Antioch Pizza Shop - Paddock Lake, WI Menu

It all started from a recipe shared by friends. The result is a pizzeria that has provided local customers with delicious meals since the doors opened. We continually strive to make the freshest pizza with natural ingredients while not skimping on portions. Being the leading pizzeria in Antioch, we love keeping our customers happy with friendly service and top quality products. We are famous for our double-decker pizza that is loaded with melted mozzarella cheese and fresh toppings. Our crispy thin crust is popular among our regular customers. Introducing our “Chicago Style Stuffed Pizza” in 2011, we continue to explore menu options while maintaining the same great taste and quality our customers expect.

Based on 456 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

Antioch Pizza Shop - Paddock Lake, WI 53168

Address:
24730 75th St, Salem, WI 53168

Phone: (262) 586-5544

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Sunday	10:30 AM–8 PM
Monday (Labor Day)	10:30 AM–8 PM Hours might differ
Tuesday	10:30 AM–8 PM
Wednesday	10:30 AM–8 PM
Thursday	10:30 AM–8 PM
Friday	10:30 AM–9 PM
Saturday	10:30 AM–9 PM

ONLINE ORDERING – STUFFED PIZZA TUESDAY
12″ Stuffed STUFFED IS ONLY AVAILABLE ON TUESDAYS two layers of dough stuffed with loads of mozzarella cheese topped with a delicious stuffed sauce (feeds 1-2) * Please anticipate an additional 10-15 minutes on top of your quoted Pickup Time when ordering this item	$18.20
14″ Stuffed STUFFED IS ONLY AVAILABLE ON TUESDAYS two layers of dough stuffed with loads of mozzarella cheese topped with a delicious stuffed sauce (feeds 2-3) * Please anticipate an additional 10-15 minutes on top of your quoted Pickup Time when ordering this item	$22.50
16″ Stuffed STUFFED IS ONLY AVAILABLE ON TUESDAYS two layers of dough stuffed with loads of mozzarella cheese topped with a delicious stuffed sauce (feeds 3-4) * Please anticipate an additional 10-15 minutes on top of your quoted Pickup Time when ordering this item	$25.90
ONLINE ORDERING
2 Slices & Drink 2 pizza slices & drink • DAILY SPECIAL FLAVORS • monday•bbq chicken / tuesday•stuffed pepperoni / wednesday•western / thursday•buffalo chicken / friday•bacon double cheeseburger	$6.00
1 Slice, Salad & Drink 1 slice, small salad & drink • DAILY SPECIAL FLAVORS • monday•bbq chicken / tuesday•stuffed pepperoni / wednesday•western / thursday•buffalo chicken / friday•bacon double cheeseburger	$7.00
2 Hot Dog Special 100% Vienna Beef hot dog topped just the way you like it & includes a small fry and fountain drink. Trimmings include mustard, relish, onion, pickle, tomato & celery salt. Ketchup and peppers on request	$9.50
Italian Beef Special homemade tender Italian Beef on top of our fresh baked bread with the option to add your choice of peppers and cheese, includes small fry & fountain drink	$12.55
Cheeseburger Special juicy 1/3 pound cheeseburger on a gourmet bun loaded with your favorite toppings, includes small fry & fountain drink EVERYTHING includes: ketchup, mustard, lettuce, tomato, pickle	$9.50
Hamburger Special juicy 1/3 pound burger on a gourmet bun loaded with your favorite toppings, includes small fry & fountain drink EVERYTHING includes: ketchup, mustard, lettuce, tomato, pickle	$8.50
Meatball Special Three jumbo Italian meatballs on top of our fresh baked bread smothered in our special marinara sauce with the option to add your choice of cheese and peppers, includes small fry & fountain drink	$9.50
Chicken Sandwich Special Tender grilled or crispy chicken breast sandwich on a gourmet bun with your favorite toppings, includes small fry & fountain drink EVERYTHING includes: lettuce, tomato & mayonnaise	$9.50
Italian Sausage Special Chicago Italian sausage link on top of our fresh baked bread with the option to add your choice of peppers and cheese, includes small fry & fountain drink	$10.10
Steak Sandwich Special thick cut steak on top of toasted fresh baked garlic bread with grilled onions & melted mozzarella, includes small fry & fountain drink	$15.35
Italian Beef & Sausage Combo Special homemade tender Italian Beef and Italian sausage link on top of our fresh baked bread with the option to add your choice of peppers and cheese, includes small fry & fountain drink	$15.30
