This old-school steakhouse known for its various cuts of meat is located in a historic old library. Based on 889 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
27 Congress St, Bradford, PA 16701
Phone: (814) 362-9717
Website: http://www.thebeefeatersrestaurant.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: thebeefeatersrestaurant.com
Reviews
Rachel Hughes
This is a MUST! Food and service were incredible. The prime rib was the best I have had in years. Deserts were fresh and absolutely phenomenal!!
Michelle Hayes
Ok first we came prime rib and salmon. It wasn’t told to us that they won’t serve these until after 4pm. We were here at 320 and even asked politely if we could still order and was told no-way after server went to ask. So we ordered the lasagna which came out warming and I had ordered the beef roast with mashed potatoes. Meat was barely warm potatoes were hot but not worth the 47.81.
Robin Gonzalez
Great place for lunch. Attentive server, great atmosphere. Beautiful old building. Second time coming here for lunch.
Darcie Prestis
Amazing place to have dinner ! The restaurant is an old historic library .. right in the town of Bradford. Wonderful ambience! Got a table next to the fireplace… really great food .. didn’t try deserts tonight .. will definitely next time . Our party had : Prime Rib, Lasagna, Squash Ravioli .. all if it was perfect ! Can’t wait to return .
Sean Nally
I had the beef on a weck for lunch today with the German potato salad. It was delicious. I talked my wife into trying it and she said it was the best sandwich she ever had.
Tom Stonehunter
Wide menu, reasonably priced. So many temptations, need to visit more often. Seafood items are good, but so is their beef. Love the horseradish garnish on every table. Staff friendly, efficient.
Amanda Mrzygut
LOVE THIS PLACE. It was our first time eating here. Everyone was so sweet and quick. The food was super delicious. Loved the sauce for the onion pedals. Plus the price for this amazing was great. I would 100% drive 2hr back to eat here again.
Pete Messer
Nice experience prime rib any day is a winner. Got the super prime and it was 3 meals! Loved it.
Nick T
I went here for the first time for my 11th anniversary dinner. We ordered the 2 lobster tails and rack of lamb meals (to share). The lobster tails were very good, but nowhere near the 8oz each the menu suggests. I prefer melted butter to dip my lobster in, but it came with a thicker creamy butter sauce. My big issue was with the rack of lamb. It was super gamey and chewy. I’ve been eating lamb for 20 years and this was easily the worst I’ve ever had. I’ve bought and made way better lamb at home (from Tops) for much less. I tried goat once at a carribean restaurant and the gameyness was eerily similar. Let’s just say I brought that home for my dogs. The service was good but at no point did they ask how the food was. While the desserts are priced well and appear to be homemade, they lacked in flavor and texture. I would recommend getting the 2 lobster tail meal at Red Lobster for $20 less. For spending $110 for two people, I expected a little more. I’m not saying I would never eat here again, but if and when I do, i will stick to the beef!
… more
Mike Kohut
Michelle made us feel very welcome and tried hard to help us connect to their WiFi, but alas, could not connect!
… View more