Old-school institution featuring classic American steak & seafood dishes, plus a soup & salad bar. Based on 681 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ No delivery
Address:
E4885 US-14, Spring Green, WI 53588
Phone: (608) 588-2521
Website: http://www.arthurssupperclub.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
bethany Starkweather
Was a little surprised by the atmosphere. Was Arthur’s court themed, not bad just was anticipating a little fancier. All staff were very nice and bubbly. Our waitress was very good juggling 4 or 5 tables along with a large table of 12. Food was very good, a little pricey but very good.
… more
Megan Hahlbeck
We had a wonderful visit to Arthur’s! We made a reservation and waited a bit at the bar and had 2 delicious bourbon old fashioneds. The rolls were just okay, but the cinnamon butter was a wonderful touch. We ordered fried pickles for an appetizer, the prime rib and fish fry for dinner and added the salad bar, and had the Nutty Arthur and cheesecake for dessert. We tried the Wisconsin old fashioned as well, and those were great! The prime rib was superb. The waitress was very friendly and attentive. Nice atmosphere, definitely had the supper club vibe. Only slight drawbacks were the soup at the salad bar was room temperature at most and the coleslaw for the fish fry never came. I wish I could do 4.5 start! Despite that, I would highly recommend!
… more
Fred Toney
Very disappointed in the dining experience. We made a reservation two hours before an APT performance on a Saturday night. By the time the food arrived, we had to quickly eat what we could and run so we could make the performance. While the food was delicious, the service was terrible. It was our first and last visit to Arthur’s. We’d have been better off going to Culver’s across the street.
… more
Emma Almy
It was our first time at a supper club last night and Arthur’s set a very high bar. The host was very nice and our server Lisa was great. Our drinks were delicious and strong. The crab cakes were great. We each got the NY Strip with toppings (blue cheese crust or merlot mushrooms with sauce) and a potato (loaded baked potato or mashed potato with gravy) and they were AMAZING. Probably the best steak dinner we’ve ever had. Dinner ended with cheesecake with strawberry topping or a slice of the key lime pie. Everything was out of this world. I would say the price was very fair for the amount of food we got and the excellent quality. We’ll be back soon! Thank you!
… more
Bruce J
Classic WI supper club. Hostess was helpful and accommodated us without reservations. Bar serves Wisconsin standards in addition to the “what’ll you have”. The prime rib was meltingly tender and required alternating bites with either jus or the creamed horseradish. The gravy on the mashed potatoes has a depth I’ve never encountered before – so good.
… more
Lynn Miller
We waited forever to get our food. The manager that night came to us and apologized that our waiter, who was new that night and had too many tables, didn’t turn in our ticket for our food! We were racing to our show at the Ametucan Theater, which was amazing! The manager didn’t offer us anything to compensate. Nothing was taken off the bill!! Suggestion: make a 5:30 reservation if you are going to an 8:00 performance!
… more
Deb Megonigle
Ist time here. Very friendly staff, great drinks and reasonable prices. My prime rib was very good as was my husband’s sirloin. Only negative was dry rools. I would have given 5 stars if the bread/rolls were good.
… more
rando vids
we were in Wisconsin looking at a property and the realtor recommend Arthur’s Supper club. A busy place but the service was great. Waitress was attentive and friendly. The food was really good. I had salmon and my husband had prime rib. We both enjoyed our dinner.
… more
Jenelle Powers
Such an amazing place!! Allllll the positives- incredibly friendly staff, salad bar, peanut butter martini, cookie desert. Literally everything was perfect
… more
Sonia Stromberg
We waited over 40 minutes at our table. The manager Kris ignored us and apologized to wvery table but ours. Worst manager ever! Even heard her blaming her new staff instead of helping. Poor new kid didn’t stand a chance
… more
… View more