Based on 92 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
4963 E Dublin Granville Rd, New Albany, OH 43081
Phone: (614) 665-0555
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 2–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
MRBARBQ 1
Out cruising today and decided to check Brenz Pizza in New Albany out. Ordered a small Pepperoni Pizza. They opened last November. Talked with Adam about the operation. He said that dough is made fresh daily. All vegetables are brought in fresh from their suppliers, no frozen vegetables. They’re cut up once they are in the store. On to the pizza. It was cooked perfectly for me, slight crispy to the crust. The sauce had the slightest spicy taste to it which was perfect. Nice mild cheese and the pepperoni was a nice addition cup and char type. Might be Ezzo’s, not sure. Good experience, will definitely return. Everyone needs to check them out.
… more
Alexia Andrade
This was our first time trying Brenz Pizza Co and we are fans! We ordered the BBQ chicken pizza which was really tasty and the crust was nice and fluffy but not too thick. We also ordered a gluten free crust pizza with pepperoni, pineapple and onion. The gluten free crust was not great. It was very grainy, almost like it was not fully cooked. We have tried gluten free crusts at many other spots and this was definitely not the best. The pepperoni is also a little spicy- we liked it but just as an fyi for families with kids or spice sensitive people. We also ordered the cheesy bread and that was delicious! Just the right amount of cheese. When picking up our order I saw then giant cookies and made an impulse decision lol and we were not disappointed! The chocolate chip chunk and sugar cookies were super tasty, moist, and chewy! I will also add that the cookies ended up being on the house, which was a really pleasant surprise. This is a customer service touch that I have not seen in quite a while. We will absolutely be recommending Brenz to others and be repeat customers!
… more
J
When you spend $50 for two medium pizzas and some wings, you expect them to be made with a little care. These were the pizzas I was given (Brenz Bomber, Heritage Hot Honey). Looks like someone either shook the box, dropped them, or put them in upside down. It’s a shame because the ingredients seem higher quality, and the staff were friendly, but this is inexcusable. I highly doubt this was done on purpose, but it certainly indicates that Brenz has to work on their quality control. Hopefully they can improve.
… more
Tom Hamilton
2 visits since they just opened. A minor hiccup on our first order, that they were very eager to correct. A big kudos to the team for their ears and actions on the circumstances.
… more
Ashley Duty
New favorite pizza place! This is a hard award to win, because I can only have gluten free pizza!
… more
Antwane R.
I had heard about this place for quite sometime & finally made my way over. The price had me a bit cautious @ first but after my first bite I was sold. All the ingredients were fresh & it was well prepared 5 stars. I’ll slowly make my way through the menu if I can leave the Heritage Honey Pizza alone.
… more
Jerry Hooper
My favorite pizza spot in Columbus area! Fast delivery and exceptional pizza and cheese bread is
… more
BrittanyLynn Hawkins
I really like the pizza…its great! But this is a issue at all locations. I always purchase a small Greek salad with my pizza & everytime the lettuce is brown, wilted or just undesirables pieces. This makes me question the lettuce being rinsed off or looked at by employees. Picked up from New Albany location today & the same issue. Ill reframe from ordering salad in the future. Hate spending $5 for a salad that i have to pick through & throw away most of it….bummer & waste of money. After further inspection this lettuce was poorly rinsed if it even was so I just threw the entire salad away smh.
… more
Geena Smith
My husband and I tried this tonight for the first time. I’m a little bit of a pizza snub so I read alot of reviews before buying. We got the cheese bread and a cheese/pepperoni pizza. The bread was hands down my favorite part. One of the best I’ve ever had. We got it with a side of ranch and happy to report it’s not hidden valley, it was super tasty and paired well with it. The pizza was good. The dough was a little on the chewy side but a top place here in Columbus for sure. Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a new pizza place to try!
… more
beth ders
Pizza was very good, got the harvest hot honey. Would skip the ricotta next time but crust was fantastic. Only downside is that it is very expensive.
… more
… View more