Bay Pointe Bar & Grille Menu – Shelbyville, MI

Type : New American restaurant

Location : Shelbyville, MI

Bay Pointe Bar & Grille is an award-winning farm to table restaurant. Aptly named for its lakefront terrace with panoramic island and garden views, Bay Pointe’s Executive Chef impresses guests with house made locally-sourced cuisine to satisfy the most seasoned palate. Bay Pointe Bar & Grille is a true culinary gem that will delight your senses with a fresh, seasonal menu, extensive wine selection, handcrafted cocktails and exceptional personalized service.

Based on 288 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery

Bay Pointe Bar & Grille 49344

Address:
11456 Marsh Rd, Shelbyville, MI 49344

Phone: (269) 672-5202

Website: https://baypointeinn.com/eat/

Social Profile:

Hours

Monday

(Labor Day)
4–9 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 4–9 PM
Wednesday 4–9 PM
Thursday 4–9 PM
Friday 11:30 AM–10 PM
Saturday 11:30 AM–10 PM
Sunday 11:30 AM–9 PM

Menu

Main Menu
Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna
ahi tuna | sesame seeds | asian vegetables | sweet soy | wasabi
$17.00
Buca Shrimp
jumbo shrimp | shallots | tomatoes | sambuca butter | cream | hot honey
$19.00
Trio Spreads & Dips
roasted red pepper hummus | smoked whitefish dip | asiago cheese spread | cucumbers | pita chips
$17.00
Maryland “Jumbo Lump” Crab Cakes
jumbo lump crabmeat | sweet bell peppers | scallions | golden pineapple salsa | honey jalapeño aioli
$18.00
Crispy Korean Pork Belly
sous vide pork belly | gochujang sauce | sesame seeds
$16.00
Truffle Fries
truffle oil | parmesan cheese | sea salt | roasted garlic aioli | parsley
$12.00
Chicken Caesar Salad
chicken breast | romaine | shaved parmesan cheese | caesar dressing | house-made croutons | cherry tomatoes
$17.00
Bay Pointe Chop Salad
romaine | iceberg | radicchio | diced red onions | cucumbers | fresh tomatoes | pepperoncini peppers | sun-dried tomatoes | chickpeas | provolone cheese | italian vinaigrette
$14.00
Strawberry Avocado Caprese Salad
mixed greens | fresh mozzarella | cherry tomatoes | avocado | strawberries | extra virgin olive oil | aged balsamic reduction
$15.00
Buddha Bowl
kale | cabbage | radishes | carrots | quinoa salad | edamame beans | pecans | cucumbers | red peppers | cherry tomatoes | avocado | Craisins | honey balsamic
$15.00
Roasted Red Pepper-Smoked Gouda Bisque $6.00
Soup Du Jour $6.00
Tenderloin Tips
Angus Beef Tenderloin Tips | quartered mushrooms | garlic | red wine | veal demi-glace | garlic parsley linguine
$32.00
Honey Mustard Glazed Salmon
fresh atlantic salmon | stone ground honey mustard | jasmine rice | sautéed vegetables
$29.00
Cashew Chicken Stir Fry
chicken breast | asian vegetables | garlic | ginger | cashews | green onions | sesame garlic sauce | jasmine rice
$26.00
Sticky Finger Ribs
spice-rubbed baby back ribs | cherry bourbon bbq sauce | haystack onions | seasoned french fries | house-made cilantro-lime coleslaw
$27.00
Filet Mignon
8 oz. hand-cut Angus Tenderloin | veal demi-glace | garlic mushrooms | candied bacon | haystack onions | asiago gratin | french green beans
$48.00
Oberon Fish Tacos
mahi-mahi | Oberon Beer Batter | cilantro-lime coleslaw | golden pineapple salsa | flour tortilla
$22.00
Our Famous Lake Perch, “Fish & Chips Style”
seasoned french fries | cilantro-lime coleslaw | house-made tartar sauce
$29.00
Prime Rib
Available wednesday through saturday. Slow roasted seasoned prime rib | asiago gratin | french green beans | au jus | horseradish crema
$39.00
Bay Pointe Burger
Angus Beef Steak Burger | lettuce | tomatoes | onions | choice of cheese | brioche bun
$16.00
Memphis Sweet BBQ Bacon Burger
Angus Beef Steak Burger | applewood smoked bacon | smoked gouda cheese | onion straws | cherry bourbon bbq sauce | brioche bun
$17.00
Grouper Sandwich
wild caught grouper | Oberon Beer Batter | cilantro-lime coleslaw | house-made tartar sauce | ciabatta roll
$18.00
Prime Dip
shaved prime rib | provolone cheese | caramelized onions | garlic aioli | ciabatta roll | au jus
$18.00
Hawaiian Grilled Chicken Sandwich
grilled chicken breast | golden pineapple | applewood smoked bacon | pepper jack cheese | teriyaki aioli | brioche bun
$17.00
House Or Caesar Side Salad $6.00
Asiago Gratin Potato $7.00
Jasmine Rice $6.00
French Green Beans $7.00
Sautéed Vegetables $7.00
House-Made Cilantro-Lime Coleslaw $5.00
Bay Pointe “Cobbler In A Jar”
seasonal fruit cobbler | Plainwell Ice Cream | whipped cream
$10.00
Crème Brûlée
vanilla bean custard | caramelized sugar
$8.00
Peanut Butter Pie
Oreo Cookie Crust | peanut butter | cream cheese | Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Crumbles | whipped cream
$8.00
Vanilla Cheesecake
