High-end steaks & seafood in the elegant interior of a renovated theater house built in 1863. Based on 8 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price
Address:
16 N Chestnut St, New Paltz, NY 12561
Reviews
Edward Stypulkoski
My wife and I stopped at Barnaby’s Steakhouse on a Saturday for lunch. We walked through the door about 5 minutes after noon. I think there was only one other couple in the place, so we were not too sure what to expect, being first time customers. The waiter was very pleasant. I ordered the fish and chips…it was by far the best I ever had. The fish was cooked perfectly and lightly battered. It was flaky and not over powered by the batter. The steak fries that came with it were also top notch, not overly salted or greasy. This dish also came with a fresh house salad. I never had a salad served with an order of Fish&Chips anywhere else. My wife had the claims casino which she thoroughly enjoyed. She didn’t even let me sample one. The atmosphere was great, no blaring music. The waiter was attentive but not bothersome. We didn’t have to wait for the check , a pet peeve of mine. We will difinately return, next time for dinner.
… more
Anne W.
Got the steak sandwich, recommended to me. I would happily recommend it. The steak was very high quality and the bread was delicious. Steak fries are standard. Great old-fashioned atmosphere.
… more
Tonie Schmitt
One of the best meals I have ever had. A Waldorf salad worth coming back for and a country chicken cooked to perfection.
… more
Josh Dillon
Best variety and atmosphere in New Paltz. I often take my guests here. In a neat historic building.
… more
Tisa Loewen
Expensive, but delicious! The upstairs is beautiful and would be perfect to rent for an engagement or office party.
… more
Maashes Caisteal
Good selection menu wise and at the Bar. I had a rare Tbone, perfect. Good attentive service
… more
mickey farmer
Real nice place. Not cheap to eat there. Food is good. I have been there several times.
… more
… View more