Based on 202 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
4781 S Orange Ave, Orlando, FL 32806
Phone: (407) 237-9981
Website: http://www.buttercrust.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–2 AM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Anica Cousley
Edges crispy. Pizza saucy and cheesy and oh so hot. Wings were okay, definitely would pass on those. Parmesan bites were very good. Will be back!
… more
Abraham Hernandez
We ordered a whole squared pizza, I thought the crust was the highlight of the whole thing, it was soft , buttery and airy, almost like eating focaccia bread topped with sauce , cheese and toppings with a caramelized crust (caramelized crust as it should for Detroit style pizza) the flavor profile of the overall package was good, but not great in my opinion. The wings we had on the other hand were not so good, the flavor and texture of the wings just wasn’t for us, doesn’t necessarily mean they were bad. Would eat here again , suggest those who love pizza , to this place and determine for themselves.
… more
Michael H
This pizza always hits the spot and I literally will crave the buttercrust until I finally order some. Highly recommend the pepperoni buttercrust or even the Buffalo chicken one , or the Mac and cheese. And the wings are always so good too
… more
John Carrascal
Buttercrust pizza is family owned and operated. It’s not a chain restaurant it’s the only one in all Orlando. If you’re looking for authentic Detroit style pizza, this is the place for you. Also, they have chicken wings which are not fried, they are double cooked in the oven. They also have a nice variety of soft drinks available. They don’t have in-house delivery, but they do Ubereats! I recommend you order a pie and pick it up yourself, staff is super friendly. A++ more me!
… more
Sherry Ashley
The food was not as expected & definitely not worth $45 . I ordered the new garlic parm bread and it was like a very greasy garlic parm grilled cheese, a 16” hand tossed and a 12” thin crust pizza. The crust on both was so hard and some areas had sauce , no sauce and excessive sauce and tasted funny. Terribly disappointing.
… more
Sofia
The pizza was amazing the wings were just as good! The service was quick and the lady up front was very nice. The only upsetting part is you can’t eat there it’s only take out. Not a dining place where you can sit and enjoy your pizza.
… more
Joshua Corlew
Buttercrust is our go-to pizza in the Belle Isle/Conway area. We have it every week for our Pizza and Movie family night and it makes the whole family happy. The pizza is always well made and delicious and it’s affordable. Their sides are also great.
… more
Genesis Nunez
I love the pizza here the crust is by far the best of Orlando. It’s cheesy and crisp around the edges and the bruschetta is one of my favorites. The pesto sauce on it is one of a kind. Really love this pizza and the shop is so cute looking forward to their second location!
… more
Peter Franklin
Wonderful service and the sauce to cheese ratio on their hand tossed pizzas are spot-on. My husband had gotten their “butter crust” and he said the same thing. It’s great to have a local (and female-owned) business in the neighborhood thatwecansupport.
… more
Heather Crowell
Was very disappointed in our food after reading such great reviews. We ordered a build your own (1/2 pepperoni pizza) and the cheese bombs. The pizza crust was crunchy and hard as a rock and had hardly any sauce. The pepperonis were practically burnt. Had to make the kids a frozen pizza because they couldn’t eat this. Of the 4 cheese bombs, there was only 1 that had any cheese worth mentioning. The others we had to pull them into many pieces to find the tiny blob of mozzarella. The marinara on the side was really good though and the garlic dough of the bombs was soft and tasty. Don’t think we’d eat here again.
… more
… View more