Big Jim’s Pizzeria and Restaurant Menu – New Milford, NJ

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : New Milford, NJ

Based on 173 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Big Jim's Pizzeria and Restaurant 07646

Address:
281 Main St, New Milford, NJ 07646

Phone: (201) 262-4600

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–8:45 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–8:45 PM
Thursday 11 AM–8:45 PM
Friday 11 AM–9:30 PM
Saturday 11 AM–8:45 PM
Sunday 11 AM–8:45 PM
Monday 11 AM–8:45 PM

Menu

Pizza
Per Slice $2.35
Sicilian Slice $2.80
Whole Cheese Pizza Pie $9.45
1-Topping Or Half And Half $10.95
1-Topping On Half Of Pie $10.75
2-Toppings $18.95
3-Toppings $13.25
Big Jim’s Special Pie $16.00
Specialty Pizza
Margarita Bar Pie
11″special dough. Fresh mozzarella, Italian plum tomatoes, fresh basil		 $7.75
Chicken Pizza Pie $13.25
Calamari Pizza Pie $13.25
Shrimp Pizza Pie
Fried or Sauteed		 $15.50
Hawaiian Pizza
Ham and pineapple		 $12.00
Veggie Pizza Pie
With mushrooms, peppers, broccoli, tomatoes, onions, eggplant, mozzarella and pizza sauce		 $14.00
White Pizza Pie
Mozzarella, ricotta (no tomato sauce)		 $12.00
Salad Pie $8.75
Sicilian Pizza Pie $16.50
Calzone Ham & Cheese $6.50
Garlic Knots Each $0.60
Big Jim’s Special Sicilian Pie $25.00
Salads
Antipasto $8.75
Salad $6.00
Side Salad $3.75
Caesar Salad $6.75
Shrimp Caesar Salad
Specify fried or grilled		 $11.75
Chicken “N” Salad
Specify fried or grilled		 $9.25
Chicken Supreme Salad
Chicken (specify fried or grilled), fried pepperoni, ham, salami, and provolone		 $10.50
Tuna Salad
House salad topped with homemade tuna		 $7.50
Fresh Mozzarella
Fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, sundried tomatoes, sliced tomatoes and fresh basil, with balsamic vinaigrette		 $8.75
Appetizers
Shrimp Cocktail $9.75
Mussels (Approx. 10)
Specify hot or sweet		 $6.75
French Fries $3.75
French Fries Parmigiana $4.95
French Fries With Brown Gravy $4.75
French Fries Parmigiana With Brown Gravy $6.25
Onion Rings $4.50
Garlic Bread $2.95
Garlic Bread Parmigiana $3.95
Breaded Chicken Wings
With BBQ sauce		 $7.95
Chicken Fingers
With honey mustard		 $7.95
Buffalo Wings $7.95
Buffalo Chicken Fingers $7.95
Zucchini Sticks
With tomato sauce or honey mustard		 $3.95
Fried Mushrooms
With tomato sauce or honey mustard		 $3.95
Mozzarella Sticks $6.95
Fried Raviolis
With marinara sauce		 $5.95
Entrees
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana, Marsala, Or Lemon Sauce
Milk fed nature veal		 $16.50
Eggplant Parmigiana Or Rollatini $12.50
Chicken Parmigiana, Lemon Sauce, Or Marsala $15.75
Sorrentino
Chicken and eggplant cutlets, white wine sauce, baked mozzarella on top		 $15.75
Girardi
Sautéed chicken in a light marsala sauce topped with fresh eggplant and melted provolone cheese		 $15.75
Shrimp Scampi, Fra Diavolo, Or Parmigiana $16.50
Pasta
Spaghetti With Marinara Sauce $5.95
Ziti, Rigatoni Or Linguine $7.25
Homemade Lasagna $9.50
Manicotti Or Stuffed Shells $9.50
Penne With Vodka Sauce $9.95
Penne With Broccoli And Garlic
In garlic and oil or white wine sauce		 $8.75
Baked Ziti $9.50
Baked Ziti Sicilian Style
With ricotta cheese		 $10.50
Ravioli With Meat Or Cheese $9.50
Spinach Ravioli
With tomato sauce or garlic and oil		 $9.50
Sausage And Broccoli Rabe Ravioli
With tomato sauce or garlic and oil		 $9.50
Big Jim’s Special Ziti
Penne, sausage, broccoli in pink wine sauce		 $9.95
Penne Sorrentino
With penne, chicken and eggplant in pink wine sauce. Topped with mozzarella		 $10.50
Side Of Meatballs (2) Or Sausage (2) $3.50
Seafood
Fried Shrimp Platter
With fries and salad		 $9.95
Baked Calamari
Hot or sweet		 $7.95
Fried Calamari
Hot or sweet		 $9.25
Baked Clams $5.95
Mussels (Approx. 20)
Hot or sweet		 $11.25
Burgers and Hot Dogs
All Natural Chicken
Lettuce, tomato and pickle		 $6.25
Hamburger
Fresh Ground 6oz. Char-Broiled, Lettuce, tomato and pickle		 $6.25
Chicken Or Hamburger Deluxe
Specify French fries or onion rings lettuce, tomato, sliced onion, and pickle		 $9.00
Thumann’s Hot Dog $2.25
Wraps
Veggie Wrap With Eggplant
Roasted red peppers, sundried tomatoes, romaine lettuce, sliced mozzarella and balsamic vinaigrette		 $7.25
Turkey Wrap
With shredded lettuce, sliced tomato, onion and choice of dressing		 $7.25
Roast Beef Wrap
With shredded lettuce, sliced tomato and choice of dressing		 $7.25
Tuna Salad Wrap
With shredded lettuce and sliced tomato		 $7.25
Grilled Chicken Wrap
With romaine lettuce, sliced tomato, red onion and honey mustard		 $7.25
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap
With romaine lettuce, and caesar salad dressing		 $7.25
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
With shredded lettuce, mozzarella cheese and bleu cheese dressing		 $7.25
Heros
Eggplant
With sauce		 $6.50
Eggplant Parmigiana $7.95
Veal Cutlet With Sauce $7.75
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana $8.75
Meatball Or Sausage
With Sauce		 $6.95
Meatball Or Sausage Parmigiana $7.95
Sausage
With peppers and onions		 $7.75
Shrimp Parmigiana $8.95
Chicken Parmigiana $8.25
Cheesesteak Any Style $7.95
Chicken Cheesesteak Any Style $7.95
Pepper And Egg $3.95
Sausage And Egg $3.95
Italian Hot Dog
Peppers, onions and potato		 $3.95
Roast Beef
With brown gravy		 $8.75
Ham $6.50
Ham And Provolone $7.00
Ham And Swiss $7.00
Ham And American $7.00
6 In 1 Special Cold-Cut Combo $7.50
Tuna Fish $6.75
Veggie Special
Eggplant, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, sun dried tomatoes, romaine lettuce with balsamic vinaigrette		 $7.25
Turkey Breast $7.50
Salami $6.75
Roast Beef $7.75
Chicken, Lettuce And Tomato $8.25
Grilled Chicken
With lettuce, tomato, red onion and honey mustard		 $8.25
Catering Trays
Baked Ziti $65.00
Ziti With Vodka Sauce $65.00
Ziti W/ Broccoli & Garlic $65.00
Ziti With Sundried Tomato & Oil $65.00
Stuffed Shells $65.00
Manicotti $65.00
Lasagna $65.00
Meatballs (40/20) $65.00
Sausage, Peppers & Onions $65.00
Mussels $65.00
Eggplant Parmigiana $65.00
Eggplant Rollantini $65.00
Fried Calamari $65.00
Chicken Parmigiana $70.00
Chicken With Lemon Sauce $70.00
Chicken Marsala $75.00
Chicken Piccata $75.00
Veal Parmigiana $85.00
Chicken Fingers $70.00
Buffalo Wings $55.00
Salad $45.00
Caesar Salad $50.00
Antipasta $55.00
Shrimp Cocktail $130.00
3-6 Ft Heros $16.00
Sandwich Platters $50.00
Wrap Platters $55.00
Pizza Pie
8-10 Pizza Pies $12.25
11-19 Pizza Pies $12.00
20-34 Pizza Pies $11.25
35-49 Pizza Pies $10.75
50-74 Pizza Pies $10.00
75 Or More $6.95