12″ Thin Crust crispy thin crust 12″ feeds 1-2 Get a free 12″ Cheese with the purchase of an 18″ Pizza, using the promo code: FREE CHEESE (BOTH pizzas must be in your cart for the code to work)	$14.70
14″ Thin Crust crispy thin crust 14″ feeds 2-3	$17.65
16″ Thin Crust crispy thin crust 16″ feeds 3-4	$20.50
18″ Thin Crust crispy thin crust 18″ feeds 4-5	$22.95
12″ Pan thick buttery crust loaded with mozzarella (feeds 1-2) * Please anticipate an additional 10-15 minutes on top of your quoted Pickup Time when ordering this item	$18.20
14″ Pan thick buttery crust loaded with mozzarella (feeds 2-3) * Please anticipate an additional 10-15 minutes on top of your quoted Pickup Time when ordering this item	$22.50
16″ Pan thick buttery crust loaded with mozzarella (feeds 3-4) * Please anticipate an additional 10-15 minutes on top of your quoted Pickup Time when ordering this item	$25.90
12″ Double Decker two layers of pizza loaded with a ton of mozzarella and your favorite toppings (feeds 1-2) * Please anticipate an additional 10-15 minutes on top of your quoted Pickup Time when ordering this item	$19.45
14″ Double Decker two layers of pizza loaded with a ton of mozzarella and your favorite toppings (feeds 2-3) * Please anticipate an additional 10-15 minutes on top of your quoted Pickup Time when ordering this item	$23.60
16″ Double Decker two layers of pizza loaded with a ton of mozzarella and your favorite toppings (feeds 3-4) * Please anticipate an additional 10-15 minutes on top of your quoted Pickup Time when ordering this item	$27.60
18″ Double Decker two layers of pizza loaded with a ton of mozzarella and your favorite toppings (feeds 4-5) * Please anticipate an additional 10-15 minutes on top of your quoted Pickup Time when ordering this item	$31.75
12″ Stromboli TRADITIONAL STROMBOLI comes with mozzarella cheese, Canadian bacon, pepperoni, mushroom, onion & green pepper with pizza sauce on the side. OR CUSTOMIZE YOUR OWN (feeds 1-2)	$18.20
14″ Stromboli TRADITIONAL STROMBOLI comes with mozzarella cheese, Canadian bacon, pepperoni, mushroom, onion & green pepper with pizza sauce on the side. OR CUSTOMIZE YOUR OWN (feeds 2-3)	$22.50
16″ Stromboli TRADITIONAL STROMBOLI comes with mozzarella cheese, Canadian bacon, pepperoni, mushroom, onion & green pepper with pizza sauce on the side. OR CUSTOMIZE YOUR OWN (feeds 3-4)	$25.90
Gluten Free Our gluten free pizzas are made with gluten free crust cooked in the same kitchen as food containing gluten. Cross contamination may occur. Anyone with serious allergy to gluten are advised not to consume our gluten free pizza. (feeds 1)	$16.00
Heart Pizza send the ones you love a HEART PIZZA available any day – high demand on Valentines Day add a message for additional charge	$19.50
12″ BBQ Chicken sweet & tangy bbq sauce, chicken and mozzarella (feeds 1-2)	$19.65
14″ BBQ Chicken sweet & tangy bbq sauce, chicken and mozzarella (feeds 2-3)	$22.83
16″ BBQ Chicken sweet & tangy bbq sauce, chicken and mozzarella (feeds 3-4)	$26.13
18″ BBQ Chicken sweet & tangy bbq sauce, chicken and mozzarella (feeds 4-5)	$29.14
12″ Buffalo Chicken spicy buffalo sauce, chicken and mozzarella (feeds 1-2)	$19.65
14″ Buffalo Chicken spicy buffalo sauce, chicken and mozzarella (feeds 2-3)	$22.83
16″ Buffalo Chicken spicy buffalo sauce, chicken and mozzarella (feeds 3-4)	$26.13
18″ Buffalo Chicken spicy buffalo sauce, chicken and mozzarella (feeds 4-5)	$29.14
12″ Supreme sausage, mushroom, onion & green pepper (feeds 1-2)	$23.50
14″ Supreme sausage, mushroom, onion & green pepper (feeds 2-3)	$26.85
16″ Supreme sausage, mushroom, onion & green pepper (feeds 3-4)	$30.50
18″ Supreme sausage, mushroom, onion & green pepper (feeds 4-5)	$33.95
12″ Western sausage, bacon, onion, cheddar, mozzarella & BBQ sauce (feeds 1-2)	$23.50
14″ Western sausage, bacon, onion, cheddar, mozzarella & BBQ sauce (feeds 2-3)	$26.85
16″ Western sausage, bacon, onion, cheddar, mozzarella & BBQ sauce (feeds 3-4)	$30.50
18″ Western sausage, bacon, onion, cheddar, mozzarella & BBQ sauce (feeds 4-5)	$33.95
12″ Vegetable green pepper, onion, mushroom & tomato (feeds 1-2)	$23.50
14″ Vegetable green pepper, onion, mushroom & tomato (feeds 2-3)	$26.85
16″ Vegetable green pepper, onion, mushroom & tomato (feeds 3-4)	$30.50
