Based on 79 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
Address:
60 El Jebel Rd #108, Carbondale, CO 81623
Phone: (970) 963-2600
Social Profile: 
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rafael Dietsch
Fantastic Italian restaurant with over 30 years of history. You don’t get to be in business for over 30 years by having a bad product. Food was fantastic, service was even better! On the expensive side but so worth it! If you are around El Jebel this restaurant is a must!
… more
Josh T
Delicious food! The outdoor patio has a little stream running under it which adds some nice sound. The portions are large. We split a plate which is a $4 upcharge but they included sides on both plates. We did get an appetizer which was also large and wonderful. We both had plenty to eat and enough to get two to-go boxes! Not cheap but great food and plenty of it!
… more
Craig Miller
Great food but the worst wait staff ever. One night in August our waiter went on tirade pushing chairs
… more
Fruit
A absolute disappointing experience for a Thursday night dinner. As a group of four we went in at about 7 PM and waited 5 min to be seated when we could see multiple clean empty tables. It was so loud inside we had to raise our voices to speak across the table. We got two orders of Garlic Bread, one Shrimp Scampi and Calamari. The Shrimp were terribly overcooked, topped with a sauce that was so flavor less I would have sent it back if we all didnt want to leave so quickly.
… more
Miles Craft
Long time restuarant in the area, that has been open for over a decade, that is a nice restaurant, with friendly staff. The food however is way over priced for the quality. There desserts are great and much more worth the price then the rest of the food which is to low a quality for the price that the food is. If the food was cheaper, I’d consider eating here more often, because then I’d get a meal for a reasonable price, instead of a decent meal for a super high price that is to high for the quality. The price isn’t outrageous and super exspensive, and is easily affordable by an upper middle class family, but still the foods quality is to low for the price that the food is. Even if the price is lowered, there is lots of better places with higher quality food in the area, some with lower prices then Bella Mia’s current prices. I wouldn’t say not eat here, because the desserts are great, and so is the staff, however the rest of the food outside the desserts is to over priced for the quality that it is. I’d suggest eating here, because the food is pretty good and the desserts at Bella Mia are great, however as I’ve said before, although the food is good, the price is to high for the quality of the food except for the desserts, which the quality of, better fits with the prices that they are.
… more
Joe Dempsey
Our service was nice, we had two servers. One didn’t know the prices of the dishes off the menu when we asked about them but was trying their best. Water pitcher wasn’t being refilled quite as much as we would have liked. Dined with 3 others, complimentary bread and tapenade was a nice addition.
… more
Becky Ciani
What a great dinner…so accommodating…I asked for something not on the menu and it was no problem for them to find it and make exactly what we wanted. Wonderful customer service !!! Thank you so much…very rare these days. The food was wonderful.
… more
Eric “Ericter” Gadzinski
Food was very good, sever and staff we’re very friendly and attentive. Had a “Stuffed shells” speacial of the day and it was delicious. Can’t wait to check out more of their menu.
… more
Jessica Hardin
Food was alright, but a bit overpriced for what it was. Server was super nice and cheery. Nice atmosphere that’s been the same for years.
… more
Steven “sting1224” Leishman
Seriously so good! I had a crab cake special that was fabulous. Service was great. Atmosphere was perfect. Loved it.
… more
… View more