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Colleen Sotiryadis
I grew up in New Milford, Big Jim’s pizza is the absolute BEST pizza ever!!! I now live on the North Shore of Long Island for the past 11 years and have yet to find pizza that comes close to Big Jims. My entire family agrees. He gets a 10 out of 10 in my opinion. We miss it! Colleen O’Leary Sotiryadis.

… more

Dana Rubin
I have been coming to Big Jim’s for over 40 years and the owner Jimmy was always reasonable and fair. New ownership must be very petty.

… more

Leslie Lane
Every time I place an order, it’s made fresh and in the time they say. I enjoy their plain cheese pie. There is something so simple and soulful about it. Thank you, Big Jims

… more

Francisco Marrero (Franky)
First time giving this place a try. Ordered a Sicilian pie. Have to say it was the best Sicilian I’ve had in about 25 years.

… more

Bell McGough
I ordered calamari and it was horrible. I was chewy and and nasty. I was afraid to eat it bec it seems like not a real food. The thin Pizza was not thin at all. Was so unhappy. Not coming back ever.I can’t even put a star bec the food was that bad.

… more

Cactus Jack
I honestly don’t see the hype. The pizza dough the taste the sauce nothing feels special. I believe it was better years ago unfortunately. I bought a pie yesterday and I really wanted to give 4 stars but I couldn’t I eat pizza almost everyday and if I was to rate it 1 -10 it would be a 6.4 pizza review @daveportnoy.

… more

Lilly Cannarozzi
Don’t order their bar pie unless you enjoy eating cheese melted on a whole wheat tortilla, which the menu describes as “special dough”. extremely weird and genuinely unsure why you would serve this

… more

Leigh Lehman
Big Jim’s pizza is great – we think the best pizza in NJ. The people at Jim’s are the nicest and so accommodating. Don’t use the Slice online ordering as they add a 20% surcharge – just call Big Jim’s directly.

… more

Andy Puzak
Hi Jeff the pizza that we got for you was five stars and I hope you remember me I bought you the lottery ticket so have a great day and we’ll be customers for a long time to come thank you Andy Puzak

… more

Foxy Cotton (FoxyCotton)
I grew up in New Milford, My family lived in this town as far back as my Great Grandparents, we loved Big Jim’s, until Jim left.

… more

… View more

Related:

  1. Bravo Pizza (K) Menu – East Rutherford, NJ
  2. Little Caesars Pizza Menu – Winston-Salem, NC
  3. Little Caesars Pizza Menu – Del City, OK
  4. Pizza Hut Express Menu – Pompano Beach, FL

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch