Buttermilk’s Chicken Menu – East Islip, NY

Type : Chicken restaurant

Location : East Islip, NY

We’re proud to use the very best ingredients to serve you the freshest and tastiest meals. We cook from scratch all day long to bring you delicious homestyle comfort.

Chicken Sandwiches, Fried Chicken, Chicken Tenders, Homemade Side Dishes

Fresh. Made To Order. We are all about Quality!

Based on 114 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Buttermilk's Chicken 11730

Address:
93 E Main St, East Islip, NY 11730

Phone: (631) 581-3000

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 12–7:30 PM
Wednesday 12–7:30 PM
Thursday 12–7:30 PM
Friday 12–7:30 PM
Saturday 12–7:30 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday Closed

Menu

Salads
Garden
Tomatoes, cukes, carrots, red onion, and black olives. Made with baby Romaine and mixed greens.
$9.60
Caesar
Asiago and Parmesan cheese, toasted croutons, and creamy Caesar. Made with baby Romaine and mixed greens.
$11.30
Country Cobb
Grilled chicken, bacon, hard-boiled egg, tomato, dried cranberries, and crumbled Bleu cheese. Made with baby Romaine and mixed greens.
$17.80
Mediterranean
Feta, tomato, cukes, red onion, pepperoncini, Kalamata olives, and house vinaigrette. Made with baby Romaine and mixed greens.
$14.25
Baja
Grilled chicken, red onion, black olives, Cheddar, sour cream, tomatoes, and black beans. Made with baby Romaine and mixed greens.
$16.65
Chicken Salad
Just A Scoop
Our classic chicken salad in a cup
$9.60
Creamy Cobb Chicken Salad
Hard-boiled eggs, bacon, tomatoes, and crumbled bleu. Served in a flatbread pita or over greens.
$17.80
Rancher Chicken Salad
Bacon, cheddar & buttermilk ranch. Served in a flatbread pita or over greens.
$14.25
Classic Chicken Salad
Mayonnaise, celery, seasonings & dijon. Served in a flatbread pita or over greens.
$12.00
Waldorf Chicken Salad
apples, cranberries & glazed walnuts. Served in a flatbread pita or over greens.
$14.25
BLT Chicken Salad
Bacon, lettuce & tomato. Served in a flatbread pita or over greens.
$14.25
Sandwiches
Crispy Classic
Crispy chicken, dill pickle chips, and sassy sauce (sweet and savory with a kick) on a buttery French bun.
$10.15
Crispy Classic Deluxe
Crispy chicken, dill pickle chips, sassy sauce, American cheese, and lettuce on a buttery French bun.
$11.30
Buff-A-Leu
Crispy chicken, drizzled in a spicy-sweet Buffalo sauce, topped with Bleu cheese on a buttery French bun.
$11.30
Hey, Honey!
Crispy chicken, honey dijon sauce, lettuce, and tomato on a buttery French bun.
$11.30
Peppercorn
Grilled chicken, Parmesan peppercorn sauce, fresh Mozzarella, and tomato on a buttery French bun.
$13.10
Country Club
Grilled chicken, applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on a buttery French bun.
$13.10
Farmhouse
Crispy chicken, applewood smoked bacon, and Cheddar, topped with ranch sauce on a buttery French bun.
$13.10
Kickin’ Chicken
Crispy chicken, sriracha honey, lettuce, tomato, drizzled with buttermilk ranch on a buttery French bun.
$11.30
Roadhouse
Crispy chicken, Cheddar, smokey bacon, and BBQ sauce topped with crispy onion rings on a buttery French bun.
$13.65
Build A Sandwich
Create your Own Buttermilk’s Chicken Sandwich!
$8.90
Jumbo Fried Shrimp & Fish
Golden Shrimp
Includes waffle fries, lemon wedge and choice of buttermilk biscuit or cornbread served with tartar or cocktail sauce.
$14.85
Half Dozen Shrimp
Served with lemon wedges, tarter, cocktail or sweet chili sauce
$11.90
Chicken Boxes
32pc Box
8 Breast, 8 Wings, 8 Legs, 8 Thighs
(served in equal parts.)

*Roasted – Allow 45 mins*

$94.85
24pc Box
6 Breast, 6 Wings, 6 Legs, 6 Thighs
(served in equal parts.)

*Roasted – Allow 45 mins*

$71.15
Dark 2pc Box
Thigh and drumstick (served in equal parts.)
$5.95
White 2pc Box
Breast and wing (served in equal parts.)
$7.70
4pc Box
Breast, wing, leg, and thigh (served in equal parts.)
$11.85
8pc Box
2 Breasts, 2 Wings, 2 Legs, 2 Thighs (served in equal parts)

*Roasted – Allow 45 mins*

$23.75
12pc Box
3 Breast, 3 Wings, 3 Legs, 3 Thighs
(served in equal parts.)

*Roasted – Allow 45 mins*

$35.60
16pc Box
4 Breast, 4 Wings, 4 Legs, 4 Thighs
(served in equal parts.)

