gradted Pecorino Romano Cheese	$9.95
HEROS
Cold Italian Hero Genoa Salami, Prosciutto, Mortadella & Provolone Cheese, Roasted Peppers, Lettuce & Tomato – Served w/ choice of side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad	$19.95
Tomato & Mozzarella Hero Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Prosciutto, Sliced Tomato, Basil & Herbed Olive Oil – Served w/ choice of side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad	$18.95
Chicken Cutlet Combo Hero Chicken Cutlet w/ Fried Eggplant, Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella Cheese & Tomato Sauce – Served w/ choice of side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad	$19.95
Veal Cutlet Combo Hero Veal Cutlet w/ Fried Eggplant, Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella Cheese & Tomato Sauce – Served w/ choice of side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad	$23.95
Hot Italian Hero Grilled Soppressata, Mortadella, Provolone Cheese, Roasted Peppers & Hot Cherry Peppers on Garlic Bread – Served w/ choice of side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad	$19.95
Italian Cheese Steak Hero Sliced Steak Sautéed w/ Peppers & Onions on Garlic Bread – Served w/ choice of side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad	$19.95
Meatball Parmigiana Hero Served w/ choice of side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad	$18.95
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero Served w/ choice of side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad	$17.95
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Hero Served w/ choice of side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad	$21.95
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero Served w/ choice of side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad	$18.95
Sausage Peppers & Onions Hero Served w/ choice of side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad	$17.95
DESSERTS
Italian Cheesecake (For 4) Our Homemade Italian Cheese Cake with Creamy Ricotta above a Marble Chocolate Pound Cake Crust – Topped with Fresh Strawberries	$28.95
Italian Cheesecake (For 2) Our Homemade Italian Cheese Cake with Creamy Ricotta above a Marble Chocolate Pound Cake Crust – Topped with Fresh Strawberries	$20.95
Bread Pudding Toasted Italian Bread with Golden Raisins, Chocolate Chips, Soaked in a Custard Consisting of Cinnamon, Eggs, Vanilla, & Heavy Cream – Baked Until Crispy Brown, Served Warm with Whipped Cream on The Side – Feeds 2-4	$25.95
Chocolate Cannoli (6pc) Small Chocolate Covered Cannoli Shells Ricotta Filling with Candied Fruit, Chocolate Chips, Pistachios	$18.95
Chocolate Cannoli (3pc) Small Chocolate Covered Cannoli Shells Ricotta Filling with Candied Fruit, Chocolate Chips, Pistachios	$12.95
Tiramisu Homemade Lady-fingers Sponge Cake Soaked in Espresso & Coffee Liquor, Layered with Sweet & airy Mascarpone & Zabaglione Cream. Covered with Semi-sweet Belgian Chocolate Shavings – Feeds 2-4	$28.95
Strawberry Shortcake House Made Marble Pound Cake Soaked with Strawberry Syrup Layered with Whipped Cream & Fresh Strawberry Slices -drizzled with Coffee Liquor & Sprinkled with Pistachio Nuts – Feeds 2-4	$19.95
Chocolate Torta Rich Creamy Flourless Chocolate Cake with a Hint of Coffee Liquor, Fresh Cream & Strawberries – Feeds 2-4	$17.95
Fresh Fruit Platter Seasonal Fresh Fruit – Feeds 2-4	$25.95
NON-ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES
Acqua Panna Large 1 Liter Bottle Of Acqua Panna Natural Spring Water	$7.95
San Pellegrino Large 1 Liter Bottle of San Pellegrino Sparkling Natural Spring Water	$7.95
Coke Can	$1.95
Diet Coke Can	$1.95
Sprite Can	$1.95
Ginger Ale Can	$1.95
Water Bottle	$1.95
Plates & Utensils
Plastic Plates & Utensils	$0.00
Plastic Serving Utensils	$0.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reservations: carminesnyc.com

Reviews

Shams L

Paul was amazing as the server for our large group. He wrote nothing down and memorized our entire order with drinks, which we all noticed and was fascinated by. We had zucchini fries, steak, garlic bread, baked clams & two pasta dishes. The food portions are insanely large and even with our large group we still had a significant amount of leftovers. The dishes were tasty and the environment is very very vibrant and lively. If you want a more quiet Carmine experience go to the upper west side location. As this location embodies the energy of the theater district and nearby Times Sq

… more

Jaylah Gillespie

A lot to try and eat on your own. I came here with a family of six. The fried zucchini and calamari appetizers were both too greasy. The rigatoni & broccoli – with white sauce – could have been cooked longer and was a little (meh or mid). The lasagna was excellent and easy to cut through. It was a birthday celebration so the servers brought ice cream and sang. We also ordered the titanic. Huge but delicious.

… more

Fern Blossom

I went here for my birthday with family and the food was amazing. The plates are obviously family size. Our waiter was persistent on telling us that we were ordering a lot of plates (6 plates for 8 of us we knew we were going to have leftovers which is what we wanted) my favorite dish was the shrimp Parmesan and the garlic bread. The cheesecake was ok I expected it to be more creamier, but over all the food was good and so was the experience.

… more

Leslee Gregory

Family style so portions are large. Food was amazing. This place is extremely busy, so the service is a bit slow. Once you’ve ordered, the food comes out quickly. Very loud atmosphere. Definitely recommend going with more than two people. Be prepared to take home leftovers.

… more

Sabrina Zucaro

If you’re looking for an authentic Italian experience in New York, this is the spot. The portions are over the top and could be very overwhelming at first. 2 dishes would be enough to split between a group of 4. The cold antipasto and the warm seafood pasta were great. If you opt for dessert, be prepared to be super stuffed. I would recommend coming here for just dinner or dessert.

… more

Jenny Ramos

We came back to celebrate my son’s birthday. It was even more packed than during Christmas time. They did not skip a beat. Service was quick and efficient. Our table was waiting for us. They even called to double check we were coming about 40 minutes before our reserved time. The food was outstanding. Large family style portions. We were a party of 14 and everyone was full at the end. The garlic bread with cheese is always a favorite. This time they had the cannolis. The rum runner was delicious in case you wanted a drink recommendation. I think this is the best place to eat if you have a large party.

… more

Gab Esc

We went to celebrate my daughter’s b-day with friends. We all loved it. A bit pricey due to location(walking distance to Times Square) but huge and delicious portions. For 9 people we ordered 1 salad, 2 pastas, the porterhouse contadina style and 1dessert and still had left overs. Beautiful old Italian style. Rosalee was our server and she was excellent.

… more

Analia Gerard

Carmine’s is fun, very loud, always packed and well with a visit in NYC with a group. All dishes are Italian family style and huge. Tonight, six of us women shared fried calamari appetizer with Carmine’s salad, followed by rigatoni bolognese and lemon chicken piccata. Overkill for dessert was the titanic, which was way too much but fun to order at least once in a lifetime.

… more

Khay Bee

Recently had dinner here while visiting NYC for the first time. It was very nice to sit down to have dinner instead of grab and go meals. It was a full house, they had plenty of people there and we still were able to get seated rather quickly. The food was delicious, served hot! They had multiple servers check in us and were very helpful. This is family style portions however and party two we were both able to manage have left overs being that our dish was meant to serve 3 I do believe!

… more

Rovik Robert

When they say that their plates are ALL family style they are not joking. Honestly, if you’re coming as a party of two, you’ve likely got leftovers set for your next few meals. Food is above average, especially their pastas. Cocktails were too sweet for my liking. Service is incredibly busy and so we couldn’t get much attention but we weren’t too affected by it.

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Carmine’s Menu – New York, NY

Hours

Menu

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reviews

Related:

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions