Small, modest counter-service pizza joint featuring classic pies, BBQ ribs & chicken wings. Based on 826 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
5339 English Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46219
Phone: (317) 638-3663
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 3 PM–1 AM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
3 PM–1 AM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 3 PM–1 AM |
| Wednesday | 3 PM–1 AM |
| Thursday | 3 PM–2 AM |
| Friday | 3 PM–2 AM |
| Saturday | 3 PM–2 AM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tony Owens
Update, 5/25/2023
… more
AgainsTtheGraiN
I’ve been a fan of this place in the past few years. I’d have to say they’ve grown to quite an expensive place. I guess for the late night convienance lol. But, here’s a pic of a $35 dollar Philly cheese steak pizza I called and politely asked and paid for without question… Thank you AUNT POLLY’S for ripping off someone whose put good money into your company. No entitlement.
… more
jordan mathews
We love aunt Polly’s pizza and it’s a hit every time for every occasion! Along with great food they have amazing people there that are always there for everyone! They provided pizza for my Uncle Gary Cockrill’s Celebration of life we had for everyone and it was amazing! We appreciate it so much! My uncle worked for Aunt Polly’s for so long and they showed their love and support to us!
… more
Carolyn Phelps
We loved your food service and everything else. Your prices are reasonable for the quality of items you have. We loved it all. We are short in money at the time but we will be back as soon as we catch up. Thanks for yummy food and sweet staff. ❤️
… more
Hartsock wayne
I just moved my sister and her family to the east side, I drove by this place late at night. She was blown away. They deserve a 10 for being so friendly, being open so late. Another 10 across the board for the best rak of ribs in the city. Nothing like a good late night snack from a perfect little hole in the wall.
… more
zach bone
They were very nice and accommodating but their quality of food is sub par. As someone who has been in the restaurant business I can tell they are using the cheap and lowest quality ingredients. I would love to support local business but when you charge wood fired gourmet pizza prices and get Wal mart quality ingredients I would rather buy frozen pizzas.
… more
Reaks honesty Adams
Let me tell you… this place is absolutely Great. I order a medium supreme pizza and ten wings. I didn’t expect the pizza to be so big!!! Everything was fresh. My wings were battered can you believe it!!! Golden brown batter like I cook at home. Guess what I didn’t get a heart burn. The staff was friendly a natural friendly very pleasant professional. I would have given 10 stars. I would have took a picture, but I ate that food so fast!
… more
Simon Kemp
They delivered to us at midnight and the wings are hands down the best I’ve had!!! Better than Hooters and BW3!!! Breadsticks and cheese are also fire!!!
… more
R V
This was my first time here and I was NOT disappointed. We got a large 2 topping pizza, order of breadsticks and 2L for a VERY affordable price. I had heard many good things about Aunt Polly’s but for whatever reason had not tried it yet. I’m kicking myself for not going here sooner. The staff was also extremely nice and friendly. I felt right at home as soon as I arrived. I can’t say enough good things about this place. I can’t wait to go back and try their other items!
… more
Geneva Faubion
Really liked their food. Ordered dinner Friday night for the family cost me $50.05. They ran my card twice I called they took care of it then the next day they charged me again the lady wanted to argue with me on the phone so I went in showed my transactions and they voided that charge off then today guess what another $50.05 was charged again. I called my bank to take care of the issue this time. Needless to say I WILL NOT BE DO BUSSINESS with aunt pollys again.
… more
… View more