*Roasted – Allow 45 mins*

$47.45
Crispy Tenders
Just Tenders 4pc
Our premium, all-natural chicken is marinated in our buttermilk brine and cooked in 100% canola oil (served in equal parts.)
$11.90
4pc Tender Combo
Served with choice of side, dipping sauce, and cornbread.
$15.45
Just Tenders 8pc
Our premium, all-natural chicken is marinated in our buttermilk brine and cooked in 100% canola oil (served in equal parts.)
$23.75
Just Tenders 12pc
Our premium, all-natural chicken is marinated in our buttermilk brine and cooked in 100% canola oil (served in equal parts.)
$35.60
Just Tenders 16pc
Our premium, all-natural chicken is marinated in our buttermilk brine and cooked in 100% canola oil (served in equal parts.)
$46.25
6pc Tender Combo
Served with choice of side, dipping sauce, and cornbread.
$21.40
8pc Tender Combo
Served with choice of side, dipping sauce, and cornbread.
$27.35
What’s For Dinner
Feast Dinner
16 pcs, 3 large sides, 8 cornbread

*Roasted – Allow 45 mins*

$77.10
Gobble Dinner
12 pcs, 2 large sides, 6 cornbread

*Roasted – Allow 45 mins*

$59.30
Peck Dinner
8 pcs, 2 regular sides, 4 cornbread

*Roasted – Allow 45 mins*

$41.50
Combos
Dark 2pc Combo
Thigh and drumstick served with choice of side, and cornbread.
$10.75
White 2pc Combo
Breast and wing served with choice of side, and cornbread.
$13.10
Half Chicken
Served with choice of side, and cornbread.
$16.60
Lil’ Peeps / up to 12yrs
Kids Drumsticks
Served with your choice of side.
$8.35
Kids Shrimp
Served with your choice of side and dipping sauce.
$8.35
Kids Tenders
Served with your choice of side and dipping sauce.
$8.35
On The Side
French Fries $6.00
Onion Rings $9.55
Creamy Coleslaw $6.00
Buttery Corn $4.85
Gravy $4.20
Cornbread $1.80
Mac & Cheese $7.15
Cheddar Jalapeno Poppers
spicy, crunchy and ooze-y, comes with any dipping sauce

*limited time offer

$7.15
Let’s Get Saucey
Sassy Sauce $0.95
Buffalo Sauce $0.95
BBQ Sauce $0.95
Ranch $0.95
Bleu Cheese $0.95
Honey Mustard Sauce $0.95
Parmesan Peppercorn Sauce $0.95
Sriracha Honey Sauce $0.95
Sweet Chili Sauce $0.95
Drinks
Boylans Black Cherry $2.75
Boylans Creamy Birch Beer $2.75
Boylans Root Beer $2.75
Boylans Cream $2.75
Boylans Orange $2.75
Boylans Ginger Ale $2.75
Boylans Cola $2.75
Boylans Diet Cola $2.75
Evian Water $2.40
Montauk Lemon Tea $3.00
Montauk Raspberry Tea $3.00
Montauk Tea, Half & Half $3.00
Montauk Tea, Pink Lemonade $3.00
Montauk Tea, Diet Lemon $3.00
Chips
Hal’s Original Sea Salt Chips $1.75
Hal’s Sweet Chili Chips $1.75

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Jose Torres
Food is SO good that it should get a 6th star. At the first bite you can taste it is 100% buttermilk chicken. Everything is made to order so it doesn’t get better than that. Staff was amazing, kind, patient and helpful. Fries have the right amount of salt and the onion rings are battered perfectly.

… more

Tristan St. Louis
We decided to try Buttermilk’s Chicken before our long 9.5 hour drive home from Long Island to Toronto and we were not disappointed at all. The music, the friendliness of the man and woman running the place and of course the food exceeded our expectations. I had the Kickin’ Chicken and would seriously consider this as one of the main reasons aside from visiting family to make the drive again. As a family of self-proclaimed ‘foodies’ this place topped our list as great little spots to eat. A hidden gem!

… more

Nate Peebles
Food was very good, service was excellent and friendly. Chicken was tender. Place was nice with a good vibe. Next time iam gonna order the onion rings tho .

… more

Robert Miccio
All of our food was delicious. Perfectly cooked. People working there are so nice . (side note) flooring needs some attention . Im a stickler to details.

… more

Alpha “Alpha Killo” L.
Always support local businesses! Was kept very clean! Super friendly owner/staff! Food was great!!!

… more

Hassan M.
Hidden gem Pretty good fried chicken. If you like KICKIN’ CHICKEN is a great option. Also, the roasted chicken is worth the wait. Better alternative to Pudgies if you are debating the two.

… more

Walt
Fresh food and great tasting. The workers are super nice. We have eaten there only a few times but each time it was delicious. We are making this our go to chicken place.

… more

Lulu Dolan
By far the best chicken I’ve had in a long time. It was fresh and seasoned to perfection! Their mashed potatoes and that gravy… oh my goodness!!!! Oh! And their cornbread… and coleslaw…. The list goes on. It was delicious. The owners are such sweet people as well! I will be returning! Worth the commute

… more

Ryan Gillies
My son and I ordered from Buttermilk’s Chicken today, the atmosphere, the people and the food was excellent! Nice to see a great establishment right here in East Islip!

… more

Jimmil431
The the chicken and corn muffins are great. That’s all I had tonight. The staff is very friendly

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions