Local counter-serve chain that’s a take-out/delivery staple for NY-style pies & other Italian eats. Based on 72 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
200 Alter Rd # 2, Natrona Heights, PA 15065
Phone: (724) 294-2828
Photo Gallery
Reviews
crazy rabbit lady
The food is very poorly done. I’ve had pizza, sub, and last week a wrap. The wrap was horrible. My coworker had a sub and neither of us ate them. That is the last time we are getting food. The guy couldn’t even roll the wrap, one end had cheese, one end had the frozen chicken, the middle was all mayo. The ladies at the register are either always on their phones or to busy talking to wait on you. This used to be a decent gas station but has gone way down hill. I have to stop here weekly for work or else I’d go elsewhere.
… more
Lori Novak La Vette
This BP is a great place to stop for a bite to eat.
… more
Josh Prunty
Good pizza but they need to hire people who can count to 4. I asked for 4 slices of pizza. Kid thought I said 1. No I said 4. Ok and I should have checked it before I left. Open the boxes and there’s 1 slice per box.
… more
Dustin Therrien
Excellent subs, much better than the Subway that was here before. Anthony’s also has a pizza shop here, both stores are inside the BP gas station and they make it worth my time to use this BP even though I have a closer one.
… more
Keean Anderson
For a gas station pizza… its actually phucking amazing!!! Great sauce, Great toppings!! Will definitely be ordering from them again!!!
… more
Drew Berry
Anthony’s is an AMAZING place to get pizza! You wouldn’t expect to have pizza this great in a gas station!! They are very generous with their toppings and they have many specialty varieties. The breakfast pizza here is a definite, MUST TRY!!! Anytime we are in the area, we call ahead and order a few whole pizzas because our entire family are FANATICS!
… more
Matt Garger
For gas station pizza, it is amazingly good
… more
Patrick Norris
Actually one of the better pizzas I’ve ever eaten. The cheese is great. You gotta love greasy NY thin crust to like Anthony’s. Good stuff. My new favorite.
… more
Ted Burkholder
Best gas station pizza I have EVER had. With that being said, don’t let that sway you. Its actually really good pizza. Much better than a lot of regular pizza shops around.
… more
Timothy Mathews
People think I’m crazy when I say the best pizza around the area comes from a “gas station” but it seriously is the best! Love the breakfast pizza and the slices are huge. Recommend going if you have never gone before.
… more
… View more