Based on 429 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1851 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Phone: (631) 665-4939
Social Profile:
Hours
Tuesday | 10:30 AM–9:30 PM |
Wednesday | 10:30 AM–9:30 PM |
Thursday | 10:30 AM–9:30 PM |
Friday | 10:30 AM–9:30 PM |
Saturday | 10:30 AM–9:30 PM |
Sunday | 10:30 AM–9:30 PM |
Monday | 10:30 AM–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
damian amico
Not sure what’s going on with this place? My wife and I used to love everything we ordered, but lately??? I ordered manicotti a few weeks ago and it was literally sour and inedible. I figured I’d try again tonight and we got a shrimp dish that I actually took a bite of and spit out! It’s a shame and I hope they get back to what they were but until then I’ll take my business elsewhere.
… more
Vanessa Gonzalez
Pizza was extremely overly greasy. The moment you opened the box all you saw was grease. The pie was filled with bubbles. Taste was not the greatest. Paying close to $40 for one plain pie, soda and mozzarella sticks was a lot compared to other places I’ve ordered from, only to receive something even my little girls complained about. Hate to give bad reviews but definitely won’t order again. The only good thing was the mozzarella sticks. The pics on their site looks nothing like what was delivered to me it looked poorly made. Staff was kind, so was the delivery driver.
… more
Tara Bee
I’ve been going here for years. Yesterday i encountered something absolutely distasteful. I ordered a chicken sandwich with cheese. (I did not want the basil or pepper on it). So i wouldve thought they would make a fresh one, instead the girl opened the sanwich that was avaialable and pulled out the pepper and basil with her bare hand, no gloves and definitely after handling monetary activities. I straight forward told her that that was disgusting and had i known she would do that i would have just done it myself. So i asked her to just give me the one with the pepper and basil. I work in hospitality myself and know that is UNACCEPTABLE. She was needless to say very annoyed with me and i refused to leave the counter and wait for my whole order elsewhere to be sure she didnt replace the items and just give me that same one. I will not be returning because not only was this poor practice, the atmosphere is not friendly anymore and they are WAY too overpriced. They need to be taught how to handle food appropriately, and how to be more customer friendly and need to separate food handling and financial transactions.
… more
Willian Curran
I don’t know what was in my pizza but this was the best Chicken bacon ranch slice I ever had
… more
Jonathan Gomez
My daughter’s favorite pizza, it’s just great food good service .
… more
Marc Cummings
I got the chicken marsala pizza. They were extremely busy but still managed to get everyone served quickly. What a great place. Top quality food here. I cant wait to go back.
… more
Jenny Ramirez
Their dough is so delicious. The crust is not too thin or thick. They have a good variety of pizzas. Small for eating in. Reasonably priced and good size slices. Their heroes are delicious I wish their side sauce was a big bigger, it is really good!
… more
Tyrus Curtis
Pizza was good. Service was good. Kid friendly place
… more
Chery Kivens
Had 2 slices of barbecue pizza today and they were delicious. The flavor, crust, etc were all good to great. The place looked pleasant and family friendly.
… more
Glenn Terry
I’ve been coming here since I was 9, I’m almost 30. This is the best tasting pizzeria in Suffolk. It taste best when dining in because it’s hot. I will willing burn the roof of my mouth because it taste so good. The decor could be refreshed, but the friendly smiles make up for it.
… more
… View more