Based on 460 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
287 Wading River Rd, Manorville, NY 11949
Phone: (631) 878-2345
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Justin Beresford
This place has really went downhill i recently ordered a Chicken Francese Hero and what I got was frozen chicken strips undercooked in a disgusting “sauce” consisting of what I think (and hope) is butter and seasoning that reminded me of Raman Noodle seasoning
… more
Mary Ferraro
Carlo’s is my go-to place for pizza. Especially salad pizza! Ask for it heated up and drizzle the red wine vinaigrette on it. Delicious. As is all their pizza and food. Great menu.
… more
Jill Kolodnik
Horrible! Not the first time either. This time we won’t be going back. Everything burnt when we asked for light. They say they have no more Sicilian so we pick other things and what cones out a second later ? A hot Sicilian pie. No one knows what’s going on. Handling food without gloves. This isn’t the first time . This is however my first time leaving a review. I rather travel further to get better quality. They have kids working that can’t slice a pie up. I’m just aggravated. Sorry for the rant.
… more
CM
1st time here & will be back. Excellent & yummy food. Portions are big so had take homes for another meal. Nicely decorated.
… more
John Corbett
This place is just fabulous, been eating at Carlos for years and years. The owner is a caring family guy who cares about his customers. I wholeheartedly recommend Carlos for lunch,dinner and or catering, which they’ve also done for me
… more
Ross Whalen
Nice neighborhood pizza place, everything was incredibly fresh and delicious. The Pizza was served hot and crispy. The sesame seed finish on the speciality slices was a touch of class! One of the best pizzas places I’ve been too!
… more
Dan Gallo
Heard it was great, was anything but…cheese pizza that was ordered well done but was undercooked. Chicken franchese was underwhelming. Cannoli cream sucked…
… more
Carlos Rivera Jr
Food is good but person(s) taking order over the phone never get it right. I order food from here all the time and when I get there I am still waiting around because they forgot to put in my correct order. So on top of waiting for 20 minutes for food to be prepared, I will have to wait an additional 15 minutes so they can prepare what they forgot to put in. Besides that the food is delicious!l just make sure to double check your order if getting takeout.
… more
Marc Mauss
One of our regular lunch stops during our motorcycle rides
… more
Marie Anne Corba
Best Italian in the area. Owner super nice. Quality food. We just love this place. Such a wide variety of food. Everything is delicious. The servers at the counter are very friendly and helpful. This place is the best.. From the pizza to everything on the menu is excellent.
… more
… View more