Based on 240 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
30 Hancock Harbor Rd, Greenwich, NJ 08323
Phone: (856) 455-2610
Website: http://www.hancockharbor.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sarah Kelli
I came for crab cakes but the shrimp tacos stole my heart. We arrived at sunset after a quiet drive through the swamp to the buzz of a band playing live music and orange hues lighting up the docks through our car windows. As soon as we open the car doors, we realized that the buzz was in fact human-eating flies likely evolved after decades of living too close to the nuclear plant. After battling said gnats while my toddler lost her shoes on the way in, we were beyond starving and carrying the battle scars of carnivorous flies. Thankfully, the friendly atmosphere and aromas satiated our nerves long enough to browse the tasteful menu. After tasting the menu, even my one year old thought everything was delectable! The tacos were definitely top-notch and win for culinary creativity, the crabby fries were actually quite amicable when eaten, and their succulent flavor was a gracious compliment to any entree. The pizza was satisfactory and the Alfredo and palatable although it lacked in the waves of flavor that the other dishes possessed. This is definitely a gem of south Jersey and well worth the drive….. possibly even worth risking life and limb through the gauntlet of gnats.
… more
David E Hunnings Jr
Beautiful location on the river. Has inside dining, outdoor bar area and entertainment (check scheduling).
… more
Danielle Cartier
Very cool local nook to eat/drink near the bay!! You can pull your boat up dockside from the Cohansey River and grab a bite. We had a great date night and ate outside at the picnic tables by the outside tiki bar. Great selection of draft beers. Absolutely loved the stuffed pineapple poke bowl appetizer. Highly recommend!
… more
SJT Tripoli
We had a wonderful meal. Service was fantastic. The select desserts were homemade (from scratch) this is a true fact since I bake. I had the beef brisket sandwich which melted in my mouth. The fried green tomatoes were very good along with the crab and cheese old bay fries. This is definitely a well hidden gem. I have read some of the reviews about this establishment and the negative ones are truly hard to believe, there was nothingnegativeto comment. The water views just beautiful. We truly enjoyed our visit and will be returning. Worth my hour ride.
… more
Justin
Came to this spot with our family. It’s a cute restaurant nestled in the middle of no where. Lots of boats and a brand new bar.
… more
Alura Cein
We were searching for a historical area to tour around and ended up out in the middle of nowhere, not quite what we had in mind. However we didn’t want the entire road trip to be a bus and so we looked up local places to sit down and catch a bite to eat. We found this restaurant located on the shore of Cohancy River out in the middle of nowhere in New Jersey. There’s nothing out there, literally. The only things that we could find were just fields and fields of growing corn. It was actually rather surprising to find a restaurant like this! When we first arrived, we saw a bunch of all the boats that were stored on the lot which gave it a pretty authentic but eccentric vibe. Sort of like an old junkyard but for boats. It was very unique. You can’t really judge a book by the cover and so pulling into the lot further we found the restaurant. It was actually very similar to that I have a boating club. Inside, it had a “Margaritaville” like setting, And during the time of day that we arrived it was pretty empty. However outside they had a bar area set up, and there was a stage with a band getting ready to play live. We even had a very unique style bar which was made out of an old boat. They had little areas make bonfires and really cool areas to sit down around them. In the river there were a lot of other boats with boat owners just relaxing. It’s really a nice atmosphere and I truly enjoyed the restaurant and it’s set up itself. A really good point was that their dessert was rather tasty. They had a really great chocolate cake. Their drinks were also pretty awesome. I had a mai tai. The service was also rather quick but to be honest with you the only negative thing about the restaurant was the menu. I ordered some kind of shrimp spaghetti stuff and I didn’t really enjoy it. Just seem like a bunch of egg noodles with some spaghetti and clam sauce slept in there with some shrimp. Other than that I think it was pretty good experience and worth going to. You just have to be very careful what you order. I think they had some really great selections of steak and shrimp as well as any other fish and some burgers that would probably very worth trying. Overall I really loved this restaurant.
… more
Julia Carr
I have been trying to get out to the Bait Box for what seems like forever. We finally made it out and frankly, we were disappointed.
… more
Joseph Walder
I was on my way to Cape May by boat. I stopped here. The service was impeccable. I did not eat but the food looked and smelled incredible. Awesome people work here. I’ll be back for lunch on my next boat trip from Westville to Cape May. Thanks guys. You’re awesome people.
… more
Aidan Molloy
The bait box is like the MBL, it’s opening marks the beginning of a hopefully good summer, a place to forget the year of covid 19 that for many changed a lot of life’s, we are truly sorry for those that did loose people in this pandemic.
… more
matthew lucas
Great location, good food, good live music, good servers,
… more
… View more