18″ Vegetable green pepper, onion, mushroom & tomato (feeds 4-5)	$33.95
12″ Bacon Double Cheeseburger hamburger, bacon, mozzarella & cheddar cheese (feeds 1-2)	$23.50
14″ Bacon Double Cheeseburger hamburger, bacon, mozzarella & cheddar cheese (feeds 2-3)	$26.85
16″ Bacon Double Cheeseburger hamburger, bacon, mozzarella & cheddar cheese (feeds 3-4)	$30.50
18″ Bacon Double Cheeseburger hamburger, bacon, mozzarella & cheddar cheese (feeds 4-5)	$33.95
12″ ITALIAN BEEF Homemade slow roasted Italian beef topped with your favorite peppers and loaded with mozzarella. (feeds 1-2)	$19.65
14″ ITALIAN BEEF Homemade slow roasted Italian beef topped with your favorite peppers and loaded with mozzarella. (feeds 2-3)	$22.83
16″ ITALIAN BEEF Homemade slow roasted Italian beef topped with your favorite peppers and loaded with mozzarella. (feeds 3-4)	$26.13
18″ ITALIAN BEEF Homemade slow roasted Italian beef topped with your favorite peppers and loaded with mozzarella. (feeds 4-5)	$29.14
12″ Hawaiian Canadian bacon and sweet pineapple (feeds 1-2)	$19.10
14″ Hawaiian Canadian bacon and sweet pineapple (feeds 2-3)	$22.25
16″ Hawaiian Canadian bacon and sweet pineapple (feeds 3-4)	$25.50
18″ Hawaiian Canadian bacon and sweet pineapple (feeds 4-5)	$28.45
12″ Meat Lovers sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, bacon (feeds 1-2)	$23.50
14″ Meat Lovers sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, bacon (feeds 2-3)	$26.85
16″ Meat Lovers sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, bacon (feeds 3-4)	$30.50
18″ Meat Lovers sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, bacon (feeds 4-5)	$33.95
12″ BLT crispy bacon cooked with mozzarella topped with fresh iceberg lettuce, diced tomatoes and mayo (feeds 1-2)	$23.50
14″ BLT crispy bacon cooked with mozzarella topped with fresh iceberg lettuce, diced tomatoes and mayo (feeds 2-3)	$26.85
16″ BLT crispy bacon cooked with mozzarella topped with fresh iceberg lettuce, diced tomatoes and mayo (feeds 3-4)	$30.50
18″ BLT crispy bacon cooked with mozzarella topped with fresh iceberg lettuce, diced tomatoes and mayo (feeds 4-5)	$33.95
SHAMROCK Pizza Celebrate St. Patrick’s Day with a thin crust Shamrock shaped pizza!	$19.50
MESSAGE PIZZA Add a personalized message to any pizza	$6.25
Small French Fries french fries cooked golden brown ready for dipping – choice of thin cut straight fries or crinkle cut	$2.10
Large French Fries shareable portion of french fries, cooked golden brown ready for dipping – choice of thin cut straight fries or crinkle cut	$3.70
Onion Rings thick-cut onion rings are made from whole white onions, lightly battered highlighting the onion’s natural sweetness	$5.20
Appetizer Sampler Includes: onion rings, mozzarella sticks, jalapeno poppers & fried mushrooms with a side of ranch and marinara	$13.10
7 Piece BONE IN Wings hot • mild • sweet chili • garlic parmesan • honey bbq	$10.45
12 Piece BONE IN Wings hot • mild • sweet chili • garlic parmesan • honey bbq	$15.75
1/2 Lb BONELESS Wings hot • mild • sweet chili • garlic parmesan • honey bbq	$9.90
1 Lb. BONELESS Wings hot • mild • sweet chili • garlic parmesan • honey bbq	$15.50
Fried Mushrooms Plump and tasty hand-breaded mushrooms fried just right, includes a side of Ranch dressing or marinara for dipping.	$5.80
Chicken Fingers (5) 5 breaded chicken tenders served with your choice of dipping sauce	$7.60
Garlic Bread fresh baked bread topped with homemade garlic butter spread and toasted to perfection	$2.95
Garlic Bread W/Cheese fresh baked bread topped with homemade garlic butter spread topped with melted mozzarella and toasted to perfection	$3.95
Cheese Fries Shareable portion of french fries, cooked golden brown topped with creamy melted cheddar cheese- choice of thin cut straight fries or crinkle cut	$4.75
Mozzarella Sticks (6) 6 sticks of mozzarella cheese coated in seasoned Italian breadcrumbs, then deep fried until golden brown served with a choice of ranch or marinara for dipping	$6.65
Pizza Puff hand held deep-fried dough pocket filled with cheese, tomato sauce, and sausage and pepperoni	$4.25
Cheese Breadsticks (4) 4 jumbo mozzarella cheese-stuffed breadsticks that are deep fried and served with marinara	$6.55
