Informal establishment with New York–style pizzas, subs, wings & a handful of Italian entrees. Based on 396 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
13820 Old St Augustine Rd #121, Jacksonville, FL 32258
Phone: (904) 880-0020
Website: http://www.realbrooklynpizzajax.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
sarah corrigan
I ordered to go for dinner. 2 people greeted me before I even got to the counter to order. Super nice staff, my pizza and garlics knots were make quickly and we loved our food.
… more
Kelley Hoover
25-35 minite wait for medium pizza, 2 subs and a salad. The girl at the register lacked training, big time. No receipt given, didn’t get a number for our order, and then when it was ready she asked if I paid. Italian subs were toasted, prefer them not to be, very hard to eat. But great flavor. Pizza is good too. Kids were happy. Garden salad on the small side but good and fresh.
… more
Valerie Iglesias
Pros:
… more
Donald Keene
Wanted a pizza place close to the house and our neighbors said Brooklyn Pizza was a good place. Well shocker it was not great. Walked and the restaurant was hot. The staff was polite and saw people tossing dough by hand so we stayed and gave it a shot. Ordered a medium cheese with pepperoni and extra cheese. When it came out the pizza looked oily and dry. It taste just liked as looked cheese was oily and pepperoni was not good and no sauce could be found only the pizza. For 30 bucks I could got a better pizza from Little Caesars. So if you want pizza Brooklyn’s Pizza is not the place. Sad because I like supporting mom and pop shops.
… more
Genia By
They only have 2 pizza sizes, medium 14″ and XL 18″. And some specials (see pictures). Cheese pizza was pretty good.
… more
Phillip Garofalo
The pizza was very tasty. It reminded me of being back in NY. I had them add sausage to my two slices and I was surprised they put so much on each slice. Definitely will be going back.
… more
Charlotte Leto
By far one of the best Gluten free pizzas I’ve had. I was very pleased to see their sign so I had to try and was pleasantly surprised. Not your typical frozen Udis crust, definitely more of a fresh made taste.
… more
Christy K
Hands down best New York style pizza in Jacksonville. We drive from Fleming Island just for this pizza. Favorite order, 18” half ground beef half pepperoni with mushrooms. Crust, sauce, cheese, all excellent. Love some Brooklyn Pizza!
… more
Anthony Gregoli
Unbelievable! First bite brought me back to my childhood. The best pie I’ve had in a long time especially for Florida. It’s a must try.
… more
rosa scialdone
Pizza is okay but as a New Yorker I never believe when someone says this is NY pizza in FL. My only issue with this place is every time I call in an order they never actually place my order or “lose it” and I have to reorder when I get to the restaurant and end up waiting another 30 mins after pick up. Not the workers fault but more training should be implemented
… more
… View more