Based on 258 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
Address:
62 W Pleasant Ave, Maywood, NJ 07607
Phone: (201) 843-5033
Website: https://www.angelospizzamaywood.com/?utm_source=gbp
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Surendhar
We ordered a large large pizza pie today from Angelo’s it was horrible. Pizza was half baked and veggies are raw breaded chicken was not cooked, very little cheese.They charged 20+ dollars for this pizza pie. This was my first time so i wanted to let them know my feedback in phone and there was no proper response so writing this review. It was a total disappointment…
… more
Kathy Tomlin
Remembered this pizzeria from my childhood and after moving back to the area couldnt wait to share with my family all the good food and memories. Well the first time we ordered it was fantastic! Just like I remembered it ! But since then we ordered at lunchtime and got our 6 in 1 hero’s with oil vinegar and get this mayonnaise? So disgusting? Couldn’t bear it. And now on a Monday night ordered pizza and hero’s again. The tomatoes in the sandwich were all the end pieces and the lettuce was brown. Gross. Wait and best yet one slice meat each and one slice of cheese. Really really super disappointed!!!!!!!how cheap and who’s in charge of kitchen at these times. ? Very inconsistent. Will never order from again!!!!!!!
… more
Jelly
Sloppy, undercooked and no flavor.. I don’t understand the hype
… more
Lewis Neuman
My family has been buying eggplant pizza from Angelo’s for more than 40 years and we have never been disappointed, that is until last night. The pizza tasted like it was an old readymade plain pie that had been warmed up after some eggplant had been put on it. I can’t tell for sure if that is what we received, but I don’t know if I would be happier if I learned that the pie had been made freshly, but it tasted like it was a warmed up readymade.
… more
Mauresa Walker
Ordered once as I am relatively new to the area and was trying to support local. Pizza was “aight” not bad at all taste was ok but crust was burnt could not enjoy. Veal cutlet hero- veal was dry no salt or seasoning. Steak fries were dry/a bit burnt and portion small which turned out not to be a bad thing.
… more
Joseph Koppinger
Great customer service, very respectful. Best pizza I ever had in my life! 10 min or less if you order take out, deliveries are very fast. Fresh ingredients every single day. Great dine in with beautiful tables and backgrounds. When you walk in you feel like your family. Very nice!
… more
Matteo
Angelo’s has been around Since 1963 and has proven to be a contender in the Pizza business for 58 years. That tells you their doing it right and keeping customers happy with what their menu has to offer. from A-Z whether it’s a lunch or Dinner, you won’t be disappointed. I’m in there quite a bit over decades, and calling ahead is key to fast service. Start out by trying your type of Pie, and see for yourself. I know IMO, I don’t hesitate if I’m craving Pizza, all I do is use my Bluetooth while driving, place my order and by the time I get there it’s waiting for me, Hot. Thank you! Angelo’s for your dedication in serving Maywood & the surrounding area. -Mateo
… more
Ann Marie Oconnell
So we typically go to this Restaurant to order our pizza and it’s always so good, I never go anywhere else, but… we ordered dinner tonight and the chicken sandwich I ordered was an epic fail! It was supposed to be a chicken cutlet hero with FRESH mozzarella and balsamic vinegar, well it came with no cheese and chix tenders that we’re definitely frozen and old with no balsamic. Ok, so I’m not sure we will go back, bummer bc the pizza is great! Thanks for the bread sandwich!!!!
… more
Vanessa Canosa
We have ordered pizza from here on several occasions and do like the pizza, however their subs/heroes are not appetizing at all. We ordered two different subs- one chicken/CLT and one sausage/SBO. The chicken sub did not taste good and the sausage sub had a plastic taste as if the ingredients had been frozen and re-heated in a plastic container.
… more
A.C.
Terrible service. Never again. I work up the street at HackensackUMC Fitness and Wellness. Sunday Nov. 3rd was my front desk staff meeting. We ordered 5 pies for 7PM at 1PM. The pies came 45 minutes late leaving my staff member waiting at the door missing a meeting. We were on a conference call so we couldn’t eat… Pies were cold. We never received a receipt. When we went to the pizzeria to get a receipt their excuse was “we were busy” …… Very nice. Great customer service.
… more
… View more