Based on 99 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
36 W Ramapo Rd, Garnerville, NY 10923
Phone: (845) 553-9888
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Mark Lara
I ordered linguini with (white) clam sauce…. well apparently what I was told when I called back, i asked how it was prepared, the person asked what do you mean? I said isnt it supposed to be linguini, white wine, oil, salt, pepper, garlic, parsley? Person on the phone said yes thats right ok well attached is the picture of what I got, I got linguine, drenched in oil, sliced garlic, parsley and 6 little neck clams on top, only thing i ate were the clams and a few bite of the pasta because i tried to give it the benefit of a doubt……………. never ordering from this place again.
… more
Mary Ferlauto
After waiting 2 hours for our food, with calls to them where they repeated each time that the driver just left. By time the food arrived it wasn’t even hot. We live 3 minutes away from them by car. They could of sent him 60 times but they wait until they have a bunch of orders and lie to each customer that their food will arrive in 20 minutes to 1/2 hour. Over 2 hours to deliver an order 3 minutes away is not worth it for food that is nothing to brag about.
… more
Paul Cleary
Been eating here for years. Great service and food. Consistent quality is the key.
… more
Melissa Moise
I really like the pizza..but im not ordering from here again. You would think i would have learned my lesson the last time i placed an order and it NEVER showed up even after multiple phone calls.get some management for orders/deliveries..its ridiculous.
… more
Matt M
First time ordering from this establishment and the order was incorrect. Called, and a young lady assisted me… Was very apologetic and corrected the mistake quickly. Excellent customer service! Will definitely be back!
… more
John Salter
I work in the Town of Haverstraw but grew up in the Bronx. If us Bronxites “?” Know anything it’s what quality pizza tastes like. I live many miles away from Calbrias Pizza but when my significant other requests “Pizza” I make the journey to this establishment to satisfy the craving for “Pizza”. Yes its in a Supermarket mall setting, but inside its clean, the staff us attentive and because it’s a shopping plaza parking is plentiful. When you don’t want to experience the drama of driving to the Bronx for the world’s best slice or pie, head over to Calabrias Pizza for the quality. Tasty. Pizza. JKS
… more
POOLMAN
I have given this ESTABLISHMENT plenty of opportunities to make a pizza and food the right way!!Tonight will be last time purchasing anything from them. I ordered a large pizza to go, half cheese and half meatballs. I asked before they made the pie please make sure it had enough cheese and sauce .The pizza was dry and had hardly any cheese or sauce.This will be my last time ordering from them.They were rude about the whole situation!! I would suggest you go to other pizza shops in the area Stay away!!Also I have tried to get in touch with the owner but he is never there and never returns my phone calls. There are a bunch of kids running the place.
… more
Sarah A. Lindon
Ordered a catering tray if there penne ala vodka for a birthday party and all night people were asking where it came from. Everyone loved it. The workers are friendly beyond belief. Such a clean place no matter what time it is. I make it a priority to go there whenever I am in the area. You have to go!!
… more
carlos mazariego
No complaints! I like this place! Good pizza !good people!
… more
Bri N
I really like the quality of the food the pizzas are great and the dinner specials are great as well the only issue I have is that there’s always that one cashier girl that always has an attitude other than that everybody else is so friendly it just to be nice and pleasing to have some good customer service as soon as you walk in
… more
… View more