Old-school, unadorned counter-serve preparing pizza, pasta & subs for dine-in, delivery or takeout. Based on 572 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Drive-through ✔️ No-contact delivery ✔️ No dine-in
Address:
5450 E Livingston Ave, Columbus, OH 43232
Phone: (614) 866-7827
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 1–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Eric Duhs
Very good food and reasonably priced. Pepperoni pizza, very good. Works pizza, very good. Italian sub, very good. Antipasto salad, very good. Menu is plentiful. I would rate the food well above the national chains.
… more
Carrie Knapp (fluffyBNY)
Not only is it fresh ingredients put together in a delicious home style recipe, but it’s all affordable, and the super cute guy with the tattoos, is a real customer service star! Spot on attention to detail, anticipation of guests needs and upselling so smooth, you’ll always enjoy every course of this meal, including a sweet treat for dessert! The wonderful lady in fashion forward apparel who packed up my to go order saw to it that I felt as welcomed as a family member! Taking such care to make sure I had everything I’d need, even small plates, to share with, and the correct dressing for my crisp side salad. Five star!!
… more
Andrew Lowry
Pizza has always exceeded my expectations, worth checking out if you live in the area.
… more
terrell robinson
Ordered a supreme pizza and veggies was raw. Ordered a Philly steak pizza and it was terrible, It came drenched with A-1 steak sauce. Should have read ingredients I was expecting a white sauce like every other pizza place has on there Philly steak pizza.
… more
Amber Dishman
My family and I tried Angelina’s Villa, it was me and my bf’s 1st time and our kids had it before and loved it so we gave it a try and they were right!! This is really delicious, flavorful pizza. It had some kind of delicious garlicky flavor coating the top of the pizza, The crust was crunchy and cooked perfectly, the sausage was flavorful with a kick of spice i really loved it, the onions were sweet and their sauce is one of our new favorites, it wasn’t too tangy or too sweet it was perfect. Pepperoni and the cheese were very delicious and we will definitely be back… like allot!! Also the cookies were sooooo soft, we got chocolate chip and oatmeal rasin and they were absolutely delicious and did not make it home nor did the pizza and between the 4 of us we demolished the whole 16inch in about 15 min.
… more
Tantece Trotter
I recently went to Angelina’s Villa and I been going here for over 15 years the service was beyond horrible… I ordered 20 wings and they gave me all drums not flats and refused to make my order right!!! The disrespect was beyond me… and to add insult to injury she said I would have to pay an additional $1.50 to get flats and drums … it’s safe to say they lost a loyal customer of years over something that could’ve been resolved ♀️
… more
Nacho Nacho Man
Very good food, and always hot and fresh. Love the pizza, lasagna l, cheese sticks and salads. Everything is very good. Best pizza place on the east side and one of the best in Columbus
… more
Brittaney Barnes
My family has been coming for years! Convenient, affordable, and of course delicious! We always get a pepperoni pizza or two and those yummy chocolate chip cookies. I love all the updates that happened, even during COVID. I especially love the new pull-up pick up window.
… more
Eddie Grosso
I like the wings. You can choose all flappers if you like. That’s rare! Just wish there were more flavors to choose from. And a $1.50 per ranch packet, is a bit pricey. Should come with at least one ranch, depending on order size. Pizza is good fresh, but not so much, left over. Overall, not bad
… more
Kayla W
Placed an order for the Philly cheese steak pizza and it was the worst pizza I have had. One it was burnt, two the sauce was A1 instead of marinara (which I went back and looked and it’s suppose to be A1 so that’s my fault for not looking). Three, the wings was barely cooked and were slimy. I had to put them back in the air fryer. The people were nice, I just didn’t have a good experience with the food.
… more
… View more