Bacon Cheese Fries Shareable portion of french fries, cooked golden brown topped with creamy melted cheddar cheese and crispy bacon bits- choice of thin cut straight fries or crinkle cut	$5.75
Jalapeno Poppers (6) 6 jalapeno peppers stuffed with cream cheese or cheddar cheese	$6.65
Ranch On Side	$1.00
Cheese On Side	$1.00
BBQ Sauce On Side	$1.00
Marinara On Side	$1.00
Hot Dog 100% Vienna Beef hot dogs include fries. Trimmings include mustard, relish, onion, pickle, tomato & celery salt. Ketchup and peppers on request	$4.25
Chicken Sandwich Tender grilled or crispy chicken breast sandwich on a gourmet bun with your favorite toppings EVERYTHING includes: lettuce, tomato & mayonnaise	$7.75
Italian Beef homemade tender Italian Beef on top of our fresh baked bread with the option to add your choice of peppers and cheese	$10.45
1/3 Lb Cheeseburger juicy 1/3 pound cheeseburger EVERYTHING includes: ketchup, mustard, lettuce, tomato, pickle	$7.70
Double Cheeseburger Two juicy 1/3 pound cheeseburger piled high EVERYTHING includes: ketchup, mustard, lettuce, tomato, pickle	$9.75
Cheese Dog 100% Vienna Beef hot dog topped with melted cheddar cheese sauce EVERYTHING includes: mustard, relish, onion, pickle, tomato & celery salt. Ketchup and peppers upon request	$4.90
Italian Sausage Chicago Italian sausage link on top of our fresh baked bread with the option to add your choice of peppers and cheese	$8.00
1/3 Lb Hamburger juicy 1/3 pound burger EVERYTHING includes: ketchup, mustard, lettuce, tomato, pickle	$7.05
Double Hamburger two juicy 1/3 pound burgers EVERYTHING includes: ketchup, mustard, lettuce, tomato, pickle	$8.85
Bacon Cheeseburger juicy 1/3 pound cheeseburger topped with crispy bacon EVERYTHING includes: ketchup, mustard, lettuce, tomato, pickle	$8.35
Bacon Double Cheeseburger Two juicy 1/3 pound cheeseburgers piled high with crispy bacon EVERYTHING includes: ketchup, mustard, lettuce, tomato, pickle	$10.75
Italian Beef & Sausage Combo homemade tender Italian Beef and Italian sausage link on top of our fresh baked bread with the option to add your choice of peppers and cheese	$13.20
Steak Sandwich thick cut steak on top of toasted fresh baked garlic bread with grilled onions & melted mozzarella	$13.25
Italian Meatball Three jumbo Italian meatballs on top of our fresh baked bread smothered in our special marinara sauce with the option to add your choice of cheese and peppers	$7.50
Small Dinner Salad crisp iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, mozzarella & croutons serves 1	$4.50
Large Dinner Salad crisp iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, mozzarella & croutons serves 1-2	$7.75
Family Dinner Salad crisp iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, mozzarella & croutons serves 2-4	$12.60
Chicken Salad grilled or crispy chicken salad loaded with fresh iceberg lettuce, topped with chicken, tomato, green pepper, onion, mushroom, cheese & croutons with a choice of dressing on the side (serves 1-2)	$10.75
Italian Salad Italian salad loaded with fresh iceberg lettuce, topped with pepperoni, ham, tomato, pepperoncini peppers, onion, black olives, cheese & croutons with a choice of dressing on the side (serves 1-2)	$11.50
Chicken Caesar Salad crisp lettuce topped with juicy chicken, homemade crutons, parmesan and caesar dressing	$10.75
Mostaccioli Mostaccioli baked in our special marinara sauce with the choice to add jumbo meatballs or Italian sausage. Get is baked with our creamy mozzarella. Includes our homemade garlic bread.	$7.90
Chicken Parmigiana Mostaccioli baked in our special marinara sauce topped with tender crispy chicken and our creamy mozzarella. Includes our homemade garlic bread.	$10.85
Shake hand dipped ice cream blended into a thick and creamy shake	$5.25
Malt hand dipped ice cream blended into a thick and creamy malt	$5.50
Cannoli crunchy Italian pastry filled with Sweet ricotta cream and chocolate chips • made fresh for each order	$4.00
Jumbo Cookie thick jumbo cookie to satisfy your sweet tooth	$2.50
Shake – PICK UP ONLY	$5.25
Malt – PICK UP ONLY	$5.50
Dessert Pizza – LIMITED TIME OFFER LIMITED TIME ONLY Chocolate Chip Dessert Pizza is chewy on the inside and crispy on the outside. Served warm. Choice of drizzle. Feeds 2-4	$7.99
20 Oz	$2.65
2 Liter	$4.25
Bottle Of Water	$2.10

