Based on 456 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1898 Hinds Rd, Toms River, NJ 08753
Phone: (732) 769-6333
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8:40 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Daniel
Solid pizza joint in a prime location plenty of parking. Lots of options for slices (which is what I had) but the pie/regular menu was packed as well. Friendly guys behind the counter and fast service I tried the pepperoni, cheese, and grandma slice. All were flavorful and good (wish there was a bit more sauce on the grandma but I like it saucy). Prices are great compared to other places around here
… more
Matt Tropeano
I tried many pizza places in Toms River, and I’ve haven’t been happy until now. Finally, a good pizza.
… more
Ya ya G
I ordered an eggplant parm and it was disgusting and I barley touched it. I didn’t call and complain but I did show up the next day to order a pizza and I showed him the eggplant from the night before explaining how I didn’t enjoy it and I was asking if he could give me a discount for the pizza I was about to buy and he didn’t want to look up the order from last night , claiming I was lying so I honestly just paid for the pizza and left… terrible how he Handel the situation. He’s never getting another dime of my money after that interaction and I’ll make sure I’ll tell everyone I know not to go to him
… more
Michael Herlihy
Great pizza but you really shouldn’t exploit your drivers, paying them $30 a shift where they have to pay for the gas wear and tear on their vehicle to receive the honor of delivering your food. You’re actually making money with the delivery charge add all the costs fall onto the driver. There is greed and then there’s over the top disgusting greed that actually turns your stomach secondhand embarrassment for you and to top it off at the end of the shift you get to mop your floors . LOL LOL
… more
Matthew S
This is a great spot to get pizza! BE AWARE- During busy times there is sometimes a wait! Well worth it! Good pizza with nice crust. The upside-down square pie is also a must try. Also- they make special pizzas not on menu- you must be there to get a slice. Highly recommend Brooklyn Square! Best!
… more
Rene Guarino
Worst pizza ever. I am from NYC and this is definitely not Brooklyn style pizza. I ordered 3 slices to eat in store… was heated only to warm … not hot and had no flavor. Shame on them for calling this Brooklyn pizza
… more
Joseph Lanzarotta
Really good pizza here the upside down was great had great sauce high quality cheese and the dough was crunchy on the outside and fluffy in the inside it was great and the regular slice was good and loved the sesame seed crust will definitely have it again!!
… more
Jackie Nowak
First time here tonight, my husband and I have been searching for the best pizza in Tom’s River area. We may have found it tonight at this tiny pizzeria. We wanted to dine in but the place has limited seating. We looked over the pizza and the menu and decided to try a slice of their square pizza that had pepperoni on it. We took it to our car because there was no place to sit for dinner. Was very good, crust was thick and crunchy, the sauce was very good sweet and acidic too. We were still hungry so we decided to go back in, this time there were three tables that were available so we sat down. We decided to try the pizza that was round called the Sophia. This pizza had fresh tomato’s, garlic and regular mozzarella on it. (you could order it with smoked mozzarella)
… more
Casey Mehrman
It was great when kt first opened but twice now my pizza was completely burnt and black on the bottom! Ready to stop going here!!! It’s a lot more expensive that other places and just not worth it when it is so burnt you don’t finish the pie!
… more
David M. Dwight
After long day working down in the Cedar Glen Community Garden building a new gate, rested and cleaned up to go out for dinner.
… more
… View more