Based on 127 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.9 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2452 NY-207, Campbell Hall, NY 10916
Phone: (845) 636-4818
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Alina Cedillo
This is by far the best pizza in NY! Every pie is made fresh by Tony, who has been in the pizza business for 45 years! He and his staff are so friendly and give you the best pizza experience. We came to visit from California and we’d travel back just to have his pizza and visit his restaurant. It has a nice spacious dining room for friends and family to get together. Please visit if you’re able to. Thank you Tony and staff!
… more
Lisa Pellegrino
My very first bite, I knew something was different. I grew up having pizza from NYC, so I know good pizza. This pizza is so good, I had to get a third slice! I got the special which is 2 cheese slices and a fountain soda for $8.50. By far best deal in the state. You can taste the quality in every bite, the cheese is so rich and buttery, the sauce is the perfect consistency and freshness, and the dough is the kind where you eat the crust. Just absolutely stellar. This is a destination pizzeria, they don’t make em like this anymore. Plus Tony is such a nice guy. Wow What a hidden gem this place is!
… more
Amy Coopersmith
Antonella’s is the best! We recently moved to the area and have been searching for a great pizzeria. We’ve tried a few popular spots, but nothing compares to Antonella’s. When we first drove up, we thought the place looked ordinary. But once inside, we realized the food is extraordinary! The regular cheese pie is so full of flavor with a crunchy delicious crust. The Grandma slice has nice chunky tomato sauce and plenty of cheese, again with a nice crunchy crust. The chicken parm roll with a side of marinara is a real stand out. We can’t wait to try some of the dinner specials. Anthony and the staff are so friendly and professional. So glad we found Antonella’s!
… more
Linda Sewitt
Not much I can add from all the other glowing reviews. My son was so lucky to discover this restaurant and Tony, the friendly and generous owner. He took me there when I was visiting and I cannot wait to go back. The food is fabulous. Best sauce ever, wish he bottled it. Everything is fresh, flavorful and you can tell it’s high quality and Tony puts love into his cooking. So reasonably priced with huge portions. I recommend everything on the menu. There were even patrons from the Bronx dining which tells you everything! My new absolute favorite place!
… more
monica carbajosa
Amazing Pizza! Service was amazing, workers were extremely friendly as well. The pizza wasn’t greasy at ALL. Not a single bit, I highly recommend this pizzeria to anyone looking for a good pizzeria. Also, not to mention the owner was super friendly and welcoming! Been to NYC gotten pizza, but NOTHING can in NYC as of where I have been can compare to here.
… more
George Sewitt
A small business with amazing homestyle food. The pizza is the best and the lasagna is better than the best homemade. I’m using the word best alot and it still doesn’t do it justice. Tony makes everything from scratch and it shows. He is very friendly, loves what he’s doing and is eager to please. Why don’t you give Antonella’s a try. You’ll be glad you did. This review is from a Brooklyn guy. Who has eaten great Italian food all his life.
… more
Keene International Market
What a great experience! Owner originally from the Bronx and super welcoming. Food was so good. We bought extra to take back to NH with us. This will be our new go-to spot when we travel through here again.
… more
Thomas Culhane
By far the best pizza in Orange County, I recently moved out of the Bronx and was looking for a good pie and, lo and behold. right in Campbell Hall I find Antonella’s Pizza. Tony, the owner, is the real deal and flings a great pie. The chicken parm and the Cannoli are equal to Arthur Ave, which, if you know Arthur Avenue, is saying a lot. Do yourself a favor and stop in and say hello to Tony and grab some good authentic Italian food- you will be very happy you did.
… more
Melanie Cedillo
This pepperoni pizza was delicious! Crust was crispy and plenty of toppings and cheese for a delicious pie. We met Tony who was working the counter by himself and was making all the orders that were coming in. He was FAST and definitely knew what he was doing. He said he has been doing this for 45 years. Come here for a slice!
… more
Leo Klepacki
Food is outstanding especially the rolls you can’t beat them. Service is great they do more then just take care of you they treat you like your family. 10/10 place would definitely recommend it to anyone
… more
… View more