Based on 432 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
96 Wall St, Madison, CT 06443
Phone: (203) 318-0300
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 9 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
8 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 8 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Joseph Nuccio
We ordered our food online and it had a ready time of 12:16. We got there at 12:20 and told them we are picking up online order. They were calling names as the orders were ready. At 12:38 I asked them the status of our order. Only to find out everything was ready and it had been sitting there. Our pizza was supposed to be a large and it was a medium. After further review the toppings weren’t even correct. They made it right let us keep the wrong Pizza and made us a new pizza properly. The pizza was very good. The schiacciata sandwiches we got were excellent. Unfortunately the Italian hero was not. The sub roll wasn’t that great and they also messed that order up as well. All in all some of the things were phenomenal and some of the things were just mediocre. I was glad the owner made things right with the pizza. Wasn’t thrilled about having to wait all that time when our order was already ready. That may not seem like much but when you’re on vacation and extra half an hour it’s not fun. I would definitely go back and stick to pizza and sandwiches on the schiacciata bread. Things to avoid are there sandwiches that are on the hero rolls and the stuffed breads they make in my opinion. Also I would avoid going at the middle of lunch as we did and they’re extremely busy and probably overwhelmed.
… more
Emily Morrissette
Stopped here on a road trip from New England. Was so pleasantly surprised by the options and quality of food. We got a meatball sub and a buffalo chicken Caesar salad. We’ll be back!
… more
Madeline Elaine
Do y’all know what a margarita pizza is?? Terrible terrible customer service! My husband just picked up our pizza, we ordered one large margarita which anywhere in the world is a red sauce pie with sliced motz and basil. It’s a white pizza with sliced tomato?????? What??? I called to inquire about this and the person just went silent on the other end and refused to speak to me! How rude! I would’ve liked them to remedy this but I guess not!
… more
Zachary Taylor
Buddy of mine took me here last week. Although I don’t know why. Maybe it’s the only joint in town. They have a huge menu, got a panini, nothing to write home about.
… more
Matthew Power
My girlfriend took me here, she’s from the area and I couldn’t have been more satisfied. I got a buffalo chicken wrap, it was absolutely amazing. There were a lot of people there so it was a bit of a wait. You may want to call your order in if you’re in a rush.
… more
Alicja Guziewicz
First time here. Recommended by an acquaintance. Very pleased with the quality of food. Very yummy! I ordered a BLT/grilled cheese pannini & my husband ordered a meatball sub. Will definitely come back to try something else. Price was very reasonable. Extensive menu. Casual atmosphere.
… more
ChampionsMentality
Excellent food, excellent staff!
… more
31tmdavies
Sat there for 10 minutes and nobody asked me what I wanted. Food is okay and over-priced. Staff isn’t very friendly. A lot of the 5 star reviews say word for word the same thing. Makes me think they are bots
… more
Neil Tessier
Went with family. Party of 6, 3 waited 25 minutes to be addressed, 2 others had to wait another 8 minutes. Elderly family member was left ignored for another 15 minutes. Staff stood around talking with each other, other guests came and went while we waited to be served, and not even served together. Menu is large, but difficult to read due to small chalk writing in “fancy” script. FOOD really good, service is horrendous. We will NEVER return.
… more
K C
Not really a fan… their panini’s aren’t really paninis . They are never warm or pressed. They just have the marks on them as if They were. I kept trying to give the benefit of the doubt but not worth the price. The Pizza is pretty good..
… more
… View more