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Samita Slack

Yummy Yummy Yummy. I love the hot & ready pizza slices. No wait. The chicken is good. The honey bbq sauce tastes amazing. Pure deliciousness. The icecream is omg!!! I tried m&m with oreo (never had it b4) So good I plan on returning soon even though it is a drive. It’s so worth it.

… more

Morgan Booe

We come to Antioch Pizza VERY often & have ordered their food for birthday parties for the last 5 years. The service used to be great but the staff in there has gotten less friendly & less helpful. Every time we come in there with my kids now, the staff does not even say hello. When we wait at the ice cream cooler to order ice cream, they just stand by the kitchen doors talking and don’t even say one minute or we will be right with you, nothing. I have to usually say something again for them to even come by the cooler to help us. The service has progressively gotten worse in there the last year. As far as catering for parties go, the last 4 times we ordered from them, they forgot something in our order or pick up time was way later than we expected. We always order tons of pizza and Italian beefs and they usually forget all the bread to go with it and the beef toppings. Just overall disappointed in their customer service and hope it improves.

… more

Von D

Have stopped here many times while passing through. Absolutely love the two pizzas and a drink combo. Very inexpensive way to feed the family. Food always tastes delicious. There is always something for everyone to order. Staff was nice and patient. THANK YOU for having Frank’s hot sauce available!!!! Kids love the ice cream section as well. Will continue to stop here every chance we get.

… more

Chris

2 slices 1 beverage $7, okay. 2 slices stacked on top of each other, not okay. Ate it anyhow as I was in a rush. Owners/Managers, you unintelligently set up these kids with the .06 cent flimsy economy 9” paper plates. This is on you. At least Use paper plates where two slices fit. Or buy the 9 1/2” – 10” plastic plates for dine-in customers and wash dishes. You’ll save in the long run. Good luck.

… more

Jamie Ashlin

So I now have an update… always been a great place I eat here all the time.. no problems ever it is now 7:25 and I called for delivery and she was gonna take the address and someone said nope only pick up…. I’ve always tipped well and I’m just confused I’ve ordered at 7:45 for delivery and I have a lot of family over and was gonna order 3 pizzas but idk what a bummer

… more

Joy Sundstrom

This is not our favorite Antioch Pizza. Our 1st experience was negative so we tried it again. It was very cold in the place, so we had to eat with our coats on. The tables were only big enough for the pizza, so we had to sit at separate tables.

… more

John Maki

We order from Antioch weekly and have never had a bad experience. Hands down the best pizza around. Love this place and so do the kiddos! Great job and thank you for the amazing food and extraordinary service!

… more

Patricia Banwart

Great pizza …been getting our “pies” there in Antioch since the early 70’s. Same taste in Paddock Lake

… more

Chubs69 Busch

From out of town and choose this pizza place , a little sauce but good kids ate it up . The lady on the phone was nice !

… more

Liz Lois

We just picked up our pizza which we asked for it to be well done. Crust is barely cooked and very chewy.

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Antioch Pizza Shop – Paddock Lake, WI Menu – Salem, WI

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Related:

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions