Anthony’s Italian Restaurant Menu – Petersburg, WV

Type : Italian restaurant

Location : Petersburg, WV

Based on 54 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.6 stars. Price $$

Anthony's Italian Restaurant 26847

Address:
330 Keyser Ave, Petersburg, WV 26847

Phone: (304) 257-2222

Website:

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Bryan Henchey
The service is always excellent here and the prices are great for what you get. When the food is good it’s great; however, they are somewhat inconsistent in terms of quality. There are times where the sauce that accompanies meals is scorched or where dishes are cooked differently. Overall though, their food is usually good.

… more

Jalane Reed
Very disappointed. We stopped in on April 14 around 12:40. There were only 2 tables occupied. We placed our order and our drinks came right out. And then we waited……and waited………and waited. The waitress finally came over after 30 minutes and apologized for the delay stating that they only had 1 cook and that our food should be out shortly. So we waited some more. After about another 15 minutes, and food being delivered to a table that came in and ordered well after we did, we decided that we’d wasted enough time. I went up to the register to cancel the order and was told that “it should be out in no more than 15 minutes”. I told them to just cancel the order and that I would pay for the drinks and nothing more. We have eaten there in the past and both food and service were very good then. We will not be back.

… more

Cindy Abramowicz
The food and service here is very good. I’ve found on numerous occasions that the owners and staff go out of their way to accommodate us – they even fixed us food after closing time (we were exhausted that night from moving, so they really saved the day for us!). I especially like their cheesesteaks and pizzas – they will even make you a thin crust pizza if you request it. I haven’t tried much off the other foods served here as i already know what i like They also deliver. This has become one of our go to restaurants.

… more

Jerry Adkins
This place was amazing. The food was very good and nicely priced. The staff is very friendly and accommodated our special request perfectly. The Stromboli was incredible. We didn’t order the spaghetti and meatballs but the table next to us did and it looked fabulous. It will be my next order for sure. Can’t wait to go back!

… more

Seth Pratt
Good food and prices. I would recommend asking for pizza to be cooked well as my onions needed more time or have them sliced thin. Had a group of 10 stop in 45 minutes before closing and they handled us well.

… more

Justin Wind
My wife and I stayed at the Harman North Fork Cottages (about 15 minutes south) and ordered delivery from here. We were so thankful it was one of the few places that delivers to the cabins and the food here is amazingly good. We ordered a large cheese pizza, two orders of spaghetti and meatballs (they came with salads and bread). The portions were generous, the food was delicious, and the prices were reasonable. If I were a local I would make this place my spot, but since I’m an out-of-towner, next time I’m around I’ll be eating here.

… more

Elizabeth Schultz
All around decent reviews. The pizza is thin so either one likes it or they don’t. Everything I have ordered has been good. I usually get the special steak sub and fries or onion rings. Clean restautant.

… more

Mary Smith
Delicious food, perfect service and very reasonably priced. We were a huge crowd and they handled all of the confusion wonderfully. You can really taste that everything is freshly made.

… more

Chris Nelson
We ordered at about 4:20 and order our food took till 5 to get the food the wait staff had to come tell my wife that what she wanted they were out of and they havent had truck in a while the table next to us was the same thing she settled for the baked ziti it was very bland and had no taste she only had a few bites of. the pasta that i got was not completly cooked and nither was it in the baked ziti idk if this is how it always is here but on new years eve it sucked really bad we will not be coming back here

… more

Josh Johnson
The staff is friendly and attentive, food is decent, not 5 star if we’re going to be perfectly honest though. The value is great, lots and lots of food, much better than Fox’s!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions