Based on 91 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
Address:
477 B Lake St, Green Lake, WI 54941
Phone: (920) 807-0225
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Amberel
Absolutely amazing, the gyro is fresh right off the spit. The beer cheese is perfect, not overly bitter, the flavors are perfect. The shark bites taste great and squeaky, the chicken is so tender. Nothing bad to say, even the staff is awesome here. It is pricey but well worth it in quality. Want good experience and great food i definitely recommend this place. The shrimp is perfect it taste just caught yummm. The lemonade with flavors is great. I had the cherry one.
… more
Rebecca
First time at Big John’s Shark Shack and it was great. We were seated upstairs where we had a nice view of Green Lake. Our waitress was attentive and accurate. My Husband and I shared the cheese curds w/a side of ranch, which were really good. I ordered the Shark’s Chicken Harpoon’s with the Boom Boom Garlic Sauce. The Boom Boom Garlic Sauce had a nice bite but not too spicy. (Buffalo Wild Wing’s Buffalo sauce was crazy hot for me, like a 10, I’d say this sauce was a 5 or 6). The Husband ordered the Chicken Bacon Wrap with a side of fries and thought it was really good & tasted fresh. Will be stopping back again in the future. (Their loaded Bloody Mary’s look awesome, we’re going to have to try those next time).
… more
Ashley Johnson
Went to Big John’s Shark Shack for the first time and was pleasantly surprised! Food was great, gorgeous view of Green Lake and friendly staff. The owner Big John was making the rounds thanking everyone for being there!!
… more
Ryan Yantis
Enjoyed a nice lunch inside, with an awesome view of Green Lake. Really impressive service and food, with amazing taste and freshness. Followed up with sunset drinks on the dock later that same day. Bourbon Mule? Never before. Will again. Hopefully soon.
… more
Matthew Schinske
The Ahi Tuna appetizer was delicious with a generous portion. Friendly service. Clean place. Small windows.
… more
Andy Fallon (LT Fallon)
Good views and good food at a reasonable price.
… more
Sean Fitzpatrick
Good food, good service, clean restaurant, beautiful view on the lake.
… more
Mike B Petersen
Great view, great service and tasty pub food at reasonable prices. Does it get any better than that?
… more
Bob Jafferis
Food was good. The drinks were a bit lame. Hurting for staff like most places. Made worse by an inattentive bartender that seemed to want our waitress to look bad. Bartender sat on our drinks order for 10 minutes. We had to go ask her for them. The bartender took over our table after blaming our server when the owner asked us why we were waiting so long. Given that she was the issue to start it rubbed us the wrong way.
… more
Adam Trejo
Smaller place not much room for seating. Friendly staff. Food was decent, nothing spectacular and for the portion vs price I wouldn’t recommend. Ordered a drink once I was seated it took around 20 min. To get and it wasn’t even that busy at the time. There was a couple seated behind us and we’re waiting for their order to be taken for over 15 min. The woman got up and asked someone for service. All in all I’d most likely pass this place up next time I’m in the area.
… more
… View more