Local joint serving pizzas, pastas & other red-sauce classics in casual digs with outdoor seating. Based on 483 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
8809 Mitchell Blvd #4407, New Port Richey, FL 34655
Phone: (727) 372-1663
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8:30 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
12–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 12–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Spencer Freiman
Service was amazing. We ordered the 30” pizza it did not disappoint. The crust was crispy and one of the best pizzas I have had in Florida and I don’t even really like pizza. The chef came to the table a true Italian guy who knows how to make a pie. Will be back again when we visit New Port Richie again!
… more
Willing Vessel
GOOD garlic knots are very hard to come by!!! I’d know because I love them so much and have been on a mission to find a place that has delicious ones since relocating to the area. I’d never been to nor heard of Anthony’s before visiting recently. I have to say, the knots were very good and the marinara was too!!! I ordered 1/2 dozen because I was skeptical but after trying them I wished that I had gotten a dozen. We now know for next time, 6 knots just won’t do it.
… more
David Alexander
We tried this restaurant because we wanted something Italian… We tried 4 dishes between the 5 of us and every dish was excellent. The waitress Meadow was very attentive and sweet natured… Making this a very enjoyable dinner.
… more
Sandra “LadyBlue” Duquette
So decided we’d take my brother in-law out for his birthday, we chose Italian and oh the place was detailed with NY photos. Wouldn’t you know it him & my sister live in Queens, NY. The food was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS and mouth watering. We started with the muscles in a white wine sauce, add some garlic knots and I had the salmon garnished with a white butter sauce and mandarin oranges yum the portions were enough for 2-3 people. Pls if your in the mood for authentic Italian food, this place is a must folks. Bon Apetit’
… more
Lisa Lutz
They delivered the wrong pizza. Then didn’t want to deliver the new one and wanted the old one back. The new one finally got delivered and it’s burnt , So be aware they might give old food to you
… more
Luanna Albrecht
Loved this place. Went with a friend after a movie and was the perfect end to our day. The music, wine, food and service, thank you , Meadow, all excellent! We both had the lasagna and the ABSOLUTE BEST I have every had. Salad and bread top notch. Will definitely go back! Highly recommend!
… more
J SCH
First bad experience with delivery. Called Saturday night, placed an order, web site warned 45-50 minutes. After 90 minutes, called twice and was hung up on, could tell it was very busy, 45 minutes later the food came. It was the wrong pizza and the food was cold. Very disappointing. Love this place otherwise, wont be doing delivery again though. Time to hire some help if business is that good.
… more
Barbara Mendes
This review is because of the pizza (which we could not eat and had to throw away); the owner never returned several phone calls and Rosa the Manager would not refund the money but promised a credit of $23.49. Although hesitated to go back, we attempted to use the credit 2/11/23 and was told there was a note in the system that they could not take our order. The issue was: ordered a deluxe Pizza substituting the pepperoni for meatballs. Pick up on time but Pizza still wasn’t ready. Took the pizza home and dough undercooked, veggies undercooked and meatballs were ground beef that looked like dog food and tasted terrible. See photo. Stay away. Poor management and questionable food quality to say the least.
… more
Mr Scott’s Business
This pizzeria restaurant has a nice NYC vibe and I appreciate the tribute to the Twin Towers! The Sicilian Deluxe I think it’s called with all the meat to satisfy the pickiest of eaters was my choice and a traditional pepperoni for the kids and a chicken parmigiana hero for the Mrs, we were all very impressed and pleased! I recommend this place!
… more
Ricky Bergenson
I picked up a take-out order and one of the owners, a female with a heavy accident was right outside the main entrance smoking a cigarette. I asked her if she could step away because I have stage four lung cancer that I acquired from secondhand smoke and told her that it burns my lungs. She said oh OK and whatever and she continued smoking. When I left, I advised her that I managed restaurants for 50 years and never allowed my employees nor would I smoke at the main entrance to a restaurant that I was responsible for. Also, the food was half rate and the service I received from the staff was nonexistent in picking up my order. I saw about 10 employees and it took them 10 minutes to even acknowledge me. I will not return here again.
… more
… View more