Based on 28 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
41 Reichart Ave, Wintersville, OH 43953
Phone: (740) 792-4760
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–11 PM |
| Thursday | 4–11 PM |
| Friday | 4–11 PM |
| Saturday | 4–11 PM |
| Sunday | 12–7 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
N N
Got carryout, so the atmosphere doesn’t matter, but its clean. The couple slices of pizza I got were decent, average I’d say. The calzones are huge and tasty… but for me, the Italian hoagie stole the show. Reminiscent of old school Dicarlos Italian hoagies which were my favorite, with the peppers that kinda stood in for dressing. And I’m pretty sure they bake the bread in house. A small is big, I couldn’t imagine how big a regular size is! It was REALLY good. Cheesecake cones are a nice finish also. All in all, solid food at a fair price! Hope they succeed!!!!
… more
M Thompson
Calzones are fantastic! Pepperoni rolls are fabulous! Pizza, the cheese isn’t melted & the sauce is OK but the crust is the best. A new local favorite. (If the cheese had been melted it would be 5 stars.)
… more
Resting Bitchface
I knew from the 1st bite this was my new favorite square pizza. The sauce is a little sweet and tastes fresh. Crust was good. I also got a pepperoni roll that was HUGE! Big enough to seriously share, but I won’t! I also got these cheesecake filled sugar cones that were decadent. I’ll be back for sure.
… more
Rick Clashman
Excellent pizza thick crust with a great crunch. Very good sauce. I really enjoyed it best in a long time 10 out of 10. Friendly service. I will definitely be back. If the calzone is anything like the pizza it should be great
… more
Chuck Bell
Worst ever called in order and was told they only had 2 buns left couldn’t make 3 sandwiches . So I ordered a large meatball sub and small Italian sub and 8 pieces of pizza. ended up with 2 Italian subs and 8 pieces of cold pizza and 4 of them was burnt. And 80% of the sub buns was burnt so they ended up in the trash. Won’t ever order from there ever again…. just like any other place NO PLACE CAN GET AN ORDER RIGHT FROM THE START.
… more
Tiredofnonsense
The customer service was great and I wanted to like this pizza, but I didn’t. The sauce was not good at all, the cheese tasted weird and to top it off there was hair in my pizza and I just threw it away. Im sorry, but I wont be returning.
… more
Lora Glessner
Stuffed pizza, pepperoni rolls are AWESOME!!!! No they don’t deliver, but so worth picking up. So the next time your in the area stop and get ya some..
… more
Jamie M
I am a fan! The crust n pizza sauce excellent, cheese wasn’t my favorite, but overall delicious n will definitely enjoy again.
… more
Poke Tube
Pepperoni rolls were good.
… more
Robert Gault
Man had the meat calzon today oh boy the crust is so fluffy not hard the meat was just over flowing and the pepperoni roll is just the bomb wow that sauce is just out of this world it’s worth the drive from Toronto can’t wait to try the sibs
… more
… View more