Low-key, neighborhood parlor offering super-sized pizzas along with sandwiches & other casual bites. Based on 459 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
753 W 2nd St, Seymour, IN 47274
Phone: (812) 524-8888
Website: https://www.thebrooklynpizzacompany.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 2:30–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 2:30–10 PM |
| Thursday | 2:30–10 PM |
| Friday | 2:30–10 PM |
| Saturday | 2:30–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ryan Brown
Best pizza place around! Excellent service and perfect atmosphere. They go above and beyond to make sure everything is memorable. If you haven’t tried the food here yet, I highly suggest it!
… more
Mandy Hunter
This place is just great as both a great pub and a family spot for dinner. There’s regular local entertainment outside (weather permitting). We even brought our dog! The service was extremely accommodating. I’ve never been to a place that truly treats you as a friend, whether it’s your first time there or your 100th. Pizza isn’t what you would get in Brooklyn. I mean, its not the greasy, foldable, massive sliced. But it’s great! You need to stop by and try this place!
… more
Gerald Arnold
Great place for a good time. Lives bands on weekends, their own beer, great food, and great staff making sure you’re well taken care of. My first time there and I was impressed with what they have to offer and what’s coming.
… more
Eric Bennett
Brooklyn and Shawn were amazing. I honestly wish they had the ability to be open more. Everything they do and how they treat the customers is excellent.
… more
Cory Murphy
Shawn and his crew have cultivated a great atmosphere for both families and beer lovers alike. His love and appreciation for local musical talent has really added a great option for those seeking entertainment . The food and beer options pair very well with our town .
… more
Gregory Shatto
My family and I were there last night, we were in town for ball games and I found this place on line. Let me start by saying that the pizza we had was fabulous, I can’t wait to get back to try more menu items and there is a lot. We were blessed with the opportunity to meet Shawn Malone the owner, when I say blessed, that’s because he truly is an amazing person. My son plays guitar and Shawn took the time when he found out to share a piece of his family history with my son, and that is something we will never forget. We will be back on Wednesday to hear the girl he has coming to play violin, but I’m more interested in getting a chance to talk with Shawn again! My family and I will be forever patrons from now on. Thank you for sharing your time with us Shawn.
… more
Elizabeth R
Great pizza and even better beer! This is a self service joint, but thats okay! The family side is pretty small, just a few booths. Bar side is a little bigger, but not by much. The pretzel sticks and cheese can’t be beat! I had “the Bo” pizza and it was delicious. Small selection of craft beers, but a lot of diversity in that small selection. I tasted all 4 on tap and all 4 were very good. Settled on the Scarlet mask Irish red and it was great. Definitely will visit again!
… more
Jane Stormer
Stopped in to fill a growler at the attached Seymour Brewing Co. And got to sample some pizza that didn’t get picked up! A little off the beaten path, but worthwhile! Friendly, tasty, and good beer!
… more
Buddy Hawkins
Great pizzas and pizza bowls!! And live music playing outside, called for a fun night out!!!
… more
Sarah Scobell
Great pizza, live music, and the owner is awesome!! You’ve gotta try the Pickle Pesto Pizza!
… more
… View more