Based on 37 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
1109 Noyack Rd, Southampton, NY 11968
Phone: (631) 204-5877
Hours
| Tuesday | 5–9 PM |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 5–9 PM |
| Friday | 5–10 PM |
| Saturday | 5–10 PM |
| Sunday | 5–10 PM |
| Monday | 5–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
sheaugh costello
Best New England Clam Chowder on the island, for sure! The chicken and waffle dish was phenomenal. You don’t even need a knife
… more
Sean Gallagher
THE BEST New England clam chowder I’ve EVER had. Hands down. My parents had the Peach & Goat Cheese salad with Chicken and loved it. I had the Mahi Reuben and it was delicious as well! The fries were delightful, normally I skip them, not this time! Kudos to the chef!
… more
Michelle C
Had a lovely meal and evening at Captain Jack’s! Friends and I enjoyed appetizers- calamari, crab poppers, lobster fritters, and oysters (-local, so fresh and delish)! Our main dishes were great choices as well. Definitely recommend the fish tacos and the mahi Reuben. With the restaurant right on the water it’s a great spot for a sunset view which adds to the charm. This will be such a great, fun, local, spot for this summer! Boat owners in this marina are lucky! Service was also great and the owner pays special attention to make sure everyone is enjoying themselves and happy! Will be coming back!
… more
Jordan Daniel
A wonderful experience all around! What a treat. The service was exceptional; attentive, friendly and efficient. The food was truly delicious and offered something for everyone. Our table ordered a mix of great options and everyone loved what they had. The voodoo squash was particularly tasty and the oysters were out of this world! It’s great to see a local-run restaurant and not another city conglomerate out east as well, and I wish them all the success! And of course, the views are wonderful. Don’t miss this great addition to the Southampton/Sag Harbor area!
… more
Allen Fein
Love everything about this place with a wonderful cove view, delicious food and wine/beer selection. Windows make for happy reflected noise. The lobster hush puppies were plentiful and the best, as was the Key Lime parfait. Fantastic evening. Great staff!
… more
Emily Nemecek
Really enjoyed our experience tonight! Did not need a reservation and got a table right away. Delicious food and great atmosphere with a nice view. Had the salmon which was tasty and a key lime parfait dessert was excellent. Plenty of great options, especially the lobster hush puppies as an appetizer. We will definitely be going back, highly recommend this place!
… more
Kate Byrne
I hosted a party for my husband’s birthday at Captain Jack’s. I messaged them through Instagram and was in touch with the owners, Erin & Chef Mike. The whole experience was so pleasant. From the planning, (I had both of their cellphone numbers for calls and texts!) to the actual event (amazing food, awesome friendly efficient staff behind the bar and servers). I can’t rave enough about how great this place is! A much needed addition to our sleepy side of Southampton! They are crushing it all over from atmosphere (Thank you God for the beauty surrounding us!), to the wonderful, professional, friendly staff, to the delicious food ,to the new friends I’ve made in Erin & Chef Mike. I wish them continued success and Thank them for their kindness!!!
… more
Ben
Fantastic dinner with the fam! We stopped in to check out this new spot in Noyack and we were all impressed with the friendly staff that greeted us. Our waitress Gail was lively and fun and always checked in on us at the perfect times!
… more
Kate Deyermond
Had a phenomenal time at Captain Jack’s on the Coast. The drinks were great, I love a good cocktail menu! Oysters and clams in the half shell were perfect, cold, crisp, briney, and wonderful. Everyone’s meals were tasty and the Peach Melba was the biggest highlight!! Loved that the kids meal comes with an ice cream bar! Can’t wait to go back!
… more
Christine Moffitt (Moffiie)
Met up with some old friends whom I haven’t seen in years at Captain Jack’s. Had a great time at the corner table overlooking the small marina watching the sun set. The food was delicious. We all shared the calamari, crab poppers, lobster hush puppies and oysters. All were fresh and delicious. Fish tacos are a must try, they were fantastic! Fresh, flavorful and beautifully presented. Everyone else loved their choices- the mahi Reuben, oyster po boy , & the vegetarian squash dish. Our server was sweet and attentive but not overly. The restaurant has a cool welcoming vibe. We will be back for sure!
… more
… View more