Local counter-serve chain that’s a take-out/delivery staple for NY-style pies & other Italian eats. Based on 50 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
520 Mastic Rd, Mastic Beach, NY 11951
Phone: (631) 772-5401
Hours
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
AnneMarie Leonardi
We went here with a group of about 16 for a pre class reunion reunion. They were very accommodating. The food was great, everyone ordered something different. Our server, I believe her name was Jackie, is/was also a Floyd attendee and Anthony, the owner and a Floyd alum, were so nice. Very appreciative of our business. Would recommend them highly. I think this will be our go to place for our annual get together going forward. Please give them your business as well.
… more
robert speruta speruta
In this day and age it’s all about customer service, communication and fast and friendly service. We have ordered from home twice and the pizza order was much better than the food (lasagna )type order. This time we decided to go sit in after we helped a friend with a project and wanted to support local small business. When we are the only people who are there and walk in I would expect a little cheerful greeting and some conversation to make the customer feel welcome and wanted…not saying he wasn’t friendly but in customer service field you need to be over the top. We had the specialty slice pizza which like I said is pretty good and the place was clean and inviting. I hope he continues to do a good job with the food and is able to find some help, I heard him talking with a customer that came in that he is there 24/7 and anyone knows who has owned a business that it consumes your life as an owner hence the money that comes with it.
… more
Ward Doll
Finding a good pizza place is important. I just moved to the area. I tried a bunch of others that were near. This is my place now. Other places are edible but the pizza here is tasty. The crust is yummy. It all holds together. No excessive oil. It’s a pleasure to eat, seriously. Some pizza is like “yeah, it’s okay. I was really hungry.” This is “I kinda don’t wanna tell about it. I want to keep it for me and not crazy busy.” good.
… more
Mekhai Godley
Decided to give Anthony’s Pizza a try… ordered a chicken Parm pie and a Caesar salad. Got there after estimated pickup time and salad wasn’t ready. Someone through salad together quickly and skimmed me. Pizza looked like chicken nugget pie rather than a chicken parmesan. Definitely did not get my money’s worth.Overall 3 star experience, 3 stars and that’s generous because i’m aware that it is a new business. Hope Anthony figures things out. Best of luck!
… more
jason king
Anthony’s is absolutely amazing.. vodka pizza is fire and the stuffed mushrooms are on point. I’m hooked.. the delivery driver she is cool as hell and very friendly. I definitely recommend this place for delicious food and friendly people
… more
John Aumock
Ordered a pie with half sausage.
… more
tracy_ mancini1012
OMG we went there last night and got an eggplant Parm an it was fresh cut an fried an the most delicious one I have had in years (better than mine or my grandmothers). I will definitely be going back for this an can’t wait to try everything else he makes❤️. TRY THEM YOU WON’T BE DISAPPOINTED!
… more
Kevin Copan
Conveniently located near family and THE BEST Fing PIZZA I’ve had on my trip! I was thrilled to have an argument with my mother that this place is definitely better than Florida pizza.
… more
baruch rachamim
Very nice family restaurant. Good food, great portions, reasonable prices. Best french fries ever. Manager is a prince.
… more
Eric Merckling
Best tasting pizza in Mastic/Shirley period. We had the 2 pies and garlic knots. Absolutely love the taste of the sauce.
… more
… View more