Anthony’s Pizzeria has proudly served Simpsonville and the surrounding areas since 1997. Our dough is made fresh daily, hand tossed and cooked in traditional deck ovens. Pasta dishes are prepared fresh daily and always served with a smile. Come enjoy a meal at Anthony’s!
Longtime mom-&-pop parlor in a shopping center with New York-style pizza & other basic Italian eats. Based on 737 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
655 Fairview Rd Ste A, Simpsonville, SC 29680
Phone: (864) 228-9677
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Michael Eubanks
Stay away from this place. They not only have horrible customer service, but will make you the wrong thing and then call YOU a liar. Rude staff, rude manager. If you want quality pizza STAY AWAY from here.
… more
PE Shearer
We had not been here in a little while and noticed some reviews that said this place wasn’t the same under new ownership. My grandson was heading out of town on vacation so we decided to eat dinner here the night before he flew out since he hadn’t been here since moving to S Carolina. We ordered a Hawaiian Surprise and a Margherita Pizza, both were great!!! And the service was great as well.
… more
M. A.
If I could give them a ZERO I WOULD WITHOUT A DOUBT. I ordered a LARGE cheese pizza to go (with tip 21.00). I NOTICED a large pizza on the pizza warmers. I asked how long and they said 15 to 20 minutes. I placed order at 7:52 pm. I ran to Aldi’s and back within 9 minutes (if that). That large pizza box was still on the warmer. He pulled off the ticket on it first (because lord knows how long it was sitting there) and the SO CALLED COOK/MANAGER/OWNER whatever his title is said and I QUOTE.
… more
Ileana Santos
Ordered a large fettuccine Alfredo. It was definitely not large. The sauce was bland needed more cheese or salt. Taste like it came out of a jar. Ordered an XL cheese pizza and it tasted like a Chucke E Cheese pizza. Sauce was bland and dough not crispy or thin. Many review said this was closest to authentic NY style pizza. What a lie. Best thing was the Caesar salad and the dressing tasted like it came out bottle.
… more
Jennifer Saunders
Friendly service and clean. The food is always good. I feel that the food is a bit overpriced. Most places I could purchase an entire pizza for the same price as their Pizza slice, small salad and drink special.
… more
Michelle Morgan
I had lunch at Anthony’s Pizzeria in Simpsonville, SC. There was a nice crowd, you walk in and place and pay for your order as you come in, and seat yourself. My niece and I did the lunch special. Friday’s special was baked ziti with a roll, butter and a drink. We also ordered a 16 inch meat extravaganza pizza with out Canadian bacon and an extra drink. The baked ziti was baked ziti was big enough for two, so we split that. It didn’t take long for the baked ziti to come out, and it was hot, cheesy and hot plenty of sauce. The noodles were tender and the tomato sauce was good. The pizza was also good, with plenty of meat and cheese on a very tasty crust, nothing skimpy about that pizza. Anthony’s Pizzeria was very good, and I’m looking forward to my next visit. Btw, we had to take the rest of the pizza home it was too much to finish.
… more
Debra Ferro
I’ve eaten here for years, everything always good, expect now for their antipasto salad. I don’t know wjy they changed it, the last 3 x’s I ordered it, might as well have ordered house salad, there was 3 rolled pieces of salami and cheese, 1 peppercini pepper then just sliced tomatoes, use to get cherry tomatoes, cucumber that’s it, I asked for oil and vinegar on the side, I got a cup of oil Never getting it again
… more
Shirlee Mina
Ordered pasta, chicken wrap and a spinach calzone. Picked up order and when home opened the bag. No Calzone. Instead 2 slices of what looked like somewhat pizza in grease.. nasty looking. I called and told the girl we did not receive the Calzone. She insisted we did, that she and another girl checked the package. Told me to come back in and make sure I bring back the “pizza” and then they would make the Calzone.
… more
John Bonaguro
OMG Are you kidding me? I ordered a meatball parm hero, I actually laughed when I saw it! Look, I’m from New York originally with Italian and Cherokee blood. That was No Dang Meatball Parm hero! What they gave me was a joke! Two small breadballs that they cut in have and put one tiny breadball on each side of the “hero” plus it was dry and I honestly could find the Cheese! Parm means with Cheese, plus I had to ask for more sauce. I could’ve went to Subway and got the same thing! Very Very disappointed, I want to know what happened to The Original Anthony who opened the restaurant years ago? Because these new owners are not about Food Quality!! I will never eat there again, “Sushi Burger 21 sorry for going somewhere else” Only Sushi Burger 21 from now on when I’m off my farm and in Simpsonville!!
… more
TOMMY Bryant
Friendly staff clean place. You can’t beat the 2 slices of pizza and a drink for like $7 Good pizza definitely worth the $7. You should give them a try.
… more
… View more