Based on 122 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1275 Sussex Turnpike, Randolph, NJ 07869
Phone: (973) 933-2929
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Chuck Mound
Was not a planned stop for the Pizza Hunters App, Hunting the Best Slice of Pizza, but thankfully the Pizza Gods sent us to this amazing Pizzeria. Two women behind the counter in a Male dominated industry deliver great customer service with a great slice of Pizza. Using the basic formula for success with fresh ingredients, homemade pizza with Love. Every bite delivers great taste with homemade sauce, grande cheese and a crust that has been in the family for generations. This can be one of the best pizzas in Randolph in 2019, we shall see when the final ratings come out. Just look at the photos, this Pizza speaks to you. The women have so much passion for Pizza that they have raised the bar in the Industry. I really cannot wait to get back to this place. Thank You for such a great visit. You are the Best.
… more
Alex Sharif
Amazing food have had the pizza, pizza rolls, Cheesesteak wrap and they all are amazing. The Garlic knots though are the greatest! Everyone that works here treats you like you are part of their Jersey family.
… more
James Delaney
They have always had the best pizza in my opinion around this area. Also will do simple things like me loving my cheesesteaks on garlic bread. Some other local places will not do that. Antimo’s is by far my favorite and, the dinners are excellent
… more
David Firester, Ph.D.
These folks are a staple of the community. The owners are superb human beings and they pay attention to customers’ needs. The food is great and the location is perfect for commuting families.
… more
Ken Sauter
Lousy service. They screwed up an order and, after repeatedly claiming the olives on a pizza were mushrooms, the response was that I should bring back one of the 5 pizzas, and this after ordering $120 over the holiday week. Have not gone back.
… more
Jennifer Reinmann
This was our family go to pizza restaurant. My kids loved the pizza. However, we were completely disrespected today and won’t be returning. I called in my order of two pizzas and was told I can pick it up in 20 mins. My whole family was in the car since we were coming from my daughters dance class (three young kids (6,3, and 6 mos). We had to run to the store quick before so I knew the timing would work out perfect. Well I get to the restaurant and the two ladies behind the counter are hanging around on their cell phones. They look up and ask how they can help. I gave my name that I left for the order (it had now been 30 mins since I ordered). They start looking around for my food and there is nothing there. They even opened the pizza oven to see if anything was there and it was empty. One of the ladies said, oh I haven’t made it yet. She then expected me to wait another half hour for her to cook the food! My kids have already been in the car for over an hour so this would not work, hence why I called it in ahead of time. I asked why it wasn’t ready and she claimed they had gotten busy. However, there were no other patrons there, the oven was empty and the pizza being sold by the slice was completed stocked. If they were so busy, why were they both huddled around a cell phone chatting instead of preparing our food?! Also, my order should have started to be prepared ahead of anyone who walked in after my call, isn’t that how waiting in a line works? First one ordered gets cooked first? Either way, I wouldn’t have been so upset if they took responsibly for their actions, or lack of actions, and if they offered to discount the order for my inconvenience. They didn’t do that and I left empty handed. Unfortunately I don’t appreciate my time being wasted so I won’t be returning.
… more
Susan Prisco Realtor
Stopped in for lunch. Had a salad with grilled chicken $22. It was tasty but pretty small for $22. Others in my party had salad as well and one had a burger. The burger looked delicious and was a nice size and came with fries. Atmosphere is nice and service was good, we were one of 3 tables there.
… more
Ed Witt
THE best food! Delicious sauce! Garlic Knots to die for!
… more
Angela Fernot
Owned by real Italians with amazing talent! Some of the best pizza I have had in a long time. I brought a New Yorker here who said their food was better than most of the pizza in NYC! I take that as high praise. The staff is really friendly, the restaurant is small and cozy, and the bathrooms were clean and tidy.
… more
Robert S.
Pizza is awesome here, the sauce is on point, highly recommend!
… more
… View more