graham cracker crumb crust | vanilla bean cheesecake | choice of toppings: strawberry, turtle, raspberry sauce, chocolate sauce or caramel sauce
$8.00
Brownie Sundae
Ghirardelli Triple Chocolate Brownie | Plainwell Vanilla Ice Cream | chocolate syrup | whipped cream
$8.00
Flourless Chocolate Torte
flourless chocolate hazelnut torte | chocolate hazelnut ganache | chocolate sauce
$8.00
Plainwell Ice Cream
served by the scoop | ask your server for seasonal flavors
$3.00
Chocolate Martini
Baileys | Mozart Chocolate Liqueur | Western Son Vodka
$13.00
Fresca Colada
Cruzan Coconut | Tequila Rose | cream
$13.00
Key Lime Pie Martini
Licor 43 | fresh-squeezed lime juice | cream | graham cracker rim
$13.00
Banana Split Martini
Western Son | crème de banana | crème de cacao | Tequila Rose | vanilla simple
$13.00
Pink Panther
Empress Gin | fresh-squeezed lemon juice | prickly pear simple | Freixenet Prosecco
$13.00
Rum Old Fashioned
Plantation 5-year Rum | demerara simple | molasses bitters
$14.00
Hot Gypsy
Libélula Tequila | cranberry juice | fresh-squeezed lemon juice | hot honey
$13.00
Sunkissed
Maker’s Mark | Aperol | pineapple juice | lemon juice
$14.00
Painkiller
Pusser’s British Navy Rum | Coco Lopez | pineapple juice | orange juice | nutmeg
$13.00
Fresca Colada
Cruzan Coconut | Tequila Rose | cream
$13.00
Mike’s Perfect Margarita
Patrón | Grand Marnier | fresh-squeezed lemon, lime and orange juices | agave
$15.00
Patti’s Perfect Pear Martini
Grey Goose La Poire | St-Germain | fresh-squeezed lemon juice | Angostura Bitters
$15.00
Gun Lake Sangria
Meiomi Pinot Noir or La Crema Chardonnay | spiced brandy | Combier Triple Sec | orange juice | pineapple juice | lemon juice | soda
$13.00
BYO Tito’s Mule
Tito’s Handmade Vodka | fresh-squeezed lime juice | ginger beer | your choice of flavor: original, blueberry, raspberry, strawberry, kiwi, peach or prickly pear
$13.00
Mockquila Sunrise
Ritual N/A Tequila | orange juice | fresh-squeezed lime juice | n/a cherry bitters | grenadine
$11.00
Prickly Lemonade
prickly pear simple | lemonade | soda
$6.00
Bell’s Two Hearted
Bell’s Seasonal
Founders All Day IPA
Old Nation M-43
Perrin Seasonal
Short’s Bellaire Brown
Corona
Bud Light
Bud Light Lime
Budweiser
Michelob Ultra
Coors Lite
Athletic N/A, Rotating
New Holland Dragon’s Milk
Drafts
Please Ask Your Server
White Claw
New Holland Lake Life
Ciderboys Seasonal
Rosé | Veuve Du Vernay | France $56.00
Imperial Brut | Moët & Chandon | France $100.00
Nectar Impérial Rosé | Moët & Chandon | France $120.00
Cabernet Sauvignon | Post & Beam | CA $95.00
Red Blend | The Prisoner | CA $85.00
Chardonnay | Château Vitallis Pouilly-Fuissé | France $60.00
Sauvignon Blanc | Domaine De La Pauline | France $65.00
Lunch Menu
Trio Spreads & Dips
roasted red pepper hummus | smoked whitefish dip | asiago cheese spread | cucumbers | pita chips
$17.00
Maryland “Jumbo Lump” Crab Cakes
jumbo lump crabmeat | sweet bell peppers | scallions | golden pineapple salsa | honey jalapeño aioli
$18.00
Crispy Korean Pork Belly
sous vide pork belly | gochujang sauce | sesame seeds
$16.00
Truffle Fries
truffle oil | parmesan cheese | sea salt | roasted garlic aioli | parsley
$12.00
Chicken Caesar Salad
chicken breast | romaine | shaved parmesan cheese | caesar dressing | house-made croutons | cherry tomatoes
$17.00
Bay Pointe Chop Salad
romaine | iceberg | radicchio | diced red onions | cucumbers | fresh tomatoes | pepperoncini peppers | sun-dried tomatoes | chickpeas | provolone cheese | italian vinaigrette
$14.00
Strawberry Avocado Caprese Salad
mixed greens | fresh mozzarella | cherry tomatoes | avocado | strawberries | extra virgin olive oil | aged balsamic reduction
$15.00
Buddha Bowl
kale | cabbage | radishes | carrots | quinoa salad | edamame beans | pecans | cucumbers | red peppers | cherry tomatoes | avocado | Craisins | honey balsamic
$15.00
Bay Pointe Burger
Angus Beef Steak Burger | lettuce | tomatoes | onions | choice of cheese | brioche bun
$16.00
Memphis Sweet BBQ Bacon Burger
Angus Beef Steak Burger | applewood smoked bacon | smoked gouda cheese | onion straws | cherry bourbon bbq sauce | brioche bun
$17.00
Grouper Sandwich
wild caught grouper | Oberon Beer Batter | cilantro-lime coleslaw | house-made tartar sauce | ciabatta roll
$18.00
Prime Dip
shaved prime rib | provolone cheese | caramelized onions | garlic aioli | ciabatta roll | au jus
$18.00
Hawaiian Grilled Chicken Sandwich
grilled chicken breast | golden pineapple | applewood smoked bacon | pepper jack cheese | teriyaki aioli | brioche bun
$17.00
Oberon Fish Tacos
mahi-mahi | Oberon Beer Batter | cilantro-lime coleslaw | golden pineapple salsa | flour tortilla
$22.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reservations: opentable.com

Reviews

Brad Duff
Awesome place on the water very good service our waiter was on point with everything we sat on the deck overlooking the water great view food was good and didn’t take very long I highly recommend this place of your ever in Shelbyville should definitely check them out

… more

jesse k
First time visiting and I didn’t even know this place existed. It was like a little hidden gem off of Gun Lake. The perch was amazing and I loved the strawberry salad as well.

… more

Ruby Williams
Attended a wedding that was held here and although it was a 2-hour drive it was well worth it! Absolutely stunning views of the lake. Fantastic service. And a well maintained property!

… more

Andrew Boss
Burger and sweet potato fries were great. Atmosphere and service were top notch. The head chef was not there, which may have something to do with my next statement. Tenderloin tip pasta was flavorless and dry. Had to ask for more sauce to make it palatable. It shouldn’t be on the menu if that was how it always is, so maybe I just got a bad making of it.

… more

Hannah
It seemed like the kitchen was inexperienced. We ordered the salmon and weren’t asked about how done we wanted it and it came rare and cold in the middle (and was not sushi grade). The prime rib was supposed to come with a horseradish cream sauce but they were out, didn’t tell us they were out, and then when we asked they sent containers of plain horseradish. The view was great and the waitstaff were friendly.

… more

Alex Hall
I had two Corona’s and fish tacos for $37 including tip. I sat on the porch overlooking the lake. The atmosphere was lovely but the food had room for improvement. The fish tacos were not real crispy or flavorful. The portion was good sized but the fish in one of the three tacos was grey and hard instead of white and fluffy. The servers were very friendly but it took a considerable amount of time even to receive simple items such as bottled beer.

… more

Aria Edwards
It’s okay. Very overpriced except the soups. 10/10 decor and staff but food was not the greatest for what was paid for. Soup de jour was also the signature soup (the only other soup on the menu) and I found that super weird. Soup was gritty in texture. Good cheese curds though.

… more

Steven Wood
I was very impressed with the staff and management at Bay Pointe. It was here that I asked my fiancée to marry me last weekend. Management got us a table on the patio. I called the day before to ask about where to propose and the staff was very helpful. Izzy and Hannah were great with suggestions of where and when to propose and even took pictures and a video for us. It was a magical moment by the coy pond with a light drizzle happening at the same time. I would definitely recommend this spot as very romantic. The management even sent out champagne and chocolate strawberries with the word “Congrats” written in chocolate drizzle on the plate, which was a very sweet touch. We were impressed and very thankful for all the help in making this a special moment for us. A huge thank you to Izzy, Hannah and the Management for going above and beyond.

… more

Yamin Cornell
Fancy and delish food! Will definitely go back, good quality, totally enjoyed my meal there.

… more

Maria Noto Cassada
Great ambiance summer, spring, winter, or fall. Love boating in to their restaurant. Food is disappointing, over priced, and service isn’t fabulous. There is great potential but the owners seem more interested in making money on wedding venues than creating a good tasting affordable menu. Love the drinks but the only thing I like on the menu is their wings and truffle fries. We are local and wish we could go here to enjoy great food that would match the ambiance.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions