Based on 306 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
369 Waterloo Geneva Rd, Waterloo, NY 13165
Phone: (315) 789-2780
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 5–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 4:30–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4:30–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4:30–9:30 PM |
| Monday | 5–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: hostmeapp.com
Reviews
Patricia Putney
It was my 70 th birthday and Bella’s Seneca Steakhouse made it special! They give dinners to people on their birthday!!! I had their fantastic salad bar a grilled prime rib, and a huge baked potato! Service was won and the food delightful! I totally recommend Bella’s Seneca Steakhouse for any occasion!
… more
Kaileigh Taylor
The food was delicious! Our server, Mason, was very friendly and attentive. We will definitely return for future visits!
… more
Richard Krusemark
I had the Hawaiian steak with tater tots. The steak was very well done. The Hawaiian compote on top was pineapple and mango with a few spices. It was good, but didn’t add much to the steak. The tater tots were incredible. Very crispy and a small flavoring. It could have been a little more. We also got the fish fry. It was really huge, ton of fish and fries. We also got the filet minion. It was tasty, but overdone for what was ordered. Staff was very friendly and hustling like crazy. They probably could have used one more server. The food was a little slow coming out. There is a salad bar. It has the basics. The deserts looked good, but too full to try any. The place is slightly aged and could use some upkeep, but clean. This is a bit on the pricey side for the area. The food is worth the money, but the atmosphere could be better for the price.
… more
Gary Wurstner
Went for the first time on Valentine’s Day for an early dinner and were pleased overall. Surprisingly, at 5:00 (the 4th seating time) only about quarter of the tables were occupied, but by the time we left only a few tables not taken. The salad bar is nice, but a little smaller than what I remember Emile’s had. Our dinners were delicious, my NY strip steak was very tender and though thin was still rare like I asked for. The better half’s chicken parm was a tad overcooked, but still tasty.
… more
George Samson
Food was amazing, had a nice 18oz 75 day cured ribeye, delmanico 22oz both cooked perfect. The size of this baked potato was hugh, like it was given steroids. Salad bar was perfect, wish the rolls were warm.
… more
Lisa Ingalls
I ordered seafood platter, asked if they could possibly make it cajun. Chef did amazing and it was fantastic!! My husband had the surf and turf and said it was really good and that the lobster was excellent. The service was great as well!! We have been a few times and never had a bad experience.
… more
Carolyn
I was here with my partner the other night and Mikayla took care of us! She was such a lovely server and we felt so well taken care of the entire time. Her attention to detail and personality made the whole experience so enjoyable I would definitely come back just to see her again! Overall, good food, great service!
… more
David Fenton
We went for mine and my sister’s birthday. We called ahead and made reservations for 14. Since it was our birthday, they gave us the option for a free meal up to $40, or $25 off one of the more expensive items.(surf and turf, 32oz Delmonico) Our waitress Sarah was amazing. She took care of a minor issue we had and even though she was very busy still handled everything well. They provided us with great food, great service, oh I forgot to mention they have a great salad bar with lots of options. Chick peas, black beans, black olives, and tons more. The salad bar is top notch. I live about a mile away, and I come often. I usually sit at the bar and eat, and RJ is usually there when I come. Monday or Thursdays. I have never had a bad meal from here. Never had any serious issues. I love this place. RJ is awesome, Sarah is awesome, Mason is awesome . Everyone there is awesome
… more
Karen Osburn
I used the on-line reservation feature, which worked beautifully. We were seated and served promptly. The food was delicious and the service wonderful. Our waitress was a gem, your salad bar had all my favorites, and the 9 of us had a delightful time!
… more
Eric Jansen
We enjoyed a banquet for nearly 60 people last night. Service was excellent, wait staff were engaging and took excellent care of us all. They went above and beyond to insure we had everything we needed. Appetizers were hot and ready and always kept filled. They were only topped by the food, tasty choices for all pallets but to be certain the Prime Rib of beef and “Pounder” baked potato were the star of the show. Though the Chicken Parm was excellent too. Portions were huge, cooked to perfection and excellent. They left little room for dessert of cannoli or oreo cookie mouse cake. Nobody left hungry. You won’t have better food or service. My mouth is watering when thinking about our banquet next year.
… more
… View more